What is the current state of AM5 motherboards? Is Gigabyte the only good option?
Posted by Spyrothedragon9972@reddit | buildapc | View on Reddit | 347 comments
I currently have an Asus Z370-H motherboard paired with an i5 8600k. I'm currently planning on switching to AM5, hopefully today. But I'm hung up on the motherboard. I've heard that MSI and ASUS are having stability and boot time issues. Is that still the case? If so, that only leaves Gigabyte and ASRock, but last time I checked they didn't have the best reputation.
I have 4 HDDs a SATA SSD and 2 NVMe drives. I do a lot of photo and video editing. I did buy an external HDD enclosure so I'm not super hung up on the number of SATA ports.
I thought I cared about 1220 audio but I'm having a hard time finding that. I love my music, but maybe it's time to get an external DAC and amp so I don't have to worry about motherboard audio in the future.
I only need a handful of highspeed USB ports for external storage, card readers, etc. Usually these devices won't fit next to each other because they always put the USB ports do close together but I don't think that will necessarily be an issue with any of these boards.
I don't care about built in wi-fi. I've always had a wired ethernet connection. I also don't see how 2.5gbps ethernet should matter. I don't expect my speeds to reach that within the AM5 lifespan. I've also heard that Intel 2.5gbps ethernet ports have issues. I forget the specifics.
I more of less have not found a board that has everything I want, at a price I like, so I'm just going to make some compromises so I'm not paying $300+ on a motherboard, which is more than I paid for my R5 7600.
Here are some mid-range boards I'm looking at:
GIGABYTE B650 AORUS ELITE AX V2
The Gigabyte Eagle only has 2 USB 3.2 and 1 type C 3.2 That's a bit light.
The Gigabyte AORUS has more than I'd ever need. $40 difference, whatever. Still had basic audio. I don't think any of the other differences really matter to me.
The only thing I'm seeing that the MSI has over the AORUS is the upgraded audio, but it's USB based which I heard is prone to issues. On top of the MSI boot time issue. Why would I choose that board? Unless these problems are overstated.
Does this decision making process make sense? Am I missing something important? Am I missing any good options?
Competitive-Art-5455@reddit
i had MSI Gaming and returned it, awful bios, dozens of problems and issues. From what i've seen on reddit etc. these issues are tied to all 650 msi boards. My advice is to stay away from them since they are just ignoring the issues users are reporting.
latvijauzvar@reddit
I have the gigabyte model, works well ig? 😄
GUNN4EVER@reddit
Its already been talked about quite a bit but Asrock is probably the best AM5 platform currently for price/performance/stability.
I agree that asrock used to have a bad rep but that got taken by asus for am4/am5 atleast.
The general concenssus is that the Asrock nova is the best am5 board when it comes to premium features and price, while the tomahawk is a cheaper alternative but more issues has been reported. Theres also the b650e steel from asrock for an even cheaper board.
Cheers :)
Select_Truck3257@reddit
I've heard nova has weird issues with expo, also not available to purchase now, bcoz of 9800x3d boom
Darth_Pug_@reddit
Not sure if I had a one off or not. But I will never be buying an ASRock product again. I had 2 ASRock products and they were both horrible. The 7900xtx taichi I had has an issue that I could never fix nor was support helpful.
As for the other thing is my motherboard, I have the x570 taichi and it has so many RGB issues. It has one ARGB header that is barely able to hand the 6 RGB fans I have and the mono lighting NEVER works properly and the software is always messing up. It has even blue screened my pc before. I wish I got the experience everyone here is having..
NormalPersonNumber3@reddit
I remember buying ASRock on a whim, and I was not disappointed. One of the best technical manuals I've ever read, and it helped me to optimize my hardware. I am so happy with that board, I'd definitely buy them again.
Leo9991@reddit
What kind of hardware optimizations?
NormalPersonNumber3@reddit
Things like knowing were all the PCI Express lanes are going, so I can see where the data bandwidth bottlenecks are.
For example, on my motherboard, there are many lanes that connect directly with the CPU, most of them reserved for the x16 slot commonly used for GPUs. 4 lanes are reserved for one NVME slot, and 4 are reserved for a PCI Express slot. (On mine, there is also one lane dedicated to a USB 3.0 slot that I mainly use with my VR system, though I think that's probably overkill, haha)
All remaining devices on the computer are connected to the remaining 4 PCI Express lanes, including every additional NVME slot on the motherboard. With that information, I bought a PCI Express x4 to NVME card to go into that PCI Express Slot for my secondary hard drive (Which I use to save my games to), so that 4 lanes are dedicated to my OS disk, 4 to the disk I store my games on, and the remaining 4 are for every other device connected to the computer, to maximize load speeds. I acknowledge that this kind of micro-optimization is way overkill, but I knew I was able to do that thanks to the ASRock Manual.
notmyaccountbruh@reddit
Bu the way, on PCI-E lanes: WHERE THE FUCK DID THEY GO?! On AM5 generation looks like you only get 1 slot in addition to the one used by a GPU.
teamsaxon@reddit
Not at all. Bottlenecks are not something to be ignored.
Chromium-Throw@reddit
Turning on xmp lol
not_a_llama@reddit
This guy hacks.
Kittelsen@reddit
Pretty hardcore if it's AMD though 🤭
The_Annoyance@reddit
i call my machine the wallet offender. 7950x3d/4090/64gb/8tb nvme/all noctua, seasonic psu the works... but my motherboard? basic bitch ASRock riptide b650m. zero complaints!
Nekryyd@reddit
I am still on an Fatal1ty B450 K4 from Asrock. I have gone from a 2600X/16GB/GTX 560 to 5800x3D/32GB/RTX 3070 on that board. It released in 2018, lol.
SoupIsNotAMeal@reddit
The Asrock B650 Steel Legend is better in terms of features than the B650e Steel Legend.
Cornpips@reddit
It also doesn't seem to be in stock at most retailers
CeaserAthrustus@reddit
Amazon has it
Cornpips@reddit
I see b650e and b650m, don't see he standard b650 steel legend though
CeaserAthrustus@reddit
My bad, I misread which comment you were replying to so I was referring to a different board lol
wegotthisonekidmongo@reddit
I have a asus x670-p wifi board and it has treated me well with my 7900X.
Foreloper@reddit
Could you please elaborate?
argonator1933@reddit
I went for an ASRock X670E steel Legend with my 7900x and have had zero issues for the last year and a half I've had it.
colxa@reddit
I just built a system with the Asrock X670E PG Lightning.. it has been great so far. I feel like I never see anyone recommend it though. Least expensive x670e board (even cheaper than the B650 Steel Legend). The only knock I can think of is the lack of wifi, but there is a slot included for it.
itsabearcannon@reddit
Which is exactly how it should be, IMO. Offer the native option to slot in a $20 AX210 if you need Wi-Fi without taking up a full PCIe slot, and take the $20 off the motherboard price. Best of both worlds.
NWVoS@reddit
Like that would happen.
colxa@reddit
But it did in this case. The PG Lightning is $30 cheaper than the next lowest priced x670e board. It is also cheaper than nearly all of the B650E boards as well.
Puzzilan@reddit
I just bought the x670e pg lightning and a 9800x3d. I haven't had time to build the PC yet as I use my computer for work and reusing the current case. I'm glad to see you people posting how good it is
colxa@reddit
No complaints so far. I ordered mine from Amazon and it came with an updated bios that supports the 9000 series, so I didn't have to worry about bios flashback. You made a good choice
No-Candy5493@reddit
Have the PG too, it’s nice. I couldn’t look over the price vs the features it was offering. Not many have done reviews on it either but I went for it and it was a great choice.
colxa@reddit
Yup, I'm happy with it on my new 9800x3d system. I love how many USB ports it has, that was a huge draw for me. More people should consider the board, especially over the super expensive x870e boards
hitops@reddit
I also have an X670E. Never see it mentioned either. Great value for (i believe) the most inexpensive am5 E mobo. It’s been great to me. Zero problems.
squeaky4all@reddit
Ill seconf that,i have one. No issues at all.
fullstacksage@reddit
Been using the x670e pgl for about 15 months now and have had zero issues. Highly recommend!
soonnow@reddit
I have the Asrock X670E Pro RS sitting here in my office. I bought in on a whim as it was $150 only and has what I need in terms of wifi and m2 slots.
The guy in the shop was concerned that it cannot handle a 9950x because of the power delivery. But I feel it should, should I be worried?
Spyrothedragon9972@reddit (OP)
This board isn't available anywhere in my country.
Hellknightx@reddit
Wait, really? I would expect the 'e' version to have more features.
Western_Broccoli_363@reddit
What's the issue with the x870 tomahawk?
Lord_Vendrick@reddit
there was a few cases of 9800x3d’s being burnt out on the new x870 tomahawks. I just finished my new build this weekend and went with the msi pro x870 p wifi instead as i planned on the tomahawk originally and it’s been performing well thus far with no issues.
My guess is maybe they had a bad batch.
Article about 9800x3d burnout.
mixplate@reddit
The problem was incorrect CPU insertion, not the motherboard, as seen by plastic being crushed in the socket.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qY0kEB-1MIc
Lord_Vendrick@reddit
Oh wow, I didn’t see this that’s crazy.
GolfCoyote@reddit
God ASUS is awful now, I went through 3 motherboards in a month while doing an AM4 build last year. Finally gave up and went with an MSI board and have had zero issues.
Neraxis@reddit
10 years using ASUS laptops, the only one still in good condition is the 2011 model before they went to shit and cheaped out on everything they could get away with.
As such I noticed their mobos have stupid high failure rates/issues (that most normal people would never identify as mobo issues like random bluescreens or crashes) because of literally shit quality.
