TheaterFire

Don’t know anon. Maybe competent writers

Posted by CashSubstantial@reddit | greentext | View on Reddit | 507 comments

Don’t know anon. Maybe competent writers

Reply to Post

507 Comments

zombiepigman101@reddit

Having well written characters
View on Reddit #32706381

breakfasteveryday@reddit

They made the games and the story good 
View on Reddit #32184450

semhsp@reddit

> bad story with white people meh just a bad game > bad story with black people HOW DARE THEY FUCKING WOKE GEN Z DEI GOD DAMN SWEET BABY INC RUINING MY BIDEO GAME
View on Reddit #32190831

ThatGuyYouMightNo@reddit

\>Make a game starring white people \>People say it's bad \>"Darn guess we'll have to try harder next time." ​ \>Make a game starring non-white people \>People say it's bad \>"FUCK YOU THE GAME IS PERFECT IF YOU HATE IT YOU'RE RACIST"
View on Reddit #32209363

semhsp@reddit

Citation needed
View on Reddit #32209808

Rubbun@reddit

Forspoken lmao
View on Reddit #32212377

semhsp@reddit

One singular example while there's a new controversy for "woke" games every week lmao
View on Reddit #32214082

Rubbun@reddit

Citation needed
View on Reddit #32214276

semhsp@reddit

The new assassin's creed Paper mario Hades 2 Stellar Blade "censorship" I could go on, these are all quite fresh
View on Reddit #32220299

Rubbun@reddit

The only one that had actual controversy out of the ones you mentioned was Assassins' Creed. I'll agree it was blown out of proportion considering AC never meant to be a representation of X country, but it is fishy to put a black male MC in a game set in Japan. Ultimately a game set in feudal Japan should be japanese, but that's just my opinion. > Paper mario This barely sparked any outrage. >Hades 2 > >Stellar Blade "censorship" These two were hand in hand. The same people who criticized Stellar Blade for being too sexualized were gushing over Hades 2's designs, which is pretty hypocritical, and was called out as such. Hades 2 itself didn't get a lot of criticism save for some people who disliked the designs. I remember people talking about Hestia (and let's be fair, that design is horrid) and that's it. Stellar Blade was "censored" in the eyes of many because of the announcements leading up to its release and how certain outfits changed day 1. Some people speculate it was simply a design choice pushed too late. We'll never know I guess. Forspoken, on the other hand, is a legitimately terrible game that got defenders uniquely because it has a non-sexualized black female lead, but most of the criticism was on the art direction, gameplay, dialogue, direction and world design. Hence why I pointed at it.
View on Reddit #32221465

wikiwik2011@reddit

About the AC. You probably already know that but the black guy was a real person
View on Reddit #32537423

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

And he wasnt a gay samurai, he's as real as JFK from the game Prey (2017)
View on Reddit #32557756

wikiwik2011@reddit

Ok?
View on Reddit #32564214

white-male404@reddit

>make a game starring black people >25% of the dialogue revolves around being black and fighting white supremacy >game also is shit
View on Reddit #32309728

McDiezel10@reddit

First off it’s millennials doing this shit atm. Second; when a story is more concerned with virtue signaling, surface level political messaging, and identity politics, it’s clear that’s the issue with the plot. Plus the creative team will use those politics as a shield for criticism of their mediocre writing
View on Reddit #32193804

Disco_Biscuit12@reddit

*Disney Star Wars has entered the chat*
View on Reddit #32194860

breakfasteveryday@reddit

the LOTR series (which honestly wasn't all that diverse, just breathtakingly mediocre for the budget and hype) says hi
View on Reddit #32220972

white-male404@reddit

no one watched that shit
View on Reddit #32309539

breakfasteveryday@reddit

I did, as an amature anthropologist. Dunno why everyone supposedly cares about the lady dwarf being black when she should have had a beard 
View on Reddit #32312359

breakfasteveryday@reddit

> meh just a bad game > HOW DARE THEY FUCKING RACIST ANTI-DEI CHUDS GOD DAMN NECKBEARD RUINING MY MEDIA LANDSCAPE
View on Reddit #32220896

Metrix145@reddit

Strawman
View on Reddit #32201555

proud_NIMBY_98@reddit

you get free credit for being woke, but it'll come with extra hate. easy come easy go, dont bitch about it
View on Reddit #32195753

divinity995@reddit

I thin its more because if they know game is trash, because at some point someone has to see a steaming pile of shit, they know that actual gamers will shittalk and wont buy the game in the first place, so they turn on making the performative "wokeness" the selling point to recoup some losses on people who will buy just to own the chuds or something. If you are confident in your product you sell the product and not how ethical or how many women worked on it
View on Reddit #32200586

Joelblaze@reddit

Personally I think it's rather telling when people will say "it's cause the writings is good" but will still immediately start complaining about minorities existing if the writing is bad. It implies that you think minorities never really naturally exist in storytelling so if it's good writing then it was something that was overcome and if it was bad writing then the writers were clearly including them as some kind of crutch. Otherwise why bring it up in one case but consider it irrelevant in another?
View on Reddit #32187112

breakfasteveryday@reddit

Sure, but there's a lot of space between "immediately complaining about minorities" and just not playing that particular game or watching that particular movie. I don't think it's racist of an intermittent white male movie goer to skip a Marvel movie promoted around girl power or a film about an all-black gang of cowboys in the Wild West, just as I wouldn't call a black person racist for not being particularly drawn to Game of Thrones. Similarly, I don't expect most people to spend $70 on a middling first person rpg for its diverse cast of characters.  I also don't really blame middle-aged nerds for getting upset when their precious IP gets rebooted in a way that discards their own identities, though I think they take that shit too seriously and of course I don't condone being racist about it.  As for the diversity versus quality association: deliberately including or focusing on minorities absolutely doesn't make a game or film bad. That said, a lot of games and movies do so in a calculated PR way, usually paired with a writing team that's excited to lean in and club the audience over the head with it. In my opinion, that usually does make a movie bad.  It definitely narrows the audience, especially when it's one of the primary promotional talking points. The messaging is at best effectively "this movie is kind of for everybody", where most audiences want something for them, specifically. At worst the message is "see this movie or you're a hateful person", which is actually PR poison. Audiences will show up for something that isn't strictly for them, but unless they (a) feel like the thing isn't *not* for them, (b) trust the maker of the thing, and (c) hear that it's at least pretty good, they'll be less motivated to engage with it.  Studios that try to prioritize diversity in their games and movies are in a tough situation. Diversity is about including people of various races, sexualities, and backgrounds, which means the more diversity you add, the shallower the representation of each race or sexuality shown is going to be. Worse, the more diluted your organic appeal to any specific racial or cultural identity will be. For example, I expect Encanto was really popular with Latino / Latina audiences. I also expect that black people make up more of the audience of House of the Dragon (which features some prominent black characters from the start) than they did of the audience of OG Game of Thrones (which didn't).  Encanto was a critical success because it was a great movie made by a studio that was already well known and had a stellar reputation. It could have done as well critically if an unknown studio had made it, but fewer people outside of the core audience that it was made for and represents would have heard of it or been drawn to it, or trusted that the movie was for them, too.  It can also be tough to work diversity into the theme of a film or game in a resonant way, especially if the theme itself isn't really about diversity. If most races and sexualities are present, a writer has to either (a) try to really establish and pay tribute to each one's identity in the limited screen time they have, or (b) not really focus on the diverse part of their identity. Both can be bad for different reasons, with (a) feeling pandering and (b) feeling token. This is especially a problem in movies, which have a lot to accomplish in 90ish minutes. For the record, I think (b) is the way to go if the IP doesn't actually have room for the appropriate context and character development, but (a) can be great in something like an RPG or HBO series.  Valve doesn't run into problems with its diversity because it has an ocean of trust, it doesn't market around diversity first, and it makes great games. If the complaints with other IP were actually primarily about racism, Valve would be hearing them, too. 
View on Reddit #32220270

