What is the current state of AM5 motherboards? Is Gigabyte the only good option?

Posted by Spyrothedragon9972@reddit | buildapc | View on Reddit | 347 comments

I currently have an Asus Z370-H motherboard paired with an i5 8600k. I'm currently planning on switching to AM5, hopefully today. But I'm hung up on the motherboard. I've heard that MSI and ASUS are having stability and boot time issues. Is that still the case? If so, that only leaves Gigabyte and ASRock, but last time I checked they didn't have the best reputation.

I have 4 HDDs a SATA SSD and 2 NVMe drives. I do a lot of photo and video editing. I did buy an external HDD enclosure so I'm not super hung up on the number of SATA ports.

I thought I cared about 1220 audio but I'm having a hard time finding that. I love my music, but maybe it's time to get an external DAC and amp so I don't have to worry about motherboard audio in the future.

I only need a handful of highspeed USB ports for external storage, card readers, etc. Usually these devices won't fit next to each other because they always put the USB ports do close together but I don't think that will necessarily be an issue with any of these boards.

I don't care about built in wi-fi. I've always had a wired ethernet connection. I also don't see how 2.5gbps ethernet should matter. I don't expect my speeds to reach that within the AM5 lifespan. I've also heard that Intel 2.5gbps ethernet ports have issues. I forget the specifics.

I more of less have not found a board that has everything I want, at a price I like, so I'm just going to make some compromises so I'm not paying $300+ on a motherboard, which is more than I paid for my R5 7600.

Here are some mid-range boards I'm looking at:

GIGABYTE B650 EAGLE AX

ASUS TUF GAMING B650-E WIFI

GIGABYTE B650 AORUS ELITE AX V2

MSI MAG B650 TOMAHAWK WIFI

The Gigabyte Eagle only has 2 USB 3.2 and 1 type C 3.2 That's a bit light.

The Gigabyte AORUS has more than I'd ever need. $40 difference, whatever. Still had basic audio. I don't think any of the other differences really matter to me.

The only thing I'm seeing that the MSI has over the AORUS is the upgraded audio, but it's USB based which I heard is prone to issues. On top of the MSI boot time issue. Why would I choose that board? Unless these problems are overstated.

Does this decision making process make sense? Am I missing something important? Am I missing any good options?