Western_Broccoli_363@reddit
My 2013 Asus laptop is still going
GolfCoyote@reddit
Best thing they’ve made recently is the ROG Ally, actually a pretty rad little handheld.
limelifesavers@reddit
Yeah, I've had zero issues with my ASRock Steel Legend. It's one of the few mobos I've had that I would honestly say exceeded my expectations
robotbeatrally@reddit
In my entire 15 year history at this company I work for I have never had one asrock motherboard fail. Could be very lucky but I have had a lot of asus (circa like 5-10 years ago) motherboards fail and more recently MSI motherboards have been failing like crazy, my personal computer included. the power rail went out on the motherboard and took my 3090 with it.
GUNN4EVER@reddit
yeah, ive heard from MSI boards taking out gpus and boiling 9800X3D, not feeling super comfortable recommending tomahawk anymore. Asrock has been solid. Msi and gigabyte about the same and asus can eat dirt at this point.
Neraxis@reddit
The MSI board and 9800 was literally user error.
All_At_0nce@reddit
Where can I find the Asrocks? I have a micro center near me but don’t see a nova
GUNN4EVER@reddit
Newegg
All_At_0nce@reddit
Ok I’ll check it out. It’s so much info take in. I see 870s, 650s and it’s a little overwhelming. It’s been a while since I’ve completed a build or upgraded
Copernican@reddit
I agree about Asrock. My old Intel 5600k build was on an asrock board and it gave me headaches and required a few bios updates to get stable. But my B550 arock mobo was a huge step forward in improvement, and it sounds like they have only gotten better.
CrateDane@reddit
My old Core i5-3450 build was on an Asrock board and it was rock solid.
MisterrTickle@reddit
Same here with a Z77 Pro 3, even had UEFI which was years ahead of the mainstream.
Hellknightx@reddit
Yeah my i5-2500k was on an ASRock board and it was fantastic
AconexOfficial@reddit
Same with my i7-4770 on an ASRock board. Ran without any issues for like 8 years til I upgraded
Jaybonaut@reddit
Has Asus fixed their issues?
NoCalWidow@reddit
Well Asus issue is mostly they don't give a shit for customers and their price for what you get doesn't work. That's hard things to solve. Asrock RMA process is solid and their price for what you get is about the best in the business. So, there is that. I'd echo the person above, the PG Lightning is a good option X670E. Their X870E option is a good value for what you get, though I wish it had 10Gbe instead of 5Gbe.
https://www.tomshardware.com/pc-components/motherboards/asrock-x870e-taichi-review
Still, compared to options near it: it performs better, costs less (sometimes a lot less) and looks beautiful. BIOS is VERY solid, and you get all the features you could want otherwise.
Xaan83@reddit
ASUS' issue has been, and continues to be that they don't give a shit about the customer. So no, they haven't fixed that
NeighborhoodOdd9584@reddit
I don’t have any with my Asus board, but I’m not the pickiest lol
ddeerrtt5@reddit
I've daily driven an Asrock ab350m pro4 and an ASRock ab450m pro4.
Never had an issue, stable and good value!
DollarsAtStarNumber@reddit
I hate having brand loyalty. But ASRock is the only Mobo brand I've never had problems with out of the box.
10YearsANoob@reddit
I don't get it. They're based in Taiwan near the equator yet they used to have problems with humidity.
My guy the humidity where we're at is at 80% at the lowest. How did they manage to forget about it?
hamfinity@reddit
Which is ironic given that ASRock was a spinoff company from Asus.
Hellknightx@reddit
Yeah, honestly I've always liked ASUS so I immediately liked ASRock when they started up. They were pretty high quality and had a great price at first because they were were still an unknown brand. It's a shame their quality took a dip at some point, but I've never had a bad experience with them.
Daneth@reddit
I'm in the market for a mid-range GPU for my kid's build and ASrock is consistently the cheapest. But they also have by far the shortest warranty (1yr seriously???) so I can't bring myself to get one.
SuperZapper_Recharge@reddit
Good luck finding a Nova. I tried to buy one yesterday and they are out of stock online everywhere.
The Tomahawk is still available. I spent today reading forums trying to understand problems and for the most part, they feel sort of average.
AMD has a new chip out - the 9800 I think. It is running hot in these boards and to the best I can figure out you need a beta bios to run them. The MSI sub seems to think that a non-beta bios is going to be released soon. No word on the heat problem though.
There is this thing that hit the internet where some knucklehead managed to get his chip to catch fire. The finding was that he overtorqued his cooling solution to the chip an crushed it.
There is some evidence that 3 or 4 other people might have as well. There is a conspiracy angle that MSI is covering, but the other angle is that 4 issues out of all the board ships points towards MSI may be correct.
After those two issues I can't find anything that falls outside of normal defective merchandise.
(note: if you need wifi then do your own search. I have no need for it and ignored any threads complaining of wifi problems. In the event this board has wifi problems that may be a blindspot for me)
strictlyfocused02@reddit
Asrock B650E Riptide here and I have zero complaints. I have a Microcenter near me and I couldve gotten a deal on a Gigabyte but I went out of my way and spent more to get an Asrock board.
feedmescotch@reddit
Same here. Just recently applied the flashback to 3.10 (board had 3.01) and everything went smooth for the 9800x3d
strictlyfocused02@reddit
I just flashed 3.10 last night in preparation for a 9800x3d that arrives Thursday. This is my first Asrock board and it has been smooth sailing so far, here’s hoping the trend holds.
Ironamsfeld@reddit
Glad to see this. I’m doing a build with this board early next month as a first timer. Did a ton of research and this is the one I landed on.
deadspace-@reddit
I got the asrock x870 in a bundle with 9800x3d, Hella coil whine when I game, it's super upsetting
-Kex@reddit
You're sleeping on their more budget boards. The B650m HDV/M.2 and the B650m Pro Rs are both insanely cheap and can easily handle the 7800X3D or even the 7950x
Fun-Psychology4806@reddit
I've used asrock exclusively over the last ten years and they have been great
itsabearcannon@reddit
Love my B650E PG Riptide, and I've used their boards largely since my old Z77 Extreme4.
They also have weirdly excellent server boards, and about the only semi-affordable AM4/AM5 server boards on the market.
creatii@reddit
Have some board. Did you update bios to 3.10 and any issues?
Jeep-Eep@reddit
Nova is a bit hard to lay hands in Canada, and I need 3 PCIE ports.
GUNN4EVER@reddit
it sure is, alot of people wants it. harder to get than a 9800X3D at this point.
christenlanger@reddit
I just got a B650I Lightning WiFi for the 9800X3D and it's been nice so far.
LisaandNeil@reddit
Wedding photographers here.
Latest build has GIGABYTE B650 AORUS ELITE AX V2 and it's just fine. One reason we chose it is that it takes gen 5 Nvme in the primary slot. This meant we could put our OS and Lightroom, Photoshop etc on a very fast Nvme. There are also two other Nvme slots and a heatsink on the mobo to keep everything cool.
Transfer of files between drives is mad fast.
Can't comment on sound quality as the output goes to a Cyrus DAC, integrated amp and full size speakers anyway.
Past-Gene-1275@reddit
I have the same motherboard and it takes forever to boot. Takes like 5 minutes or it sometimes reboots because it can't load. The board is fine for gaming haven't had an issue just use to my other gaming pc booting to login within 30 seconds.
TransientEons@reddit
Sounds like it's related to the AM5 memory training. There's usually a setting in BIOS that let's it remember previous trainings so it doesn't do it on every boot.
Past-Gene-1275@reddit
I did change it to super fast boot up made no difference lol
deadlybydsgn@reddit
Memory Training is the specific setting you want to change.
Past-Gene-1275@reddit
OK let me take a look never noticed that setting
deadlybydsgn@reddit
I think "memory training" is the issue being addressed, but the actual setting is called "memory context restore" on my MSI board.
Past-Gene-1275@reddit
So I'm looking and I'm not seeing memory context restore in the settings when it's supposed to be
deadlybydsgn@reddit
I'd say to check your BIOS manual and see what they call it.
Past-Gene-1275@reddit
I just have the 32gb vengeance 6000mhz
FDrybob@reddit
Fast Boot is usually best turned off. They're referring to a setting commonly called "Memory Context Restore", which is enabled by default on some motherboards and disabled by default on others.
TransientEons@reddit
Not fast boot, memory training.
StepDownTA@reddit
Do you have a lot of USB devices plugged in? If so try removing all of them and rebooting.
If it boots quickly, then start adding them back, one device per reboot.
Past-Gene-1275@reddit
Just standard keyboard and mouse but I'll give it a try. Just odd that a brand new board is just so slow at booting. I have crucial p3 2tb nvme should be plenty fast.
Only-Maximum-888@reddit
Mine sometimes boots into windows (usually happens on first boot of the day) but then freezes and I have to manually restart. Don't really know if it's the MoBo or some other component. Have updated it to the latest BIOS but still. Apart from that, it never failed during use.
Spyrothedragon9972@reddit (OP)
How do you like your integrated DAC/amp? I have a BT20a coming from my PC, powering some Polk Speakers. But I usually use headphones because I'm talking to people on Discord often.
lpmiller@reddit
If you are asking, it's past time you just got an external dac and amp. I went that route about 8 years back and no regrets.
LisaandNeil@reddit
Honestly? It's decent sound but though the Sony integrated is built like a tank (swapped for a primare integrated that we sold as it seemed overkill for a PC desktop setting) and the Eltax bookshelf speakers are ok for their size and second hand price...the sound isn't wildly different or better than the other PC set up which has some fairly standard Logitech speakers and a sub.
leops1984@reddit
I considered getting the B650 Steel Legend, but I ended up getting this motherboard myself as it looked fairly similar spec wise and the Asrock board was a fair bit more expensive.
Hopefully it all works out.
Pitiful-Assistance-1@reddit
And yet Photoshop and Lightroom are still very slow and half the optimizations don't scale over many cores.