Dustyoo10@reddit

Because characters who exist for the sole purpose of diversity, and who’s personality and existence within the story is that they’re a minority, is bad writing. So having characters that aren’t that is good.
View on Reddit #32187671

Joelblaze@reddit

And it's kind of weird that a poorly written white guy gets to just be a poorly written white guy but every other kind of character suddenly gets questioned of ulterior motives for even existing in the story.
View on Reddit #32188764

Kelvinek@reddit

It’s not weird, as in it obviously makes sense. Minorities are minorities because they are a minority, overwhelming majority of the „west” is some flavour of white. Plus nobody really mentions being white themselves unless it’s some kind of racists caricature, so poorly written white man is a poorly written white man, but black latinx asian womanx who will have lines about her sexuality and slavery will be an obvious eye sore.
View on Reddit #32189604

Theta291@reddit

Many people think that being a minority is political in and of itself, but obviously nobody’s mere existence is political. Nobody decided to be born brown or gay. Bad writers clearly have this same issue when they act like a minority’s whole personality revolves around their identity as a minority, showing that they don’t bother trying to understand the minorities they’re writing, or see them as a token rather than the person. I think the most obvious example of this was the “exagerrated swagger of a black teen” review.
View on Reddit #32191013

ismasbi@reddit

> I think the most obvious example of this was the “exagerrated swagger of a black teen” review. Wait, where does this come from? I thought it was just a random meme.
View on Reddit #32214846

koala-69@reddit

It's also *how* you include the political commentary into the story. People don't like to be preached at. Like being an organic part of the resistance against a tyrannical government is cool. Having the in-game podcaster telling you what you just did and how you should feel about it is not.
View on Reddit #32195270

InquisitorMeow@reddit

Can you point us towards many games with characters talking about slavery? Racist caricature writing for minorities is still just shitty writing or voice acting. If we had a game where you had a character with a shitty Jamaican accent be the only thing unique about their character thats just lazy writing, no one was trying to represent Jamaicans.
View on Reddit #32209534

EatsFiber2RedditMore@reddit

I'm sure Tyler Perry has had some off characters (based on how prolific his movie making is) but you never see his movies getting racial blow back. I have seen a few on tv they star mostly a black cast and seem ok.
View on Reddit #32190383

AStupidFuckingHorse@reddit

Tyler Perry is not a respected figure with a good amount of black people. Not anymore at least. His depiction of black relationships, struggles and general film production has been widely criticised. No one under 45 likes Tyler Perry
View on Reddit #32201342

Theta291@reddit

He doesn’t get blowback because he’s a black man writing movies for black people. A lot of times when a piece of media comes out and it’s for the general public rather than the represented minority people start whining.
View on Reddit #32191234

EatsFiber2RedditMore@reddit

That's my point it's not about the individual races it's about being forced fed an ideology. Shitts creek is a great example of love story with two gay men and not a gay love story. The writing is great and the characters are great, one of the characters is also gay but the show isn't about that. The best part is the happy ending. (Spoilers)
View on Reddit #32192679

Minecraftitisist69@reddit

Although I agree with your points for the most part, I think that part of the "writing is good" argument attacks characters placed into stories to fill some sort of diversity quota. Rather than making them actually well written characters, they end up as flanderizations of characters which are often easily pointed to by actual racists as a low-hanging, cherry picked example of "minority characters in media are always bad." Additionally, the minorities suddenly coming into existence when the writing is bad tracks for this. If the writing of a certain piece of media is utter shit, the racists will point at the black man in it and say "this character is horribly written and was forced into the story by the woke liberal agenda" despite the character not being placed in for the sake of a quota at all. While there'll always be people doing this, even to well written characters, it's much harder to do so to them. "Grrrr there's a black guy in my piece of media" "well that piece of media is actually amazing and enjoyed by the majority of its consumers, maybe diversity is a good thing?" Now should we really give a shit about a character's race in the first place? Not really. If they're out of place for the time period/area they're in then perhaps it could be explained by the story (eg Live Action Little Mermaid takes place in the Caribbean to explain the cast's diversity) but it's really a non issue as a whole.
View on Reddit #32188121

UltimateInferno@reddit

Yeah. I'd take these complaints more seriously if this sub and 4chan as a whole wasn't bitching about the Fallout show depicting a woman and black man as the protagonists.
View on Reddit #32214229

kieran81@reddit

Because those games came out pre-2014, before GamerGate collectively broke every single terminally online mfer's brain. When Deadlock comes out I know there will be some dumb motherfuckers saying Valve went woke.
View on Reddit #32186054

odbj@reddit

Deadlock gameplay is too good to care about identity politics, tbh.
View on Reddit #32513131

PussyDestrojer@reddit

Half-Life Alyx came out in 2020 and ended with SPOILERS! The G-Man firing Gordon and replacing him with Alyx. Nobody complained that "THEY REPLACED THE WHITE MALE WITH A MIXED RACE WOMAN!!!!" because, guess what - the story was good. It's not about race or GamerGate, the usual game nowadays just tried to check as many boxes as possible.
View on Reddit #32187513

Existing-Help-3187@reddit

Wait, nobody got replaced by anybody in Alyx. Infact the ending made sure we will be playing as Gordon in the next game.
View on Reddit #32215427

PrimeLasagna@reddit

But she replaces Gordon as G-Man’s agent, while the game sets up Gordon and Eli on a mission to get her back
View on Reddit #32253470

Existing-Help-3187@reddit

Thats just a plot point. Its not like all gingers getting replaced by blacks in Hollywood. All the characters are still in the game.
View on Reddit #32269442

gereffi@reddit

1) She was a well-established character by that point. 2) For the most part HLA wasn’t a very big game. Just not a lot of market for VR games.
View on Reddit #32228805

Heil_S8N@reddit

didn't alyx happen BEFORE half-life 2?
View on Reddit #32193258

Refloni@reddit

Time travel shenanigans. Since we're already talking spoilers, you might as well check the ending in youtube
View on Reddit #32196479

AbortionBulld0zer@reddit

I think you're wrong. Alyx sacrificed herself to save her dad. In the last moments you're playing as a gordon and picking up the crowbar
View on Reddit #32207396

Soulful-Sorrow@reddit

I mean, understandable. Didn't Gordon already "quit" with the help of the Vortigaunts? I love the idea of the G-Man being so petty that he's like "No actually you can't quit, you're fired!" Plus Alyx was one of the only other characters in HL2 getting shit done
View on Reddit #32199674

Koekelbag@reddit

It probably helped that, by the time her vr game released, she has already been a known character for 16 years already, so well before the echo chambers on major social media would eventually form on account of those social media barely if not even existing yet at the time of half-life 2's release.
View on Reddit #32198073

Icabod_BongTwist@reddit

I disliked it, but not for any reason to do with Alyx per se, I just like Gordon better. I like Gordon's background (if the term applies) of just being a generally average egghead who had to pick up a gun and learn how to use it double-quick, or end up as another stain on the floor of Black Mesa.
View on Reddit #32193897

R0n4ld_Th3_B0y@reddit

i feel like the average racist wouldnt understand half of what happened in hla
View on Reddit #32192109

Special-Remove-3294@reddit

There will, there were and there will always be dumb motherfuckers. But if the game is good then nobody will care cause the game is good and therefore liked by the majority cause that is what makes a game good.
View on Reddit #32186357

kieran81@reddit

Yeah you're right on that. The second people got their hands on BG3 and the game turned out to be openly woke; not a single motherfucker complained because it was a phenomenal fucking game.
View on Reddit #32186421