LisaandNeil@reddit
Probably all true, we're not PC experts, just trying to answer the specific question from a hopefully relevant viewpoint.
We tend to try and keep our PC's as long as possible and to have a certain amount of upgrade potential so having gen 5 Nvme and also DDR5 seemed sensible. No idea if the other boards listed do or don't have that. As for SSD speeds we have a Crucial T705 for OS/PR/PS and it's faster for some tasks but in normal events runs about the same speed as Samsung gen4 990 pro's. We'd have gone for Samsung for the OS if there had been an option in gen5 presented.
We have smaller files than you, 4xA9's but still large amounts of course with us both shooting. Adobe stuff runs really well now.
Pitiful-Assistance-1@reddit
That Crucial T705 is extremely fast, yes. 990 Pros are also excellent.
PuzzleheadedUnit1758@reddit
I have the Asus Prime x870-P Wifi with Ryzen 9 7900x3d and it works great.
Elitefuture@reddit
I've honestly never heard people cimpare the audio between the boards. Most people have usb or wireless headsets... if you have a 3.5mm headphones, then it may sound different. But if you really cared about audio, you'd get an external dac + amp.th
The ports can be fixed by getting a pcie card with extra ports if the price isn't too bad.
But usually the only thing people care about in a motherboard are: ram slots(4), pcie slots, m.2 slots, and a decent amount of USB ports in the back. Oh also maybe a header for USB c in the front.
kamegami@reddit
Using world-class headphones, a $2 Realtek integrated audio codec could not be reliably distinguished from the $2000 Benchmark DAC2 HGC in a four-device round-up.
Spyrothedragon9972@reddit (OP)
I thought 4 dimms of RAM wasn't handled well by current CPUs. I always hear that using 2 sticks is better than 4, assuming the same amount of total RAM.
Elitefuture@reddit
2 sticks is better. But bios updates over time is making 4 more and more stable. By the time we do need 64gb of ram, we'll probably have a new cpu and a more stable bios.
TimeZucchini8562@reddit
The chipsets themselves are limiting as well. I doubt we’ll see 4 sticks stable on a 650/670 chipset with a few exceptions.
Elitefuture@reddit
I thought the mem controller was in the cpu? Isn't there a chance that future gens would fair better?
TimeZucchini8562@reddit
Yes, but the motherboard has a part to play in it as well.
ASlothNamedBill@reddit
Ah, the future, where even lower end cpus are drawing 200w at idle and windows takes a terabyte.
Elitefuture@reddit
Amd has been using less power over the past few generations at least. I think intel is the only one that has been upping the power until there was nowhere left to go. Now intel is tuning back down too.
randylush@reddit
Intel has been pushing the power up at load, but Intel can also run very low power at idle
4514919@reddit
In what world? Are we really going to pretend that with Zen 4 AMD didn't increase the power consumption across the board only because the X3D are voltage limited?
6 core got a 40W bump, 12 core plus 30W and the 16 core SKU got a whopping 90W increase.
With Zen 5 they tried to revert back but there was basically no performance uplift so they created the Extended cTDP bullshit to boost it back up again.
Elitefuture@reddit
Fair, now that I have done more research, I was just swayed by the 9700x power consumption. The 9700x matched the 1700x and thought that they were fairly consistent. But the 7700x and 3900x are close, so they didn't really get better.
But staying consistent is still good. 1700x-9700x are all around the same power except the 5700x and 7700x. The 5700x actually used less power than the rest and the 7700x used more. So they took a step forward in efficiency, then 2 steps back with the 7000, then a step forward for the 9000.
The stagnating power consumption is good imo.
Granted, past the 8 core cpus, those 16 core cpus chug more and more power chasing the crown.
Drages23@reddit
You can't change the chip structure with bios updates. For AM5, 2 sockets will be always the best.
ParryHotter369@reddit
The blue ones are USB 3.0
Spyrothedragon9972@reddit (OP)
I guess USB 3.0 was common back in 2015?
ParryHotter369@reddit
2017 I think, i built my first pc in 2017 with a b350 motherboard which had usb 3.0 support. The local computer store did not have a case which had usb 3.0 ports so I had to look for one online.
Disaster_External@reddit
You are correct
rvdk156@reddit
The difference between the ALC892 and ALC1220 is audible on the lowest of low end hardware for untrained ears. “Most people”? According to whom? A lot of medium to high end headphones, microphones & headsets use the 3.5mm jacks. Sennheiser is one of those companies. The cheapest of the cheapest products are almost guaranteed to use USB, though.
A decent DAC/Amp starts at €90,- while a better onboard audio chip doesn’t have to cost more. I’d argue that higher-end onboard audio chips have even less distortion and latency than cheap DAC/Amps (so spending 20 more on the motherboard would be more beneficial than 50 towards a mediocre DAC).
Melbuf@reddit
i specifically went with a MSI board because it had a toslink out which is a 100% requirement for me. in addition to having the correct number of m.2 slot options
Journeydriven@reddit
Meanwhile I have mine hooked up to a denon a760h with two front channels and a subwoofer. Single player games go kinda crazy. Doesn't play well with 1440p monitors though thinks it's 1080
Fornico@reddit
I just want to know why every motherboard doesn't have a S/PDIF for audio.
Alternative_Wait8256@reddit
MSI Tomahawk b650 here and the board is absolutely rock solid. Most complaints are early firmware or user error.
LudensKekko@reddit
I have been getting pretty long boot times with this motherboard, 7700x with 2x16gb @6000MHz, has this been your experience too?
Alternative_Wait8256@reddit
No it boots very quickly. The latest bios is fast and solid.
So you have Expo and memory context restore turned on?
LudensKekko@reddit
Expo yes, MCR I haven't played with just yet. I'll definitely give it a go. Which bios version are you on at the moment? I've heard from a few peeps that the latest BIOS works, just not sure which version they mean, the MSI website is a bit confusing. Is it the latest non beta version?
Alternative_Wait8256@reddit
7D75v1K is what I'm on. Memory context restore will basically give you old school boot times. That said with the 1K bios it boots really fast even without it.
If I remember correctly the MCR setting is sometimes not the easiest to find, don't forget the search function :)
burningicecube@reddit
I have the same board, it's been great but I had to turn on memory context restore for the fast boot. Is there any downside to MCR? I have to look into updating the BIOS.
LudensKekko@reddit
I'm sorry, did you just say the MSI bios has a search function?? How have I missed this??? Thank you for the tips though, I really appreciate the help!
Alternative_Wait8256@reddit
Lol yep there is a search. :) Somewhere near the top maybe. Pretty sure you have to be in advanced mode.
And No problem! Enjoy!
BiscuitBarrel179@reddit
I have the 7700x, 2x16gb CL30/6000mts, and B650 Tomahawk combo as well. What is it you consider to be long boot times? Mine goes from cold to Windows pin screen in about 17 seconds, which to me is quite fast. However I've seen some people (on reddit) say anything longer than 10 seconds is unacceptable.
ItsRadical@reddit
I should probably check latest bios. I get around 30-50s with MCR enabled.
LudensKekko@reddit
I've been experiencing anywhere between 45 seconds to 2 minutes, which was a bit shocking coming from my previous build which felt like it had to have been maybe 10 seconds tops. Its not the end of the world for me or anything because I rarely sit and watch it start up anyway, but from what I've read online its pretty atypical for others with the same set up.
Aergaia@reddit
Yeah, I just bought one too for my 9800x3d. Had to change the power in BIOS from PWM to DC because it made my fans rev up too much, but aside from that it runs perfect
surfingforfido@reddit
Likewise, paired with a 9800x3d
Horst9933@reddit
Gigabyte is trash, e they can't even ensure future compatibility with their boards. I bought a b650 gigabyte gaming x ax and now have I to change my motherboard because it doesn't work with 9800x3d for some stupid reason.
epical2019@reddit
Asrock is the best for your money and if you can't get that then go for Gigabyte. If you can't get Gigabyte the next best is MSI but you get slightly less for your money with MSI depending on the board. I went with a Gigabyte Gaming X AX V2 and it's outstanding. I would have gone Asrock but they never had stock.
XxMC_ItchyBxX@reddit
I just built a new system with an asrock x670e steel legend and it was so hassle-free and easy. This was my first pc build. X670e steel legend, ryzen 9 7950x, 4080 super
alphabytes@reddit
can any one recommend a motherboard that can support PCIE x16 - dual 4090's?
i am planning on buying 9800x3d not sure it supports dual x16 slots
Repulsive_Meaning717@reddit
I have the tuf b650-e WiFi and it’s perfectly fine. I don’t rlly have a comparison bc it’s my first pc but I have no issues
BMWtooner@reddit
Eh, my Asus x670e-f gaming wifi has been solid since December 2022. Running my 7950X and 64Gb at 6400mt CL32 which is not easy for dual rank RAM. CPU is overclocked and undervolted substantially.
Boot times are fast if you set memory context restore in the BIOS, I'm quite happy with the board overall. The AI nose cancelling is great for gaming.
ohdannyboy73@reddit
MSI Tomahawk x870 and it is wonderful. Boot time was slow when I first got it, but that has been fixed. I'm very happy with this board so far running 7800x3d with 4070ti super.
mikey_licked_it@reddit
I just got the msi x870 tomahawk and love it so far. Build quality feels great, bios is solid. No real complaints so far and it has wifi7 which is something I wanted
NeverEndingXsin@reddit
I've got an asrock x670e steel legend paired with a 7800x3d (soon to be 9800x3d) and it's been perfect, no complaints at all.
FilthyCasual04@reddit
Why upgrade for a small increase. With some games there being a less than 5% increase in perf on 1080p.
NeverEndingXsin@reddit
To be completely honest, I don't need the upgrade and recognize that even at 1440P it may not be worth it.
The only reason I am considering it is because I can sell my 7800X3D to offset a bulk of the price and essentially get the 9800X3D for \~$200.
...I also ordered it from Newegg impulsively and before I could cancel it they had already packed it and it was too late lol
FilthyCasual04@reddit
I’m honestly waiting for the 9950x3d
NeverEndingXsin@reddit
Sheeesh I just looked it up, seems very promising but way over powered for anything I'd be doing.
FilthyCasual04@reddit
I’d like the extra cores for video compression and stuff like that. And nothing else with more cores is worth it over my 7800x3d
NeverEndingXsin@reddit
Oh for sure if you're using it for that it makes perfect sense. The 7800X3D is a true beast, I do wonder if by the time my 9800X3D comes from Newegg that I won't have already decided to return it lol
FilthyCasual04@reddit
The fact they scalped the 7800x3d to €400 and the 9800x3d to €600 here is just ridiculous. Hopefully I can sell mine for €300, and get the 9950x3d when it launches for under €700
NeverEndingXsin@reddit
I'm sure you'll be able to, it's the only reason I'm even considering keeping the 9800x3d is because I can sell the 7800x3d for more than I paid for it lol
Trooper1023@reddit
AsRock Tai Chi and TaiChi Lite. That is all.
AgreeableIncrease403@reddit
Asrock has good AM5 MBs.
AnthMosk@reddit
No mention of the AsRock Taichi here. Any particular reasons?
uses_irony_correctly@reddit
100 bucks more expensive than a nova and you barely get anything extra for those 100 bucks.
Emosaa@reddit
Probably because they're out of stock or commanding a premium rn.
Spyrothedragon9972@reddit (OP)
They're not available at my local computer store.
zymmaster@reddit
Working perfect for me.
Nosnibor1020@reddit
I've seen a couple mentions, including the current top comment. I've been MSI the past several interactions and had no issues yet and I like their bios. How is asrocks bios? I'm about to do a rehaul and considering them now too.
Dyrogitory@reddit
I started out with an ASUS PRIME X670E Pro Wi-Fi for my AM5 build. I had so many problems with it, I ended up switching to an ASRock X670E Steel Legend. No Regrets on my decision to switch.
Swimming-Solution-88@reddit
what problems? i just bought this board for my new build
_yeen@reddit
I built my PC the other day with an ASUS x670E TUF and have had literally zero issues. Same as my X570 TUF before it.
When AM5 first came out I heard a bunch of bad stuff about every manufacturer so idk if things got resolved or what.
My only real problem was the 45s BOOT time but that’s just how AM5 works and once I enabled the setting to remember memory training values, it hasn’t had any issues since and boots super fast
Swimming-Solution-88@reddit
thanks, i make sure to update the bios first thing and hope everything goes smooth
Dyrogitory@reddit
I built my rig over a year ago so the XPO feature was super unstable. Constantly crashing and having to reconfigure everything. The last straw was when my GPU would only allow one monitor to display. Configuration didn’t matter, which slot didn’t matter. Only one monitor lit up. So, I moved to PCIe #2 and both monitors worked fine. I wanted to send it back but have read so much bad press on ASUS, I just keep it in my closet.
Thermaltake Core C71 full tower AMD Ryzen 9 7900 X Radeon 7 Series RX 7900XT ASRock X670E Steel Legend ASUS PRIME X670E Pro Wi-Fi G.Skill Trident Z5 Neo RGB, DDR5 6000 2x32 WD Blue 1TB SA510 M.2 (Gen3) SK hynix Platinum P41 (Gen 4) Corsair RM850X Gold
luiz_victor@reddit
This is very expensive board.
Dyrogitory@reddit
I didn’t skimp on the MB because I figured I will have it for a long time.
Swimming-Solution-88@reddit
thank for reply, bought it of amazon, so if i had any problems like you will send it back
RiffsThatKill@reddit
The steel legend just looks too clashy for my rig, otherwise I'd get it.
TwixtTwo@reddit
From a failure perspective they’re mostly the same, so I’d look mostly at features. That said, the following is all anecdotal from my experience building custom PCs through Geek Squad:
I’ve put that Aorus board into probably 30+ computers over the past year and had only one come back with issues - and I’m pretty confident that’s because the client was messing around with overclocking. It’s very popular from a price for performance perspective, though it’s not as “stylish” as some other boards.
I’ve had bad experiences with MSI boards personally, and that board in particular has a mixed reputation, but I’ve only seen it outright fail twice and once saw a WiFi chip issue. Not completely terrible.
ASUS boards have a bad reputation at the moment because of the overvolting issues last year and their poor (read terrible) warranty support, but I’ve only seen one DOA so far out of maybe 15-20 units.
Personally I’d avoid the Eagle when the Aorus is right there. You can keep a good AMD mobo for a long time and you never know when you’re going to need more ports.
Scalarmotion@reddit
That's one way to put it lol, do they still have that "feature" where the motherboard automatically installs it onto your PC on its own like a rootkit?
JohnYiu@reddit
you can disable it on BIOS though
TwixtTwo@reddit
Yes.
ItchySackError404@reddit
I have experience in building custom PCs as well and I agree that when it comes to a failure rate standpoint, all of the common brands are about the same with rarer, isolated issues that have been fixed.
When it comes to broad range compatibility for networking, overclocking, heavy peripheral use and general temperature control, it's hard to beat MSI and Gigabyte.
If I remember right, Gigabyte is the brand that puts the most USB ports in the rear IO, with the Aorus line putting like 11 or 12 in there.
MSI probably has the best BIOS for tuning and finding settings.
TwixtTwo@reddit
Thanks for the backup. Not sure why I get downvoted for speaking from experience. Maybe I insulted someone’s pet brand or something.
Emosaa@reddit
YouTubers and pc people online are currently really in love with AsRock right now and the other brands have had hits to their reputation. That's how a lot of people get their info these days.
I'd have loved to buy an AsRock Nova this week, but went with gigabyte simply because they're in stock lol
TwixtTwo@reddit
ASRock used to be actual garbage but yeah, at the moment their reputation is good. Thing is OP didn’t ask about them, and unfortunately Best Buy doesn’t sell them either so I can’t comment.
Rilandaras@reddit
While not extensive, I've built probably around 20 PCs at this point, from a dirt-cheap office machine to a pimped out $5K machine. The only failed MB has been a Biostar around 10 years ago and it was dead on arrival, so I just got a replacement from the shop.
ItchySackError404@reddit
Biostar is a really uncommon brand where I live. You'd pretty much have to order one overseas
Spyrothedragon9972@reddit (OP)
Is the fact that the drivers don't come pre-installed or on a USB means I'd have to make my own install media?
What makes Gigabyte's BIOS "meh"? Is the interface not the most user friendly or does it lack some functionality?
Any_Perspective8716@reddit
Gigabyte has a app Called gigabyte control center, download That one, and all the drivers and apps Will Come from That app, works quite Well, except i cant delete the option of downloading McAfee as a option. The bios interface has Come a long way from am4 b550 to am5 b650,
Spyrothedragon9972@reddit (OP)
I guess they got paid to force McAfee with every update? That's annoying.
TwixtTwo@reddit
You’ll want to download at least the WiFi drivers from Gigabyte’s website and put them on a flash drive, unless you have an Ethernet connection available which not everyone does.
As for the BIOS, there’s no lack of features but it’s not the most user friendly. The real thing I was commenting on is Gigabyte’s “Command Center” app which provides driver updates and RGB management. It’s a little glitchy and similarly isn’t as user friendly as its competitors, and much less flashy. Gigabyte tends to be very function before form.
kiquetzal@reddit
ASRock B650 Pro RS over here and so far it looks really good. Only thing is that the WiFi Card slot (M.2 E-Key) is built directly below the graphics card and I guess this is the reason why my BT and WiFi are not all that great. Solution is quite simple though, there are more than enough PCIe slots left with lots of free space.
One thing though: I made sure that all my parts were listed in the QVL. Sure enough, first boot and each one to follow were buttery smooth. I expected the motherboard to train the RAM for like 10 minutes in the first boot as is often reported but nope, the first boot gave me the UEFI menu within a minute. As a first time builder that was really a great feeling 😅
I also liked that there are more than enough USB ports, lots of possible SSD connectors and no shared PCIe lanes.
Chrisbee76@reddit
I have been using nothing but ASrock boards for the last 10 years (5 builds), and have nothing bad to say about them at all.
Humble_Tension7241@reddit
I had gigabyte for AM4 and had nothing but problems (I know different platform) but got an ASUS proArt this go around and it’s been flawless even though I hear non-stop hate for asus. Honestly, it’s just a lottery. Sometimes you get lucky.
Accomplished-Ad-3597@reddit
I got the B650e Aorus Master, couldn't be any happier with how it's performing so far. It's a bit of an over kill due to 5 M.2 slots, but it's an amazing board for me.
tspamm3r@reddit
I have AORUS Gigabyte x670 and it was pretty fine until Realtek 2.5gb started acting up (disconnects). I am planning to swap mobo for x870E next year
aragon_1399@reddit
I have a B650 tomahawk and it seems to be working well so far (tbf this is my first ever build so I don’t really have a reference to compare it to for speed, etc.)
Libra224@reddit
I like the ASUS better for the bios software,
Ive never had any issue with any brand in the last 20 years, I’ve used and built countless pcs for people with different MBs
Caspid@reddit
Gigabyte B650I ITX was the only one with 3 M.2 ports. Worth it.
LuckyTwoSeven@reddit
Gigabyte? Absolutely not. The state of AM5 MOBO’s is MSI all day everyday or bust.
GreenKumara@reddit
You'll hear horror stores from all the big name companies.
EirHc@reddit
I have an MSI X670E TOMAHAWK. I'd say it's a pretty good mobo except boot times are a little slow. That said, there's been a firmware update in July that says:
And I haven't updated since February... reading in the forums, people are saying it get's the boot times down to 30 seconds, which is probably acceptable-ish range for any DDR5 system. Right now it's probably over a minute for me. If I'm turning on my computer from cold, I press the power button and then go grab a coffee or something. But I'm probably gonna go home and update the firmware now that you got me thinking about it.