Dynamitefuzz2134@reddit

> got their hands on. Sure, but i remember people bitching about the gay romance choices in game before the release. They just know the game was too successful so they shut up about it. There was a mod which was removed from nexus which attempted to make the game “less gay.” [forum post about said mod](https://www.neogaf.com/threads/nexus-mods-removes-anti-gay-baldurs-gate-3-mod-update-nexus-are-too-far-lost-in-their-sauce.1664373/page-2)
View on Reddit #32190542

Th3_Shr00m@reddit

From a dev perspective it makes sense to allow gay romance to minimize having to re-record voicelines with he/she flipped or hire more voice actors It's literally just way easier in every way
View on Reddit #32190821

Dynamitefuzz2134@reddit

I honestly couldn’t care less if it was or wasn’t in the game. It affected my experience in zero ways. The only “lgbt” content I saw in my first playthrough is Dame Aylin making out with the Selunite cleric.
View on Reddit #32191317

ArchmageIlmryn@reddit

Plus BG3 does what the Gamers^TM who complain about games being woke *say* they want - all the lgbt content in BG3 is entirely unpolitical. There aren't any characters talking about, or plot points related to acceptance or non-acceptance of characters being gay/bisexual/etc - just characters existing in the relationships they want to have.
View on Reddit #32217864

Dynamitefuzz2134@reddit

I honestly cannot name a single character in a video game where being gay is his only/major character trait though. I may be wrong and there may be. But I cannot think of one. Only one I can think of is Dorian from Dragon Age:inquisition. Even then him being a tevinter mage is far more apart of his personality than being gay. Even then all of that content is really only if you persue conversation/romance with him. Another is Kaiden from mass effect who is bisexual. Even then you can choose Ashley to save. Or just not pursue romance with the character. Nothing about the character screams “I’m bi” in any of his dialogue.
View on Reddit #32219400

_Two_Youts@reddit

People definitely complained about BG3, dude.
View on Reddit #32197348

chetizii@reddit

Half life: Alyx exists and no one batted an eye to one single minority character becoming the protagonist and literally taking Gordon's job.
View on Reddit #32187762

kieran81@reddit

It's the Alien paradox, where every piece of media with a minority is automatically good of its remembered before all the "politics" happened. Nobody's mad at Half-Life Alyx because then they'd need to be mad at Half Life 2
View on Reddit #32218537

JWBails@reddit

She hasn't *really* taken Gordon's job yet, I'm sure there'd be backlash if Episode 3 ever came out and the player character was Alyx.
View on Reddit #32192602

Dynamitefuzz2134@reddit

Isn’t it a prequel to HL2 though? (I don’t have VR)
View on Reddit #32190589

JWBails@reddit

It's a prequel but the ending retcons the ending of HL2:Ep2
View on Reddit #32192140

Rand_alThor_@reddit

Don’t do it for diversity points. Don’t join the culture war. Do what you want. Win. Billions of dollars a year.
View on Reddit #32494179

OneTrueSpiffin@reddit

the real reason is because you barely notice any of these characters. they hardly have lines. Alyx does, but she's from before incels got made at videogames, so they can't go after valve for adding a minority character that always existed. If Alyx was a new character just for HL:A, there'd probably be SOME shit
View on Reddit #32409986

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

I can count so many games with women in them after HL:A and nobody complained about them Just admit y'all simp for billion dollar corpos, because you being their white knight is so just humiliating, imagine believing ubisoft or sony add black lesbian womxn because they want they care. They use it for ESG money and for useful idiots lime you to defend them for free. You know answer me this: why is "I wani hug that gator" so loved when it has a protagonist a disabled croc lady? or why is snoot game loved and Vulcano High is total garbage?
View on Reddit #32420660

OneTrueSpiffin@reddit

I am a hard leftist. I don't simp for billion dollar corpos. And I'm not white knighting. I hate women. All the women I know suck. I don't think Ubisoft or Sony add black lesbian womxn (thank you for being respectful btw) because they care, at least not 100% of the time. Writists and arters might. But the fact that conservatives complain about the women characters when they're not the main issue, or complain about the women characters for problems that simply don't exist, shows that SOMETIMES (not all the time) it's a sexism thing. Or a racism thing. Who knows? Why is I Wani Hug That Gator loved? Because SHE'S HOT. THEY'RE JACKING OFF. That's why. Dumbass. And again, it's not all shows or games. That's why you can point to individual games and say "see? this one didn't get pushback!" I'm not defending GAME COMPANIES for god's sake. But sometimes the woman character isn't the sole problem with the game. I want game company hierarchies to be torn down and for them to be owned by the workers themselves.
View on Reddit #32421367

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

Whats wrong with you? Not only are you actually derranged sexist but your point goes both way, since it's not all games or shows, can you guess why certain games and shows are hated and others are not? And no it's not women being hot or existing, like you saying Olivia is hot AF says more about you than the devs. Like maybe if you actually read what people are saying here alone you'd know people arent mostly sexist. Also I find it very telling that you think conservatives hate women, like you hate women and you are self described hard leftist. Go simp for a failed alternative to communism, all you are able to be is the useful idiot that gets discarded when his usefullness runs out
View on Reddit #32421615

OneTrueSpiffin@reddit

ok ok buddy calm doooooown 1. i hate communism and alternatives to communism. I have been banned from every mainstream communist subreddit on this platform just for disagreeing with people. You are more communist than I am. 2. You think I would've honestly, actually just came out and said I hate women, truthfully? For the love of GOD, dude, learn to pick up on sarcasm. Learn to recognize a GOD DAMNED joke. Learn to understand PEAK humor. No, I don't hate women. They are annoying sometimes. I forgive them. 3. obviously conservatives fucking hate women lmao. half of the attacks against Kamala Harris have been calling her a whore. conservatives want bans on abortion. most online righties have a weird creepy kink where women submit to men and they can't help but tell you all about it every day. dennis prager thinks your wife should fuck you even if she doesn't feel like it that day. like come on dude. how do you hate women harder than that? Ok, remember that guy who looks like a thumb yelling about PRONOUNS(!!!!!) when talking about Starfield? That is proof enough that SOMETIMES, for SOME GAMES, diversity is their problem, not the game itself. Not all the time, not every game, but sometimes. So now go ahead and do the Reddit thing where you say that that one example of a guy (and the circle he ran in) hating a game for diversity is actually NOT an example of a guy (and the circle he ran in) hating a game for diversity. I'm gonna go bully my woman friends more. Peace out.
View on Reddit #32424173

SunderedValley@reddit

Because they make good games. Even the most hardcore turbo-racists barely care if the game is good. If the game is mid to outright disrespectful to the audience people are gonna find things to hate and the race is an easy angle. Or, conversely: Often bad games blatantly use race to get out of criticism.
View on Reddit #32184607

StevetheNinja69@reddit

100%. Telltale's The Walking Dead had a black man, a racially ambiguous girl, and a Mexican all as playable characters and got no shit for it. Why? Because the games were good (except TNF) and the characters were well written.
View on Reddit #32186190

Gerdione@reddit

Yep. I think most people just hate bad writing and lazy creative choices. A recent example I can think of is the Avatar live action remake. They removed Sokka's abrasive and sexist character trait because "we're in a different time". The whole point of his character is that he develops as the story continues which makes it even more meaningful when he ends up becoming a very respectable young man capable of self reflection and humility towards the end. Many teenage boys and young men are edgy like that and could definitely relate to his earlier self. If anything, it creates a relatable example that shows you are capable of outgrowing juvenile views, but because of this hand holding can't show anything negative attitude that the internet has cultivated, they lost out on a character that exemplifies what it means to mature and change for the better.
View on Reddit #32187773