LRH82@reddit
Try changing the Memory Context Restore from Auto to Enable. My B650 Tomahawk boots in 23 seconds now.
EirHc@reddit
Ya after the bios update and changing the setting I boot faster for sure. Still feels like an eternity compared to my I7-6700k computer I built like 8-9 years ago that booted in like 3-5 seconds.
EirHc@reddit
Might try it. I remember back when I first got my computer built, I was having a lot of issues with stuttering and 1% lows that were really pissing me off, and at the time I was sure it was the memory so I was trying all kinds of things, undervolting, and a bunch of stuff I can't remember off the top of my head.
Because of that, I steered far clear of enabling memory context restore.
But in the end I figured out it was actually more to do with my GPU settings. Something like the shader buffer size I wanna say? It presented as memory bus choke / cpu choke, but that was because my machine wasn't optimized for making the most out of my vram. Once I fixed that in my Nvidia control panel, it almost completely eliminated the stuttering in the UE5 engine game I was playing. Like even on first load it was pretty much completely solved.
After that whole ordeal I was so sick of looking at my bios screen, I haven't gone back to adjust anything. But it's been like 7-8 months now, I think I'm over it now. I'll probably do a bios update tonight and enable memory context restore.
Junior-Particular-24@reddit
You'll be fine with any of those boards. I've been building my own pc's since the late 90's and every brand has a few lemons here and there. IMO the more important decision is the retailer. Stick with someone who has a good return policy and hopefully has decent packaging. Three years ago I ordered my asus x570 prime pro from Amazon and they shipped it in a bubble envelope. Luckily it's still working. When I order from Newegg, I always order a smaller item with a motherboard and they both go in a larger box with *some* packing materials to keep things from moving around too much.
FitCress7497@reddit
Don't get a b650 from MSI. We have 4/5 b650m mortar (both wifi and non wifi ver) with sudden CPU debug light and won't ever post again. Changed mine to a B650M HDV from asrock and it runs perfectly. I won't ever buy any board from MSI again
surfingforfido@reddit
My MSI 670e tomahawk has worked flawlessly, paired with a 9800x3d.
adultfemalefetish@reddit
Have you had heating issues? I and many other people seem to have issues with high temps. I saw another user say that he swapped boards and the issue resolved.
surfingforfido@reddit
Nope, been at 50c while gaming with a NZXT AIO. No issues thankfully.
adultfemalefetish@reddit
Interesting. I've got an h170i elite cappelix xt and I even cleaned and reapplied paste, updated the bios, and im still having issues
surfingforfido@reddit
What’s your temps been at? Could be a bad chip too
adultfemalefetish@reddit
It idles at 45-50 and then even under a very light load (25ish%) it'll jump to 85+
Considering taking the bundle back to microcenter tbh cause I'm fucking sick of this shit already
deadlybydsgn@reddit
I got an MSI B650 wifi in a MicroCenter deal. The bluetooth got weird after a windows update and I haven't been able to get it to work consistently since, but at least that's a cheap workaround with a dongle.
Everything else has been fine, but I can understand that may not exactly be the endorsement folks want. FWIW, MC now sells the same bundle with an Asus TUF mobo.
SSmashPoyo@reddit
I got a R5 7600 a month ago, and using a MSI pro b650m-a wifi. And have no problems with it. For what I read the R5 max frequency for the ram is like 5200.
Neraxis@reddit
ASUS is trash.
smackythefrog@reddit
I went with the Tomahawk. I think it had the most ports compared to other B650 boards so it meant a good number of my peripherals would be able to be plugged in while still leaving room for the occasional peripherals. Wireless mouse and keyboard and game controller receiver vs an external SSD, and still having plenty of room for all of that without having to unplug anything.
It can get messy in the back with all the ports, though, if you use them all.
Decoy_Barbell@reddit
Gigabyte will never get a dollar from me after the cracked PCB fiasco.
Spyrothedragon9972@reddit (OP)
Hasn't every manufacturer had big issues at some point?
Decoy_Barbell@reddit
Yes, that's not the point though. Gigabyte deliberately denied any wrongdoing and placed all the blame on the consumers, denying RMA's and refunds. They can eat shit for that.
vaurapung@reddit
My gigabyte aourus elite rev1.2 was doa. Or the 7600 I ordered was doa. But the pc couldn't pass post and was stuck on the cpu check.
I eneded up pleading with Amazon. To return my ram and cpu because the late motherboard shipment made my other parts past return date. Went to a micro center about an hour away to get the 399 asus tuf gaming with 7600x3d and 32gb of ram. Booted with no problems and running 5200mhz on the gskill flare ram. Gonna try to tighten the timing on it since I'm not pushing past the rated cpu speed with my ram.
_Rusty_Axe@reddit
I have been using an MSI B650 Tomahawk Wifi since July of 2023 and have not had any problems with it. It did have the slow boot time issue when it was new, but later BIOS updates have improved that significantly.
You can also change two BIOS settings to help that, from the BIOS advanced settings menu:
My BIOS time shows as 16.6 seconds in Task Manager with those settings. I really don't notice boot times.
If that's a big deal, though, look elsewhere.
LudensKekko@reddit
May I ask which BIOS version you're on? Been having a similar experience with slow boot times, unsure if my BIOS is recent enough or not.
_Rusty_Axe@reddit
I am on the current BIOS - 7D75v1L1, release date 2024-10-21. I have a 9800x3d CPU I am planning to eventually get around to installing to upgrade the 7700x currently installed, and that is the recommended BIOS for the 9800x3d.
Whenever you update the BIOS, it resets all of your custom settings to defaults. So I had to go back in to enable the XMP profile, set Memory Context Restore and RAM Power Down Enabled back to "Enabled."
In Windows 11 Task Manager on the "Startup Apps" screen, I am showing 16.6s BIOS time.
When the MB was new, that was more like 45s.
But I think it was one of the BIOS updates from later in 2023 that really helped and got it down under 20s. From looking at my download history, seems I must have liked the 7d75v1A BIOS from 11/21/23 since I didn't have any newer BIOS update files downloaded until recently. I know I have not updated it in quite a while until I put the newest one on for the planned 9800x3d upgrade.
I have not recently tested the BIOS boot times when leaving those two BIOS settings to the default "Auto."
DoctorWhoSeason24@reddit
All I can speak of is about my personal experience but I've had an MSI Tomahawk B650 paired with a 7800x3D + 4070TiSuper for four or five months now and I couldn't be happier with it, works like a charm and no issues. I got it over theother models you mentioned mostly because it was a lot cheaper around the time I got it.
LudensKekko@reddit
Have you been experiencing long boot times as well? Mine have been anywhere between 45 sec to 2 minutes, but I've heard others getting much quicker times, I'm unsure how.
Any_Perspective8716@reddit
Gigabyte B650 Aurus ax ice user here, it is a great board. 3 minor things to point out,
the 3,2 USB Cable to the front panel connector is right under the 4th ram, and is Odd looking at best.
When using the gigabyte control center for speed of fans, when changing from a quit low speed settings to a high speed settings and back Again, once in a While the fans Will fluctuate before setting properly, having changing from nzxt fans to corsair fans, issue persist.
The gigabyte control center wont let you delete the mcAfee virus program as a download. Same with amd app. So if There is a app you dont want to download. Every time a update comes up, it Will try to bundle mcAfee together with the rest.
Spyrothedragon9972@reddit (OP)
That McAfee thing sounds annoying AF
Any_Perspective8716@reddit
Thats why i point it out because it is a thing a potential buyer should know
Hi_Im_Col@reddit
What boot issues? I got a new am5 pc and it seems it takes so long to boot to bios screen, is this what you’re talking about?
lucker1515@reddit
I have a MSI x870 tomahawk paired with a 9800x3d and it's pretty solid, I got them together as part of a bundle since it was the only way to get my hands on the CPU.
My RAM is some Corsair Samsung die garbage and is the only thing that has given me problems (It will not post at 6000mhz). I had an issue with posting early on when I was messing with memory context restore and power down settings in the bios but I'm confident it's the RAM and not the board. I've flashed the bios from an M.2 drive and cleared CMOS due to the above RAM issues and it has always booted no problem.
One other note, I've heard the realtek wireless chip on this board might be a bit buggy so if you aren't running wired I would avoid. I disabled mine in device manager so I can't comment personally.
laffer1@reddit
I just did a msi b650 build. It’s stable. It does boot slowly. I usually buy Asus, asrock or gigabyte motherboards but it was a good deal. I also had some bad experiences with asrock so that was a hard pass this time. Last one killed my cpu
gblawlz@reddit
I have an MSI x870 pro paired with a 9800x3d and it's been great. Bios is very nice. It "just works" so far. Tforce 48gb 7200 running at 6200 cl30 buildzoid timings. Stable first try. Coming from a 13700k with a gigabyte z790, that thing was a pos. Super terrible bios, very unstable for the dumbest things. I personally won't touch gigabyte for a long time
derickhirasawa@reddit
[quote]
Am I missing something important?
[/quote]
Possibly ...
If you plan on overclocking or a High watt CPU in the future, or if you're building for stability and now BSOD, then DRM phases are important.
Look at the VRM phases for the motherboards.
They will be a number like 8+2.
The first number is the number of phases for the CPU.
For less heat, smooth power at high wattage, and less vDroop, higher numbers of better quality VRM phases are better.
If you plan on overclocking or a High watt CPU in the future, then DRM phases are important.
If you only plan on a cheap low powered or possibly unstable system the you don't need to overspend on VRM's you won't need and you can spend your money on something else.
If motherboards seem to be all the same to you, then get the one with the most VRM phases.