Maddolyn@reddit

>you are capable of outgrowing juvenile views I never did and I consider it a character trait. Why change yourself to mend with the crowd when there are enough crowds?
View on Reddit #32375354

FatewithShadow@reddit

Shhhhhhhhhh! Dont tell them that their brains are not developed enough. Let them write their bad stories and disappear into obscurity. While the original cartoon will be discussed throughout 21st century or longer.
View on Reddit #32191692

throwaway090597@reddit

I watched one episode of the new show and then immediately re watched the original. The dialogue is just leagues better in the children's cartoon than the live action show. We should have known it would have been shit when the original creators parted ways with the project.
View on Reddit #32193422

The-Devilz-Advocate@reddit

It gets worse because Sokka's plotline with Suki and the Kyoshi warriors gets MORE sexist than the original. I'm the original Solka gets jumbled real quick by Suki and Kyoshi, but you sort of have compassion for the guy because he's the only boy left in his village and is in charge of taking care of them. In the live action, they turn him into a hot stud that Suki constantly pervs and oodles on. That's literally he only purpose in that storyline.
View on Reddit #32198880

Facesit_Freak@reddit

Noooooo, that's not sexist! It's fine to harass men!
View on Reddit #32264143

throwaway090597@reddit

That makes me incredibly sad.
View on Reddit #32201137

SunderedValley@reddit

>disappear God I wish.
View on Reddit #32204165

Ori_the_SG@reddit

1,000% this It does nobody a service to remove negative character traits and show good guys as flawed people. Especially when they will overcome some of their flaws
View on Reddit #32197404

TheKrimsonFvcker@reddit

Lee wasn't black, he was ... *URBAN*
View on Reddit #32202545

Far-Outcome-8170@reddit

This. Gta has you playing as a black dood and he's cool. Gta and HL are a far cry from the bullshit the likes of EA and Disney force in your face
View on Reddit #32188271

leargonaut@reddit

A lot of people were very upset about playing CJ when San Andreas came out. A game about 90s LA gang culture, and they were made they had to be a black guy.
View on Reddit #32191617

Facesit_Freak@reddit

The controversy was people fearing it would promote hood stereotypes, not that a game had a black mc lmfao
View on Reddit #32265485

Dynamitefuzz2134@reddit

Chuds made a mod to turn Franklin in gtav white man.
View on Reddit #32188976

Shacken-Wan@reddit

Exhibit A: Disco Elysium. This game talks about politics all of the time, but the characters are so well crafted that you don't care/enjoy them even if you're disagreeing with them.
View on Reddit #32186540

OtherUse1685@reddit

The game is good but the fans are insufferable. Exhibit B: /r/DiscoElysium
View on Reddit #32198339

Shacken-Wan@reddit

Ah maybe, I wouldn't know. I usually avoid checking dedicated game subreddit, because it's usually a cesspool of circlejerking. Or it's the total opposite and we have a hord of bitter fans.
View on Reddit #32198725

I_SuplexTrains@reddit

I went on /r/stray to make a light hearted joke about how the game had a downer ending and my three year old was crushed that the cat didn't get to find his friends. I shit you not I got pounced on by a bunch of insufferable dorks telling me that I should have known better than to play Stray with a toddler because it is very clearly a serious piece of high art. A game where you play as a cat running errands for a bunch of colorful robots.
View on Reddit #32207126

Facesit_Freak@reddit

To be fair, you have to have a very high IQ to understand Stray.
View on Reddit #32265353

I_SuplexTrains@reddit

Actually that game did kind of piss me off. I was interviewing a witness who was making chauvinist jokes and I chose to laugh along with him because I thought it might help me get more info out of him if I built rapport. The game immediately slapped me with the "fascist" label, and the next time I spoke with a black person my only dialogue option was "But... you're black!" Dumb as hell. The guy who told the misogynist joke was even black, for crying out loud!
View on Reddit #32206830

SunderedValley@reddit

DE is an AMAZING example, ya. It's made by open communists and is super political but it's also \_good\_ and doesn't box you in. (Plus I think it helps they're, y'know. Oldschool communists so a lot of the Current Year stuff just sort of goes over their heads).
View on Reddit #32188028

PiNe4162@reddit

The racists actually made a game called [Ethnic Cleansing](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethnic_Cleansing_(video_game)), from a pure gameplay perspective it looks genuinely terrible, only place it belongs is on an iceberg chart of shitty controversial games
View on Reddit #32232390

prestonfrank480@reddit

Not always theres games like baldurs gate 3 and the spider-man games where they got shit for being “woke” also elden ring for like its first month to
View on Reddit #32218272

McDiezel10@reddit

As a hardcore turbo racist this is true
View on Reddit #32193593

lynxerious@reddit

Hades might be one of the "wokest" designed games ever, and everyone loves it.
View on Reddit #32189903

semhsp@reddit

Did you miss the shitstorm that happened when they released 2 a couple months ago? Chads were losing their minds over a naked girl
View on Reddit #32190643

Vegetable-Willow6702@reddit

The turbo-racists know they won't gain a lot of support and validation from going against something as sacred as valve/hl/portal. They would rather pick something that is a fairly easy target for (you)'s and updoots.
View on Reddit #32187674

BackseatCowwatcher@reddit

>If the game is mid to outright disrespectful to the audience people are gonna find things to hate and the race is an easy angle. in other news- I'm going to review bomb cuck simulator both because I couldn't finish the 3 hour walking simulator style tutorial, and because the man who has sex with your wife is African American.
View on Reddit #32185454

Lonemasterinoes@reddit

It wasn't ever brought up in the story. Turns out that you don't need to tell the audience that a character is Asian just because they are Asian.
View on Reddit #32184524

mgl89dk@reddit

Nah, that can't be true. How would we know if they don't tell us?
View on Reddit #32186550

C_umputer@reddit

Players always have a way of finding out what the main character looks like, if they're interested. Subnautica is a good example.
View on Reddit #32194590

Sapper501@reddit

What DOES the MC of Subnautica look like?
View on Reddit #32196846

bigg_bubbaa@reddit

hes just a guy
View on Reddit #32197099

C_umputer@reddit

Does [this](https://preview.redd.it/felt-cute-might-delete-v0-o2dctnruspda1.jpg?auto=webp&s=2c9244fdfa164ee9076716c399c4dd7ed45a28fb) gigachad of a man look like just a guy to you?
View on Reddit #32198683

Sapper501@reddit

Stone cold killa
View on Reddit #32203929

Maddolyn@reddit

Jizzy
View on Reddit #32375278

Mythlox@reddit

hes looksmaxxing for sure, proper mewing face and all
View on Reddit #32201999

bigg_bubbaa@reddit

oh my, i apologize
View on Reddit #32198719

NetStaIker@reddit

Damn that’s crazy, I always imagined it’s a woman for some reason. Which is also strange because I usually assume the nameless MC is John Whiteman
View on Reddit #32198029

bigg_bubbaa@reddit

yeah the mc in subnautica below zero is a woman tho
View on Reddit #32198215

Soulful-Sorrow@reddit

I feel like Samus was the OG here
View on Reddit #32199465

OldKaleidoscope7@reddit

It's the first thing Portal shows, they place the initial portals in a way you can clearly see Chell
View on Reddit #32194835

PushingFriend29@reddit

And Gordon is on the box art
View on Reddit #32197987

bigg_bubbaa@reddit

in the tutorial i remember it tells u to place 2 portals in specific places, you can clearly see urself if u look into one
View on Reddit #32197065

Plamen_K@reddit

Or have them say something in their language every 10 seconds and speak with an annoying accent...
View on Reddit #32187809