_OVERHATE_@reddit
Unrelated to the motherboard itself but as per data, most of the entry level ~100$ DAC/AMP Combos or stacks completely shit on even the most elite and expensive of the motherboards built in audio chips.
Both in power output, transparency and quality of the day chip and output configurations (single 3.5mm vs 3.5/4.4/6.3 jacks) plus in many cases support for true balanced output and much lower noise floor.
Basically, never, EVER spend money on a motherboard because "better audio". It's never worth it.
Liesthroughisteeth@reddit
MSI, Gigabyte and Asrock in no particular order.
m00dawg@reddit
I was finally looking at switching from AM4 but, oof, especially with X870, I've been largely unimpressed. Largely because motherboard makers have too much crap that I don't want (Wifi) which pushes out features I do want (more than 1-2 PCIe slots laid out in a sensible way). It's weird to me that X570S has more features, at least for me, than most X870 boards I've found seem to have.
I also watercool so when you add the whole heatspreader being kinda garbo, it's just a lot of cost and some tradeoffs just to get into the platform. Certainly the CPU performance is there but oof.
Not all of this is AMD's fault but some of it is. I know it doesn't make sense due to assembly line optimizations surely, but it'd be nice if AMD just offered delided versions of the CPUs out of the box so I don't have to void my warranty and freak out about hearing sounds of crunching metal using a delid tool or having to pay someone to do it. Related, I wish GPU makers would do the same thing so I don't have to rip off and throwaway fans, metal, and plastic when putting on a waterblock. It's not even a cost savings thing I'm after, I just want to save some time, and certainly not throwaway parts I can't use in a landfill.
bearsbarely@reddit
Your best bet is going for an Asrock like the B650 steel legend or a riptide. They go in and out of stock often, but that's because they're actually good products. I'd personally avoid the tomahawk because I got a dead on arrival one myself, but that's uncommon, of course.
Hipster_Dragon@reddit
Interesting. The MSI Tomahawk was THE recommended B550 AM4 board a couple years ago.
bearsbarely@reddit
Am5 is more "fragile" than am4, so that may be playing a part. A lot of boards just end up dead on arrival. This is why the reviews are soooo much worse for every am5 board compared to am4 boards.
Crewmember169@reddit
This is what makes me keep considering an am4 build.
bearsbarely@reddit
The best bet for am5 is to buy everything very close and from reputable sellers together, and if something doesn't work, mass return everything suspect.
VenditatioDelendaEst@reddit
The B450 Tomahawk had an unusually powerful VRM for its price, which suddenly became important when Zen2 came out with 16 cores.
But it was so widely recommended that it gained brand recognition, and people started buying "tomahawk" boards, regardless of the fact that that word doesn't mean anything. In fact you should probably be suspicious of the price/perf of Tomahawk boards after B450, because MSI certainly reads forums and adverse selection is a thing. Just like the how the Hyper 212 CPU cooler was good for like 2 years in the early 2010s, and then became ludicrously overvalued.
jilsander@reddit
for more anecdotal evidence, i also got a DOA x670e tomahawk from the microcenter bundle, but exchanged for one that works fine. 50% failure rate from my 2 mb sample
FDrybob@reddit
I had a similar experience with my B650E-F bundle. Since then I downsized my build and tried the Asrock A620i, which works well.
Neymune@reddit
I also had a B650 Tomahawk come DOA. Decided to give MSI another chance, and I ordered a X670 Tomahawk because I did not want to wait for the exchange to ship out to me. 0 issues at all with the new one so far, and customer service was not bad at all.
surfingforfido@reddit
Same, I have a 670e MSI tomahawk, works flawlessly.
Lucade2210@reddit
Gigabyte is never a good option
TrueYahve@reddit
I love my Asus proart x670-e
No-Classroom-457@reddit
I have an MSI x670e gaming plus Wi-Fi and a Ryzen 7700x and I have no issues at all. Boot time to log in is maybe 20 seconds. Load time for programs and games is fast also. MSI so far has treated me well. I've also have an Asus that has been good too. I feel like it's more luck of the draw. Not sure if users trying to OC are the majority of the problems, but I didn't want to deal with any issues so I'm running a 5200mhz.
saxovtsmike@reddit
If you care about music, get a external usb dac/audio interface 4hdd + ssd internal screams you need a nas or just use old small drives because you have em
Spyrothedragon9972@reddit (OP)
I have an M-Audio MK 2 but it kinda sucks because it always glitches out on start up.
saxovtsmike@reddit
then it´s time to probably get something different but swapping to external sound device and a external fancontroller (Aquacomputer quadro even for aircooled build) just made me not to have to think about these two components when choosing a mainboard. Not overpaying hundrets of euros for a flagship mainboard with a different "better" codec.
I just run a simple Asus Xonar u7 mk2, with my headphones and M-Audio av32. Just hammer on the big knob and swap between speakers and headset. love it. Might not suite any quality ears or devices, but its enough for me, as it is conveniently easy to use and as i said, it just works (better than a pcie soundcard I had ages before I swapped to itx)
Spyrothedragon9972@reddit (OP)
I've never heard of an external fan controller. Does it monitor internal temps and adjust fan speed accordingly?
saxovtsmike@reddit
its a internal usb device roughly 5x5cm or 2"x2" in freedom units, has a molex power connector and 4 x4pin fan headers. The "magic" comes from the aquasuite software which is by far, the most advanced fanconroller software you can imagine with startboost, different profiles, master slave fan courves, everything you wand and ever need.
Plus plugins for hw info or aida to get and output different software values from the complete system
give it a google it´s worth it. Coming from custom watercooling loops where I used the aquaero , a even more powerful 5.25" device, the quadro and octo are the smaller variants witout a display
andytandy999@reddit
I went with x870e carbon, good board but I would highly recommend Asrock Nova if you do not need maximum usb ports and 27w fast charge for the front port.
Nova is value king, has also 1x Gen 5 m.2 slot, 3x Gen4 m.2 slow and another pcie 4x2 m.2 slot (Gen3 slot). VRMs are a overkill too.
I would avoid Gigabyte, they do silly stuff like 3 gen5 slots and can only use 1 unless you want gpu slot to run at x8. Also read most of there boards have less pcb layers (not 100% sure).
seajay860@reddit
brother there all good it doesnt matter
TwistedTechMike@reddit
I just finished a new build with the Aorus Elite recently. Its been rock solid. I cant speak to audio as I have a Schitt stack off to the side.
EvilDan69@reddit
Honestly.. I've been a long time Asus fan. however recently my sister accidentally drowned her last pc...... so we went for a combo deal over the holidays. Gigabyte B650M Gaming Plus wifi, Amd R5 7700CPU, 32GB D5 6000MHZ Ram by T-Force. Not my usual brand for ram, but it works well for her.
The main thing is updating that motherboard bios, setting up the proper XMP RAM profile for AMD, and making sure to update to all the latest drivers, which the AMD software did automatically once we installed Windows. It was the nicest thing and talk about convenience. I was very happy about that.
Rapom613@reddit
I have an asrock b650e PG ITX in my build. No complaints at all, has everything I needed and wanted, for a fair price.
FDrybob@reddit
I do have a big complaint with it. It doesn't have BIOS Flashback, despite all of Asrock's other AM5 ITX boards having it. Even their A620i has it, yet their most premium AM5 ITX board doesn't. It's baffling. I got the A620i for now, and it has been working well, but I'm waiting to see if things improve once new boards launch in early 2025.
luiz_victor@reddit
Placa Mãe Asus TUF Gaming B650M-Plus seems to be a good choice.
DynamicSocks@reddit
MSI B650 paired with 9800x3d. Zero problems
Careful-Mind-123@reddit
Hardware unboxed has good videos on am5 motherboards.
But, anyways...man are the names stupid....
Can you tell, by looking at just the names, which one from MSI is better (aka more expensive)? Here's the list, slightly randomized.
B650 Carbon WiFi Pro B650M-A WiFi B650I Edge WiFi B650M Mortar WiFi Pro B650-P WIFI B650 Tomahawk WiFi
Now you tell me which name suggests "BEST" Pro? Tomahawk? Carbon?
AndrijaCPVB@reddit
I use Asus B650A with Ryzen 5 7600. No issues since day 1.
Wojtkie@reddit
I have that B650 AORUS, thing is solid. Boots super fast.
suprvillin@reddit
b650 boards imo are the way to go for average users i got a msi mag tomahawk b650 the other day and bios flashed it for 9800x3d
kubunio10@reddit
All going well? I too have a 9800x3d on the way and been eyeing the msi tomahawk b650 but seen that it might have issues with boot times, so wondering of your experience with the board.
m4tic@reddit
That is a DDR5 architecture issue. In most cases, get the board running how you want, then turn on memory context restore. Might be buried under advanced DRAM timing settings.
All of the rackmount servers I set up that have DDR5 take forever for first boot. This is Zen4 Epyc 9004 and up.
_dharwin@reddit
Has anyone mentioned Context Restore?
suprvillin@reddit
My experience has been good and i like it my only gripes are
The boot times thing is true like it does take a good couple seconds to boot to lock screen
And msi boards come with a on board bloatware driver menu but that can be disabled in bios
This isn’t a gripe but you will have to bios flash because i doubt majority of b650 boards are updated to support 9800x3d
saggingrufus@reddit
I used that gigabyte motherboard, or tried to. It was DOA and it had absolutely nothing to help me determine that. There were no beep codes, there is only a singular LED for each step of the post. I had a red CPU light. I returned the CPU and got a new one, I still had a red CPU light.
It did not post, it gave absolutely zero output to anything monitors or anything on the board. Other than that one CPU light.