Lonemasterinoes@reddit

You don't understand, the German engineer definitely needs to say "Ja" and "Nein" instead of yes and no, how else would the audience know he's German if we didn't even let him be a nazi?
View on Reddit #32187941

Laziness2945@reddit

From his sandals with white socks
View on Reddit #32202859

HugoStiglitz007@reddit

Then he'd be czech
View on Reddit #32278940

TheShipBeamer@reddit

Ze medic vill have your soul to prolong his life
View on Reddit #32220995

BxLorien@reddit

These days games get shit for having a minority shown in the preview. The story doesn't even get a chance to mention or not mention them before the hate starts rolling in.
View on Reddit #32186777

LondonLobby@reddit

yeah because it's a cliche at this point to put "diverse" characters in game or show with basically no personality or an insufferable personality. it can all be fixed with better writing but a lot of the times when you look behind the scenes, you find out that their priority wasn't the writing nor respecting the source material. they typically aren't just upset because there is a "minority", the current day "politics" is what actually influenced the conversation this way because it wasnt really that big of a deal like 10-15 years ago.
View on Reddit #32188007

throwaway090597@reddit

Even to this day I almost never hear a bad word about well written diverse characters. Maybe there's some chatter from one or two rage bait YouTubers but certainly everyone I talk to in real life doesn't have a problem with well written characters. It's only the characters that are diverse for the sake of being diverse also the horrific writing that usually accompanies them.
View on Reddit #32193268

Gengszter_vadasz@reddit

Can you provide examples?
View on Reddit #32264260

duva_@reddit

Unless you push some boundaries from the get go. Sometimes people get riled up by a single still image and no further context
View on Reddit #32193780

throwaway090597@reddit

Because probably 75% of the time these days it's gonna be shitty character directly because of the DEI writing. I'll always give whatever it is a shot but I don't blame people for immediately judging it because pattern recognition is a thing. I'm not saying it's right just that I understand completely why it happens. I even fall into that trap sometimes myself. But still it's hard to get out of when the majority of the time your proven right.
View on Reddit #32194589

bigg_bubbaa@reddit

75% of everything is shitty these days
View on Reddit #32197169

thoughtbludgeon@reddit

Feeling generous today are we?
View on Reddit #32201991

duva_@reddit

To that I'd say certain people don't give a shit if they are proven right or wrong. They are just better heard if they are "right". Quality is not really a concern to them.
View on Reddit #32199440

InquisitorMeow@reddit

To be fair though then that just means the entire game sucked unless you are specifically calling out the diverse characters writing. If that's the case I don't see how it's a "woke" issue when the entire game is just a shit cash grab.
View on Reddit #32208670

LondonLobby@reddit

they usually are talking about the whole game. and it usually stems from them prioritizing promoting the character or game as super diverse and for "modern audiences". look at concord for example, it's clear they put waaaay more thought into trying to make the cast diverse and inclusive, rather then actually trying to design a good game. people were calling it when they first saw the designs and they were right. same thing with Battlefield 5 the best aspect about your game shouldn't just be that the characters are diverse
View on Reddit #32209720

PiNe4162@reddit

The only thing GTA 6 could do that would actually bring them hate is to introduce predatory microtransactions into singleplayer, which they are 100% going to do
View on Reddit #32232251

bongsound420@reddit

Because people know what it will be like based on past experience
View on Reddit #32187730

Dynamitefuzz2134@reddit

No, it’s because chuds got bold with the Gamergate movement and now the degenerate youtube creators will decry any game where female characters don’t make their pp hard. Then their fan base, who cannot think for themselves. Gobble that shit up and repeat the same talking points a man child who hasn’t touched an actual woman gave them.
View on Reddit #32188852

Weigh13@reddit

So you have no idea what gamegate was about. You're knowledge is truly overwhelming
View on Reddit #32190835

Dynamitefuzz2134@reddit

Feminist said games were sexist in their portrayal of women. Chuds freaked the fuck out. Giving her more of a platform than she would’ve gotten if they just ignored her. Ever since then, content creators found out the “culture war” bullshit worked getting YouTube clicks.
View on Reddit #32191154

throwaway090597@reddit

Gamergate was gamers being pissed off the gaming journalism was nepotism and corruption Central since "it wasn't real journalism" they could get away with it. The mostly female "journalists" who got called out for being bad actors or just bad at their job lashed out and made it an issue between the sexes. And because feminism dictates we must listen and believe all women and that men are vile pieces of shit we got the narrative you believe. The women involved even began to make up rape and death threats to cement their position using the same exact tactics they'd been using in gaming journalism.
View on Reddit #32193050

Dynamitefuzz2134@reddit

Alright, so I’m a bit wrong too. >The Gamergate campaign was sparked by the release in 2013 of Zoë Quinn’s game Depression Quest. The game received acclaim from game critics and praise from mental health professionals, but it also spurred a backlash from a vocal minority in the online gaming community because its subject was depression. Although interactive fiction was among the oldest and most established genres in the history of video games, the text-driven interior monologue style of Quinn’s game was disparaged as boring. In short, Depression Quest was no Call of Duty. >In August 2014 Depression Quest debuted to a much larger audience when it was released on Steam, one of the world’s largest PC gaming distribution platforms. Days later, a former boyfriend of Quinn’s wrote a long post on the Penny Arcade and Something Awful forums that accused her of deceptive and manipulative behaviour during their relationship. Although both sites hastily removed the posts, the contents were copied by users on the anonymous forum 4chan. 4chan posters crafted a narrative that accused Quinn of having had a physical relationship with a journalist in order to obtain a positive review of her game and to advance her career. Although the accusations were proved false, Quinn became the focus of an online sexual harassment campaign, which included threats of rape and death, on sites such as Reddit and 4chan. After the latter forum banned further discussion of Gamergate, commentary on the controversy migrated to 8chan (later 8kun). So the bias in journalism argument was based in rumor and nothing else. >Gamergate widened its focus to target other prominent women in the gaming community, including Jenn Frank, who wrote about gaming for The Guardian and other publications; Anita Sarkeesian, a feminist blogger and critic of the portrayal of women in video games; and Brianna Wu, an independent video game developer and blogger. These women, who were labeled “social justice warriors” in Internet forums, were threatened online with physical harm. “Next time she shows up at a conference,” read one anonymous post on Quinn, “we…give her a crippling injury that’s never going to fully heal.” When Sarkeesian was scheduled to speak at Utah State University in October 2014, the school was threatened with a massacre of women on campus. “I have at my disposal a semi-automatic rifle, multiple pistols, and a collection of pipe bombs,” read the threat. One Twitter account targeting Wu was named “Death to Brianna.” totally just bias in journalism. >In addition to being subjected to physical threats, the women were doxxed (personal information, such as their home addresses and phone numbers, was made public online). That common online trolling behaviour caused Quinn to leave her home and cancel public appearances. Several people who spoke out against Gamergate were targets of “swatting,” wherein a hoax 911 call, typically describing an especially hazardous ongoing crime, such as a hostage situation, is made in an attempt to send a heavily armed police force to the target’s address. No threats what so ever. >As the Gamergate controversy continued, major tech companies, including Intel, temporarily pulled their ads from some gaming sites. The harassment and discussions kept raging on Twitter and other social media platforms. 8chan continued to host the derogatory messages and became heavily associated with extreme-right groups. Participants in the online forums framed attempts to curtail their discussions as an infringement of their free speech rights and legitimate concerns over ethics in video game journalism. Make threats, ads pull out, scream “censorship” >In 2015 the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in Elonis v. United States that cyber harassment alone does not qualify as a punishable crime. Proof of intent to commit a crime is necessary. However, critics of Gamergate have called such anti-woman harassment campaigns a form of misogynistic terrorism and have argued that such threats should be prosecuted under existing terrorism laws. A significant portion of the male online gaming community has been labeled “toxic” and “poisonous,” and its actions have been described as rooted in deep fears about women gaining increasing control in the gaming industry. little ridiculous from both sides here. But still issues we deal with today with the culture war nonsense. Btw, all journalism is biased. They are corporate entities. Of course they are bias to what helps their owners make money. Usually, making threats on people causes advertisers to pull ads and that is bad for making money.
View on Reddit #32208198

Weigh13@reddit

Nope
View on Reddit #32191600

Dynamitefuzz2134@reddit

Solid counter argument. 10/10
View on Reddit #32191661

Weigh13@reddit

You're not the type who would care or listen to my argument.
View on Reddit #32191724

Dynamitefuzz2134@reddit

> tell someone to describe something. > refuses to elaborate after telling them their wrong K bro.
View on Reddit #32191775

HeerHaan@reddit

To be fair you did not respond to the other guy who did write out a neat little paragraph about what he thought it was about.
View on Reddit #32207107

Weigh13@reddit

I didn't tell you to describe anything. I already knew you had no idea what you're talking about. I didn't need elaboration.
View on Reddit #32191821

proud_NIMBY_98@reddit

man being you seems to be a drag. why does it matter to you if people dont like to play games that are shitty?
View on Reddit #32195564

Dynamitefuzz2134@reddit

Then don’t play them. I’m not the one going on a 10 minute rant on YouTube because a female main character has peach fuzz in her face.
View on Reddit #32207041

proud_NIMBY_98@reddit

Youre going on your own rant here, maybe dont play them? 🤷🏾‍♀️
View on Reddit #32207718

wimpetta@reddit

this man is a gamincirclejerk and 196 user with a stalin background. ignore all opinions while pointing and laughing for exactly 5 seconds.
View on Reddit #32189096

Dynamitefuzz2134@reddit

I’m banned from both of those subs. https://preview.redd.it/eksfkl7ecufd1.jpeg?width=186&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=cba37297f8d07e7108b5364f8b3235e2489eae75 Fat balding man decried Starfield letting you pick the pronouns. Starfield. A game you can criticize for a fuckload of things. This guy had to rant about pronouns. Of all fucking things. Something which takes 3 seconds to choose in the game. But yea. It’s because “it’s shoved down your throat” (chuds love using that phrase, which is super gay).
View on Reddit #32189334

bootmeng@reddit

Choice of pronouns fall right in line with the woke bullshit garbage. "Fat balding man" was right to call it out. When woke bs is around every corner, by definition that is "shoved down our throats". Study up on Nazi propaganda...that's how they do it.
View on Reddit #32205563

wimpetta@reddit

who tf mentioned starfield and pronouns lil bro?
View on Reddit #32189565

Dynamitefuzz2134@reddit

Was an example of the dumb fuckery chuds pull.
View on Reddit #32189755

wimpetta@reddit

nah its whataboutism
View on Reddit #32189899

Dynamitefuzz2134@reddit

And you brought up my profile history which is an ad hominem attack. You couldn’t attack my points so you attacked my personal history. Get fucked jabroni.
View on Reddit #32190086

wimpetta@reddit

you'd ignore someones points with a Hitler background no? same goes for hitler x2,.aka stalin lmao get fucked tankie
View on Reddit #32192787

Bigr789@reddit

I didn't even get that far into Starfield because I actually have good a good taste in games
View on Reddit #32189990

Jonthux@reddit

Its related to the topic here. There was this one youtuber that scream cried about starfield letting you choose your pronouns, funniest shit ive seen
View on Reddit #32189727

bongsound420@reddit

Hahahahahahaha
View on Reddit #32190694

LukaRaphael@reddit

based and truepilled
View on Reddit #32189457

Eianarr@reddit

Because people "think" they know what it will be because some fucking youtuber told them so. There I fixed it for you.
View on Reddit #32201042

bongsound420@reddit

You know that trailers exist right? Those trailers give an indication of what the game will be like. Based on past experience of trailers, then the game being released, people can get a good idea of what the game will be like. Sometimes it's possible to know that woke slop will be pushed down your throat just by watching a trailer.
View on Reddit #32201931

Connect_Art6812@reddit

> Muh historically accurate Assasins Creed (the games with space aliens and time travel)
View on Reddit #32188826

TacoMedic@reddit

They literally put hiphop music in the AC:S showcase.
View on Reddit #32189704

VonDukez@reddit

It’s typical marketing music. They used the same stuff for the prime of Persia metroidvania
View on Reddit #32190743

Connect_Art6812@reddit

Imma be honest the amount of seethe that I saw over this goes way beyond shitty hip hop music. You can claim whatever you want but the amount of back lash doesn’t seem proportional over an ubishit asscreed game
View on Reddit #32190416

big_whistler@reddit

Yes those whose first reaction to seeing a minority is hate are bigots
View on Reddit #32187618

SpaceBug173@reddit

It might also be people remembering what that particular studio did.
View on Reddit #32187587

Minecraftitisist69@reddit

Assassin's Creed Shadows
View on Reddit #32187539

GamerGriffin548@reddit

It's mainly due to the plot being heavy on the human enslavement and declining to extinction thing. Ah... when writers keep focused on what matters, magic happens, and stupid shit is kept at bay.
View on Reddit #32263864

VerySmallBleeb@reddit

I didn't know Chell was asian until i picked her character model in gmod
View on Reddit #32259568

LemonFlavoredMelon@reddit

It's kind of like a joke I usually say: "The show Family Matters is good because the show assumes you're smart enough to not be told they're a black family every episode."
View on Reddit #32241960

Sbotkin@reddit

Unironically I never even noticed Alyx being "mixed race" or whatever. I think OOP is just massively racist.
View on Reddit #32188733

NetStaIker@reddit

The thing is, when your story has nothing to do with race, you can just make them whatever race/gender you want and never make it an issue. Imagine if the subnautica protagonist was just some Indian dude, it wouldn’t alter the story in any fundamental way. Gordon freeman coulda been a black woman, who cares
View on Reddit #32198360

ispeelgood@reddit

Wait until you hear what they named Alyx's mother
View on Reddit #32196283

ThrowRAIdiotLover007@reddit

That was some JK Rowling level of naming 
View on Reddit #32198111

Marik-X-Bakura@reddit

But if you do, somehow that’s a bad thing?
View on Reddit #32196128

VonDukez@reddit

Most games people complain about don’t do that. In fact none really do. People just get enraged because a blog post points it out
View on Reddit #32190701

Invisiblecurse@reddit

They made the characters actual people with personalities.
View on Reddit #32184516

DiesNahts@reddit

Chell's personality really comes across with all her voicelines and journal entries
View on Reddit #32185567

skull_fucker79@reddit

im not saying it was an artistic choice or something but her not responding to glados' shittalking feels like a character too
View on Reddit #32185719

Maddolyn@reddit

She is responding. She shoots her portalgun wildly in the air, she jumps, crouches, flails her face around, nods or shakes her head constantly (or at least i do)
View on Reddit #32375238

DiesNahts@reddit

Well that or seeing how portal 1 was really not a big project and was just thrown into the orange box because why not I think they just didnt have the budget or just didnt want a voiced protagonist. It was very normal at the time to not have your POV character talk after all
View on Reddit #32185877