Whether that gigabyte board is good or not, I don't recommend it. It sucks the diagnose.
vapeducator@reddit
Sometimes it's better to pay more for a motherboard if you plan to keep the system with many future CPU and other upgrades. This is why it can be better to go with the best X870E chipset, which would be the Gigabyte X870E AORUS ELITE WIFI7. It has quite a few benefits today with PCIe v5, more PCIe channels, faster 160Mhz 6Ghz channels, faster overclocking RAM support, better power management and heat sinking for high power CPUs.
One warning about older B650 motherboards is that they may not boot up out-of-the box with the latest Granite Ridge CPUs. Updating the BIOS may be required, which is a bit of a pain to get going. Not terrible, just inconvenient. I had this problem with the Gigabyte B650 AORUS Elite AX Elite ICE. It required an updated bios to use the AMD Ryzen 5 9600X. I went with the B650 chipset because 9600X CPU is probably never going to be updated to something newer or better in the future, and everything else is good enough.
One unusual problem is that the motherboard indicated failure of the RAM test when booting, when the real problem was the CPU compatibility, not the RAM. Once I updated the bios, the RAM checked out fine.
Milios12@reddit
Despite what people say, I've had gigabyte mobos for my last two builds and didn't have any issues.
I wouldn't touch overpriced ASUS trash. MSI is hit or miss.
AsRock should be fine
wegotthisonekidmongo@reddit
I have an asus board that works fine. YMMV.
RiffsThatKill@reddit
I'm going to get the x670e-E gaming board soon. The overvolting of SOC is no longer an issue with the updated bios, from what I hear. It's got better USB connectivity than all the cheaper boards like Asrock. 3 internal USB headers sealed the deal for me (because I use a lot of Aquacomputer products)
TanTone4994@reddit
I am waiting on Asrock Nova x870e.
Not_Another_Name@reddit
Just wanted to post I'm in the same boat as you. Have an 8600k, want decent audio, need decent number of sata ports, don't care about wifi also trying to make heads and tails of the motherboard market right now
Spyrothedragon9972@reddit (OP)
I hope this thread is useful to you! It got a lot more engagement than I expected.
Significant_Apple904@reddit
I have an Asus and my wife has an MSI, we both don't have any issues, but a lot of people say AsRock is the best
MysticSpoon@reddit
I have an Msi b650 gaming plus WiFi. Everything works great with my 7800x3d and 32gb ddr5 ram. Was able to oc the ram to 6000 no issue at all. It’s not the fanciest mobo but I have no complaints. The boot time with expo enabled is a bit slow but hasn’t bothered me one bit. It takes maybe 20 seconds to boot.
LRH82@reddit
Try Enabling Memory Context Restore in the BIOS, brought the boot time down to 23 seconds on my B650 Tomahawk.
MysticSpoon@reddit
I feel like my boot time is already around that and my system is very stable. I also don’t completely shut down my pc that often so it doesn’t really bother me. It’s used purely for play so it’s a non issue for me. I appreciate the help though. I’ll look into it. I won’t complain if I can further reduce the boot time without effecting stability
jerryeight@reddit
Avoid the Asus one. Trust me.
Elitefuture@reddit
I got an asus prime b650 plus on release. Then shortly after I saw that my motherboard specifically has the worst vrm temps. It was funny and sad, but I'll probably stick to 8 core or less cpus so it won't be too bad.
protomartyrdom@reddit
No surprises there, Prime has been their bottom of the barrel line for a while now.
doggydp@reddit
I think the Prime series on any chipset is the cut down version - for Asus boards - I'd 'start' at Tuf gaming series as min.
But, for the AM5 chipsets - it sounds like Gigabyte and Asrock have pretty good boards - Asrock - Riptide, Gigabyte - Aorus AX Ice - among 2 good ones. I'd look at those 2 and the similarly priced ones from those 2 brands first.
Elitefuture@reddit
Yup, now that I have more knowledge, I would've gotten the asrock board. I was at microcenter and there were no reviews on these boards yet. So I picked off of name alone. All the asus drama came out later. I now heavily prefer asrock.
doggydp@reddit
Well, for the last gen or even maybe last 2 gen - on both Intel and AMD - it's their 'entry level' board - it's often the one used in prebuilts, too, if I'm not mistaken or at least for starting 'entry' if you configure a prebuilt?
Maybe start a 'just in case, Asrock mobo' fund? :)
Elitefuture@reddit
Dw I've got plenty of funds to fix my pc if something happens. I just don't like wasting money if I don't have to. I like the saying, "I can afford, but I don't want to."
Virtual-Chris@reddit
I’ve got a TUF B650 MATX board and it’s been fine.
Plenty-Industries@reddit
I have an ROG Strix X670E-E. Never an issue.
But with Asus's warranty scandal, I'll avoid Asus if I need a new motherboard.
LGCJairen@reddit
my crosshair has been good to me. i wasn't on the platform for the early issues though.
jerryeight@reddit
They burned me on my x570 tuf wifi board. It left a bad taste in my mouth. It shorted out my 3600x. I'm not sure if my ram or gpu are dead too.
cdub998@reddit
X670E Tomahawk This is a good one that will work with a lot of drives for a great price. I actually just bought one the other day.
RamXid@reddit
Personally I can vouch for the msi b650 tomahawk. Has a bunch of usb ports for my flight sim setup and the built in audio is surprisingly good so I don't even need to use any external audio stuff.
Only "issue" I had with the board was it didn't recognize my ram sticks at first for whatever reason but that was rather easily fixed with the bios ezflash and everything has been working perfectly ever since.
Scanoe@reddit
In my experience it can be compatibility dependent between parts.
Started with a 7700X / MSI Pro B650-p Wifi, that combo was never totally stable. I was able to run EXPO 6000, 36, 36, 36 but could not run Memory Context Restore, blue screen every time, so had \~45 second boots for over a year.
Upgraded to the 9700X, put it on the Msi Pro B650, totally stable. Can run Both EXPO & MCR enabled, thing is the 9700X doesn't need MCR, \~20 second boots with MCR Off, so I leave it off for better Ram stability.
Then built a 2nd PC with my 7700X on an Asrock B650 Tomahawk (not the wifi version). Totally Stable, runs EXPO, MCR & Fast Boot All enabled.
Btw the B650 Tomahawk has been quite a bargain, only $160 (new) and runs very well.
Also had the Asrock B650M HDV/M.2 for a couple months, had my 7700X on it. I never could get that HDV to run properly, it had numerous issues and a very annoying issue in that it would never wake from sleep, tried everything to get the sleep issue fixed, but nope. Had a 2 year Micro center warranty on it so returned it, got the Tomahawk to replace it.
Orjan91@reddit
I did the same research around 6 months ago or so, i ended up with the MSI B650 tomahawk paired with a 7800x3d and although the startup times were initially around 50-60sec i did the quick fix i found online, iirc it was basically just turning off(or on) a function called ram training or something like that, it reduced the boot time to around 15-20sec with boot window enabled (the screen that hangs around saying "press f2 to enter bios". If i remove the boot window feature im sure it goes down to 12-15s ish, but im not bothered, i turn it on and grab a drink and its good to go when im back.
No stability issues, solid board and easy to work with and bios is nice and intuitive. I would recommend it, although i havent tried any of the alternatives.
I know it did have some issues at AM5 launch, but thats a while ago and the recent BIOS updates seems to have fixed a lot of the issues that were before my time, i downloaded and installed the latest stable bios on mine when i built my pc just to be sure.
bwillpaw@reddit
ASRock pro rs x670e probably best features to $ board out there.
100drunkenhorses@reddit
y'all are having ASRock problems? the only boards I have trouble with the gigabyte because their bios is really stupid. I only have gigabyte due to the ITX and holding 3 m.2 drives
Officer-McDanglyton@reddit
You can’t really go wrong for the most part if you’re buying something name brand and it has the right features for you. I’ve bought 4 AM5 boards. I bought 2 MSI boards because I’ve had good luck with my MSI components in the past and they’ve been good. Then I got a Asus because it was on sale, and it came D.O.A. (Which turned out to be fairly common when I read more reviews) so I returned it for another MSI.
RaymoVizion@reddit
I'm on an Asrock board for AM5 no issues so far. Very stable.
My AM4 platform ironically was gigabyte and I've had audio issues and other things while using that build so I went with Asrock this time.
HugeTemperature4304@reddit
AS rock is best
Vash_Sama@reddit
Saw that all the boards you listed are B650 boards. Might I suggest a video by Hardware Unboxed which you can find here. They go over the top 5 boards for B650 ranging from budget models all the way up to premium ones. Hope this video helps you in some way OP and good luck! :D
rasmusdf@reddit
Check out Hardware Unboxeds review of 35 B650 motherboards. Asrock is good.
Guy_frm11563@reddit
I have built a lot of computers,the only ones that lasted more than 4 years were the computer I built with MSI motherboards ! One of them is still going that I built in 2010 !
bannedprince@reddit
I found a x870e board for 225$ after tax , the b650 were 180 to 250 $ after tax ,are their any boards cheaper than 150$ after tax ? Or should I stick with the x870e?
AbsolutZeroGI@reddit
I've had AN Asus B650E-F since May 2023 and haven't had any problems with it. I bought it after the drama. I mean, people dislike Asus rn, and I get it, this isn't a recommendation or anything, but I'm having a pretty good time with it.
Acrobatic-Writer-816@reddit
Gigabyte 650 since 2 years no prob
aLegionOfDavids@reddit
I just built my new 7800x3d build with a Gigabyte Auros Stealth Ice. Performs exactly as you expect a mobo to perform - it works, and it looks clean af 😅. OP, my old build was your build - same mobo and gpu - I won’t but asus again after it began failing after a couple years and their customer service generally sucks (but compared to evga, rip, whose doesn’t)
Xaendeau@reddit
Gigabyte Aorus boards and mid/high-end ASRock boards are both pretty good in my book. I got about a 50/50 distribution of them of all the PCs I've built over the last 5 years or so.