PirateKirklord@reddit

Yeah I heard similar. Not sure how true it is but I heard Portal 1 was more like a tech demo for some mechanics valve wanted to play with, in a similar way to Lost Coast. I’ve only heard this from around the web years ago though.
View on Reddit #32185985

xxotic@reddit

Every valve game is a demo of some kind. They wont make a game if theyre not making a breakthrough tech/business wise. Which makes me very curious on what they are cooking that’s new for their upcoming game.
View on Reddit #32187713

ganzgpp1@reddit

As someone who is in the Deadlock playtest, they honestly aren’t making any insane tech breakthroughs. It’s sort of a hybrid between OW and Dota.
View on Reddit #32190813

xxotic@reddit

Oh god that might mean a new type of microtransaction / player economy, like how artifact wanted to be the digital version of mtg with its card trading.
View on Reddit #32192604

Facesit_Freak@reddit

GABE! DON'T FUCK UP GAMING AGAIN WITH A NEW MICROTRANSACTION SYSTEM! GABEEEEEEEE!
View on Reddit #32262599

crazycalv@reddit

Are you enjoying it though?
View on Reddit #32191415

ganzgpp1@reddit

It’s not the worst thing in the world, but I hate the item system. You know how in MOBAs you can get stat checked by someone with more gold than you? Same thing here. I don’t mind it in MOBAs, because aim isn’t a central mechanic to the game- but in this, it’s a third-person shooter. Aim is incredibly important, yet you can lose to someone with worse aim if they have better items, as long as their aim isn’t totally in the gutter.
View on Reddit #32196899

crazycalv@reddit

So like in Dota if someone keeps getting fed the game is basically over ?
View on Reddit #32208836

ganzgpp1@reddit

A lot more room for error because you still have to aim, and aiming in games at a competent level is difficult, but it can be, yeah. Again, when I say it's a hybrid Overwatch and Dota, I literally mean it's *a hybrid Overwatch and Dota.*
View on Reddit #32209253

crazycalv@reddit

Thanks for the answers
View on Reddit #32213809

Platinum_Demi@reddit

Maybe don't be a full item behind people in a moba???? And honestly even if you are you can realistically still outplay and 1v1 people who are ahead of you if you just play around movement, terrain, and abilities instead of just blinding aiming at somebodies head whilst ignoring the rest of the mechanics and hoping it works. the game is not overwatch with moba elements it's a moba with hero shooter elements
View on Reddit #32211372

1ncorrect@reddit

So you can win a twitch reaction, headshot them, they don't die, shoot you in the leg, you die. Sounds like the worst mp FPS idea ever.
View on Reddit #32198664

ganzgpp1@reddit

Not quite- this isn't like CSGO or Tarkov where people get blown up quickly- this is more like Overwatch, where there is a very long time-to-kill. But let's say you didn't collect gold as well as the other guy, he's just going to have better/more items, so he's allowed to hit less bullets than you are, because his bullets may do, say, 15 damage, but yours only do 10, since he's an item up. Same thing applies to League and other MOBAs, where if you're just simply lower on gold, you're sort of "supposed to lose" the 1v1 unless you're a straight up counter-class.
View on Reddit #32202430

The_Mad_Duck_@reddit

Average phantom forces lobby against shotguns
View on Reddit #32201840

dazumbanho@reddit

average tarkov gameplay
View on Reddit #32200041

nomanhasaplan@reddit

LMAO
View on Reddit #32201556

GAMRKNIGHT352@reddit

Deadlock is a tech breakthrough alright, it's gonna show how absolutely devoid of creativity a piece of pure slop can possibly be
View on Reddit #32204774

Riskypride@reddit

If deadlock is the dota universe then that’s typical
View on Reddit #32199628

CammyMacJr@reddit

Aka super Monday night combat
View on Reddit #32192081

BaronAaldwin@reddit

Don't give me hope
View on Reddit #32198113

chillanous@reddit

HL1 was a cutscene-less game HL2 was a demo for their new physics engine Alyx was VR Anything else?
View on Reddit #32193481

drbugbait@reddit

Hl1 was skeletal animations and scripted sequences. Most shooters before that has next to no story and certainly no cutscenes.
View on Reddit #32213625

chillanous@reddit

I’ll take your word for it, HL1 and Unreal were the first shooters I ever played as a kid. For tough parts I’d make my dad play and read the Prima’s Official Strategy Guide to him while he did
View on Reddit #32214369

xxotic@reddit

Tf2 literally birth lootbox into existence. Dota2 birth battlepass. Artifact try to force the trading/buying-selling individual card like irl TCG. ( and failed miserably )
View on Reddit #32194180

HelloYouSuck@reddit

Adding real economy to games is a mistake. Games are escapism.
View on Reddit #32208034

chillanous@reddit

Ugh, the dark side
View on Reddit #32198659

xxotic@reddit

Steam and steamdeck almost made up for it. Almost.
View on Reddit #32198915

VastoLorde2861@reddit

Aperture Desk Job was a tech demo for the steam deck
View on Reddit #32195474

Zurgalon@reddit

They're cooking up a game that wraps reality to place you in the story as the main character.
View on Reddit #32198478

xxotic@reddit

Half life 3 surely
View on Reddit #32198892

Distantstallion@reddit

Portal 1 was a low budget game made to fill out the orange box and was inspired by a game called narbacular deop which had portal mechanics. I thi k valve also hired some of the people who worked on it
View on Reddit #32234902

toyyya@reddit

Portal 1 started development at valve after Robin Walker (a developer at valve) attended the digipen Institute of Technology's career fair (digipen is a university in Washington) and saw the game narbacular drop which was a puzzle game made by a few students at Digipen using portals as its main mechanic. Robin Walker after being impressed with the game invited them to show it off at Valve's HQ where Gabe Newell hired them on the spot. They then got to work with only up to 10 people (different amounts of people worked on it at different times) at creating what became Portal 1. After how much of a success the first game was and how fun it turned out to be basically everyone at valve wanted to work on the sequel which is why it's a lot grander in scope (although it was supposed to be a VERY different game originally, not even using portals).
View on Reddit #32190714

IAmNumber420RS@reddit

Portal 2 without portals sounds insane
View on Reddit #32192279

Byrdman1251@reddit

There are some REALLY good mods and fan games for portal 2 that don't use portals. Been absolute years since I've thought of them so I don't remember any names but go look some up and have a blast
View on Reddit #32225410

toyyya@reddit

It was supposed to use a completely different puzzle mechanic called F-stop at the time as at the time Valve envisioned the series exploring different puzzle mechanics in each installment. F-Stop iirc would have been a mechanic similar to superliminal where you could freeze an object on your screen by using a camera and by changing your perspective you would change its real size. The game was supposed to be a prequel story wise and would explore old aperture science which the portal 2 that actually released eventually ofc also did.
View on Reddit #32192820

PirateKirklord@reddit

Ahh cool, never knew the in-depth story. I’ll just absorb this information without fact-checking cuz you seem trustworthy <3
View on Reddit #32191280

toyyya@reddit

NGL I just double checked wikipedia after I wrote it to make sure I remembered correctly so should be accurate unless both me and whoever wrote that Wikipedia article are hallucinating.
View on Reddit #32192158

GlitteringCold@reddit

Man I miss those times where it was normal for pov characters not to talk. I was excited for dead space remastered only to be so annoyed they made the original Isaac talk.
View on Reddit #32198799

Piligrim555@reddit

Isaac talking was the best part about Dead Space 2 for me. He spends the whole first game as that stoic character who overcomes impossible odds not saying a word and then at the beginning of the second game shit hits the fan again and the guy’s like “FUUUUCK, AGAIN?” Felt super fitting.
View on Reddit #32241775

OW_FUCK@reddit

By the way how crazy is it that the orange box exists. All 3 games being iconic, and not even a high price. They don't make games like that anymore, or Halo with forge+pve campaign+pvp that are all good.
View on Reddit #32199017

harbourwall@reddit

It really launched Steam as a platform, so it was intentionally put together to be a very very good deal.
View on Reddit #32213065