ASUS and MSI are on my shit list right now, though I hear the MSI Tomahawks are pretty good boards. I haven't messed with many. In college I used to use a ton of ASUS boards for building gaming PCs and workstations for people and businesses. I had a couple of stupid RMAs and gave up on them. Never had a good opinion of MSI, TBH.
steamedturtle@reddit
I had an ASrock AM4 board that served me well for about 5 years until I upgraded last year. Using an Asus B650 E-F now, and it has worked perfectly fine. I don’t use Armory Crate. And the boot times are fine, but they were/can be weird. But again, they’ve been fine since I flashed a newer bios.
engrng@reddit
I bought the MSI X870 Tomahawk after using Asus mobos for my last 4 PC builds. Never again. It’s a real piece of shit.
My SATA drives are showing up as external drives in Windows 11 because the mobo is telling it so and there’s no way to fix this in bios. I flashed the bios to the latest version and still no fix and trying to flash the bios was a giant pita because for some reason the bios flash utility would not recognize the bios file in my M2 SSD but for some reason it is ok if the same file is on my SATA HDD. Also what kind of cheapass company wouldn’t include a goddamn physical user manual for a >$300 motherboard.
HatefulAbandon@reddit
Are these issues about the X870 Tomahawk or the Asus?
engrng@reddit
Tomahawk
HatefulAbandon@reddit
After reading and watching reviews I ordered the same motherboard lol. It got the best PCIe lane layout for the price, good VRMs, and good memory OC. Hopefully the issues you mentioned will be fixed with bios updates.
LurksOften@reddit
Anecdotal, but I’ve tried two so far this year since August: the Aorus and the Tomahawk. The aorus gave me issues originally so I switched to the tomahawk. It helped for a little but then the issues came back up.
Turns out it was an OS issue and I had to buy a completely new drive, which solved it.
So I can say both the Gig and MSI are fine boards. MSI has been a bit more intuitive and I like their BIOS more personally.
If you go with the Gigabyte, hit me up since I have it still with no use and I’ll gladly sell it at a discount.
MartiniCommander@reddit
I think the MSI MEG X870 Tomahawk is the single best x870 board out there.
Vaudane@reddit
My only complaint with ASRock is they were always known as the "ps/2 company" and their am5 line have no ps/2 ports.
Also their OC Formula XOC boards are nowhere to be seen.
I get what I'm after is niche, but it's not that niche, and they've done it plenty of times before.
allBSnoBS@reddit
I know Asus is in a bad light at the moment, but I’ve used Asus motherboards for all my builds in the last 10 years and never had any issues. I’ll personally use another Asus motherboard for my new build for the rtx 5000 series.
InvestigatorSenior@reddit
I'm a happy user of Asrock B650e riptide wifi together with 7900x. So far no problems and they had bioses with stability fixes sooner than some other brands back when it mattered.
Also the only brand I know about that had correct Vsoc during 7000 series CPU burning out drama.
biker_jay@reddit
I have an older gigabyte and a newer msi. The gigabyte audio is way better and has an optical out connection.
As far as 3.2 USB goes you can always buy a hub.
Buy a dac Amp combo. They're reasonably priced anymore. Louder and better quality. Topping. Fosi both reasonably priced and come with good reviews. Don't buy into the whole audiophile bit where you have to spend thousands for quality music. It's bs for the most part
ajs2294@reddit
I went with ASUS Tuff. First board was completely DOA, second couldn’t recognize RAM even after a few bios flash attempts. Third finally worked
Redsparow21@reddit
I'm getting on great with my Asus ROG X870-F - took my Klevv Cras RAM straight to 8000MT/s with an 9800x3D no problem. 🙂
Catscratchfever92@reddit
My asrock b650 pg lightning has been solid.
PresentMindless5691@reddit
My MSI B650 has been perfect since day one. Though maybe I got lucky based on other comments.
Inevitable_Silver_13@reddit
I got the Gigabyte Eagle AX and it's good but there have been some hiccups along the way. I tried ordering an MSI board straight from the company and it wouldn't go through. Turned out it tried to charge my card like 10 times after it said it didn't go through. They literally don't have a customer service number, so I called the tech support number and the person on the line basically seemed to have the attitude that their customer service was shit and they're was nothing he could do. It really soured me on the company, regardless of their reputation for good hardware. I got the feeling that if anything ever went wrong that I'd be screwed. Of course, that's most mobo manufacturers.
f1rstx@reddit
Mine ASRock B650M PRO RS is very good, 0 issues
Leo9991@reddit
My ROG Strix b650e-f has been working well. After enabling memory context restore it boots in 10s.
StumptownRetro@reddit
Asrock best boy. Gigabyte is a close second because even if their performance isn’t as good, their customer service makes up for it a ton.
Captobvious75@reddit
Msi B650 Tomahawk Wifi here. Rock solid since day 1.
whomad1215@reddit
If I'm avoiding any brand it would be asus and their absolutely horrendous customer service + overpriced products
I'd get the asrock b650 pro rs at $216 and call it a day
MikeTheGrass@reddit
I am putting in my 2 cents. I have the Aorus Board rev. 2 version with a 7800x3d and it's been rock solid. Zero issues. No long boots or anything. Great bios as well.
AdhocAnchovie@reddit
By the same logic that all these amd supporters excuse the bad am5 quality, I could sugest going for a 12th seeries i7 or i9 intel, that you will switch to a 14th i9 in 5 years or so. Boards are cheaper and the upgrades are already out. The 13/14th fiasco is already dealt with, and it will be an easy upgrade for the nex 3-5 years.
Gabito991@reddit
I dunno, I bought a X570 Extreme 4 from AsRock in 2021 and it stills holding pretty good. Zero drama.
Can't say the same about the last Gigabyte mobo I had because a fan pin started to make kind of sparkles and died. The mobo was fine, but it was a scary AF moment lol.
PS: Grammar isn't my friend.
donkey_loves_dragons@reddit
Since when are Gigabyte mainboards considered bad??? MSI, yes, definitely crap.
iSHJAYGAMiNG@reddit
I have Asus. Yes, they have boot issues. As in long boot time, but that can be fixed with a little bios settings.
Wooden-Agent2669@reddit
Thats not an Asus boot issue.. Thats DDR5 Memory Context Restore.
Spyrothedragon9972@reddit (OP)
So it's specifically a DDR5 issue? Wouldn't it affect all boards then?
Wooden-Agent2669@reddit
. Boot times from DDR5 are universal, they have nothing to with the brand of the Mainboard. You need to enable Memory Context Restore in Bios to have faster boot speeds
Possible_Formal_1877@reddit
My Gigabyte Auros has been stellar, no issues whatsoever. As for sound I recommend an external sound card (pretty happy with my M-audio Air), makes a world of difference and makes it possible to use upgraded speakers and headphones and actually control them without having to enter the menu on the screen: big buttons are always better than a slider on the screen. YMMW.
Spyrothedragon9972@reddit (OP)
I've been using an M-Audio MK 2 since 2015. It works okay for me, but my Corsair keyboard has a volume wheel. Luckily I haven't had to use the Windows menu to adjust volume unless it's the volume mixer for adjusting multiple programs independently.
littleemp@reddit
Gigabyte is never the best option.
LOBOTOMY_TV@reddit
ASRock b650e has been phenomenal only downside is my Ethernet port died within a month but I think it happened while I was testing/trying to repair a busted GPU
theSkareqro@reddit
This release, I'm all for ASRock and Gigabyte mobos.
And get yourself an amp+DAC stack and forget about onboard audio.
Vodskaya@reddit
I've currently got an Asus X870E ProArt board with an 9950X and I'm having no issues. Boot times were slow the first couple of times, but that was easily fixed via DDR5 context restore. I've seen no instability issues so far. Boot times are very quick on my gen 5 drive. YMMV.
Only issue so far is that the front USB C header is not working, but that may be an issue on the case rather than the board. I've not tested with a different internal cable. The case was a returned unit, after all.
sysak@reddit
I like MSI best because I mess around with overclocking quite a lot and I like their bios the most. But their low end models are quite bad in comparison with the competition and I'm not a fan of the "dragon focused" styling. Going for Am5 I went with a gigabyte b650m Aorus elite ax because it was cheaper than the MSI mortar and offered pcie5 m.2 slot where MSI only had pcie4 in their b650 boards. The bios took some getting used to but I'm very happy so far. May try ASRock next as they seem really good bang for buck but the bios looks quite unfriendly. I'd only go for Asus if money was no object and I could get their top tier boards which cost stupid money. The standard tuf & lower end rog-strix boards seem overpriced and not better than the competitors. I also don't really like their bios as they like to name common settings their own way.
belinadoseujorge@reddit
Gigabyte is the only option to AVOID
Lexxino89@reddit
I have the Gigabyte B650 Gaming X AX V2 which is reasonably priced imo. There's also the non wifi version.
TwitterUser47@reddit
I’ve had a gigabyte gaming x motherboard running in my desktop for almost 5 years and I’ve never had a single issue with it. I’m using a Ryzen 7 though so my circumstances could be different than yours
Impossible_Okra@reddit
I currently use the Asus B650M Plus Wifi TUF board. I like the built in IO shield, 2.5 gb ethernet and usb c 20gb. Also it's almost all black (with yellow accents). I think my 2.5 gb ethernet and wifi are from Realtek not Intel.
I'd take a look at the features, ports and slots.
Also consider checking Amazon resale/warehouse for an open box motherboard. Often time it's just a customer return that was barely opened up. You could get significant discounts versus new. Through Im not sure about the impact on the warranty.
TwixtTwo@reddit
If you do this just be very careful to check the socket for damage. I’ve seen customers mess up installing the CPU and then return the product after damaging the board.
_Rah@reddit
Nil stability issues on my Asus. Boot times are probably long, but I reboot like once a month, so I don't it actually know for sure how long it takes.