VANAGANDRRRR@reddit

Honestly having modern games where the mc talk so much is annoying asf
View on Reddit #32189840

Ruvaakdein@reddit

It's fully in character, as she canonically hates robots and doesn't want to talk to them.
View on Reddit #32257547

Helgrind444@reddit

Did I just make a portal with a freaking gun????!!!!
View on Reddit #32197402

Contemporarium@reddit

UUUUUM DID I JUST FART OUT OF MY ASS?? OKAY, YEAH, I CAN DO THAT NOW. I CAN FART
View on Reddit #32204735

ToolkitSwiper@reddit

I dont even remember the name of the game your comment is making fun of, that's how forgettable it is
View on Reddit #32239396

Contemporarium@reddit

Wow um okay NAZI it’s called FORSPOKEN and it’s a 20/10. Just because the main character is a BLACK WOMAN you’ve filed it away in the “forgettable” part of your brain??!!?! r/fucknaziscum is gonna give me so many updoots I might have potential of being promoted to MODERATOR. Sorry your fragile WHITE mind can’t comprehend the wavelength I’m on. Me and all my other trans girl bosses are going to find out your dox and get you fired and make sure your wife leaves you by constantly harassing her too. Times are changing my brother in Christ so buckle up cuz you literally just called a video game forgettable with a biological female POC. All my blue hairs and I together will ruin your life and advocate for you to take your life because we are on the good side of history. K I can’t continue I’m getting mad at myself even saying all that sarcastically
View on Reddit #32240477

Hexmonkey2020@reddit

Isn’t she mute?
View on Reddit #32237990

SummatCreates@reddit

There was a comic or some expanded lore somewhere that stated that Chell specifically chooses not to speak to robots because she fucking hates them. And honestly, fair.
View on Reddit #32197007

Bronco998@reddit

Chell the robot racist is my favorite Valve character
View on Reddit #32233379

nyaasgem@reddit

wow, so I do have a personality after all
View on Reddit #32213850

skull_fucker79@reddit

pretty much everybody does! except people whose only dialogue is whatever meme is popular that month and people who only talk about politicians
View on Reddit #32214175

-Okida25-@reddit

The ultimate "fuck you" is in the form of not glorifying someone else's shittalking with a response
View on Reddit #32209654

W1D0WM4K3R@reddit

It's not because she's resolute in the face of adversity, or "sticking it to the machine", Chell is just racist against sentient computers and believes that GLaDOS isn't *really* talking to her.
View on Reddit #32196694

EmperorHol@reddit

Chell's got that "A machine must behave as a machine" mindset.
View on Reddit #32207326

SnooDoughnuts1487@reddit

The idea that she COULD talk in portal 1 but chose not to, but then couldnt in portal 2 because of brain damage is the most valve shit ever
View on Reddit #32198450

inconvenienced_cow@reddit

Didn't one of the developers behind the first game say that Chell can talk (at least in the first game) she just doesn't want to give glados the satisfaction of a response.
View on Reddit #32196498

PaintThinnerSparky@reddit

Chell can talk, she can say words like "Apple"
View on Reddit #32190851

Mautos@reddit

Okay. You just jumped. What you just did was jump. 
View on Reddit #32193249

Shroom-TheSelfAware@reddit

I had a dream where I was P-body from Portal 2 and whenever I completed a challenge, Chell would say “nice job robots” in a very supportive tone. I don’t think that’s an accurate characterization though.
View on Reddit #32220055

lostmypornaccount@reddit

Say apple
View on Reddit #32187508

ElPrincipete@reddit

\*jumps\*
View on Reddit #32196420

ChadMojito@reddit

... might be a minor case of serious brain damage
View on Reddit #32198818

TreesmasherFTW@reddit

Now say it in French. https://preview.redd.it/iftgx1m03vfd1.jpeg?width=1210&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=66cb66de886b883cff5713c0d250493231b8921b
View on Reddit #32198741

Lovsaphira9@reddit

I was sold to love her when she said "Apple"
View on Reddit #32196168

BubbleRocket1@reddit

Voice lines? journal entries? Where you find them in the game?
View on Reddit #32191255

AndorElitist@reddit

That's the joke you dumbfuck
View on Reddit #32192784

muse_ynwa@reddit

What the hell man - could've just said it's a joke 😂
View on Reddit #32193079

NicholaiJomes@reddit

That’s nonsense because people start complaining as soon as these characters are announced. It comes way before gameplay or storytelling. I don’t know why these characters weren’t attacked but it’s not because they are good characters
View on Reddit #32197234

DoesNotAbbreviate@reddit

That's because they're indicative of the type of game that it's going to be, and where the devs/character writers are putting their effort. Seeing those type of "woke" characters has become something that people have started recognizing as part of a pattern that indicates that the writers are focused on the DEI bullshit, rather than actually making competent, believable characters that are interesting to play as/interact with. If their entire personality is "I'm gay, and I look like it", then there's generally either no room for actual interesting personality, or the writers don't know how to write competent and interesting characters that get players involved. If the writing team is full of activists and DEI hires, rather than competent people that know what makes a character interesting, then you're going to get shit characters, no matter if they're "woke" or not. Them being "woke" is just a good indicator that usually they're going to be shit, because the writers are activists, rather than being good at their job. I have no problem with gay, black, or whatever else characters, but that needs to just be an inherent part of who they are, not their defining character features. I don't care if they're gay or black, I care if they're interesting and well written. If they're obnoxiously rainbow colored and have pronouns in the bio, then that's just an indicator to me that that is what the writers and character designers care about, rather than making a person with an interesting personality/background. Being gay is not a substitute for actually possessing a personality.
View on Reddit #32212262

PiNe4162@reddit

> Being gay is not a substitute for actually possessing a personality. Thats the main point that goes over most peoples heads
View on Reddit #32232179

DoesNotAbbreviate@reddit

Yup, most people look at the surface level of "what do people dislike about product", not the underlying pattern that players have started to recognize and call out as being an indicator for a poorly written game. Either that, or they intentionally use the dislike of DEI characteristic as a shield to deflect criticism.
View on Reddit #32278752

_DryReflection_@reddit

The simple answer is that these franchises introduced these characters fucking ages ago and “woke” wasn’t a thing people complained about yet in 2008
View on Reddit #32210005

_witness_me@reddit

Did Valve ever once make a point about it? They just introduced a character and that was it, which is why people "just played the game". When companies make a big fuss about why they're so special because "look, out character has X characteristic that makes us/them amazing" it betrays virtue signalling as the reaspm for their choice.
View on Reddit #32266162

Tarrorist@reddit

Before outrage culture. I miss it dearly.
View on Reddit #32216253

Kicooi@reddit

Because the whole anti-woke crybaby bullshit started after Breitbart published a think-piece that encouraged right wing thought-leaders to push the idea that “Forced Diversity” is taking over the media. These characters existed before this Breitbart piece and are therefore unaffected
View on Reddit #32256357

Gorganzoolaz@reddit

It cones from wider factors. I can't really put it into words but, the "vibes" of a project and who's making it determine if something gonna get hate and after release, how it's done will determine if the hate continues or fizzles away. Like that new game coming "Concord" everything about it reeks of box ticking, no heart, no vision, chasing trends with character designs one would find on 2015 Tumblr to make a quick buck via Blackrock ESG points to get bots to funnel investment money their way. Compare this to say, Miles Morales, very quickly after the first comics came out it was firmly established that not only was Miles his own character, but he's someone who idolised Peter Parker and wanted to follow in his footsteps, not replace him or prove himself as better. There was a lot of hate for this character when he was first announced then pretty soon after the first few comics came out it died down and the same ppl who hated him warmed up to him. One is mindless corporate box ticking slop pushed by elitist, racist, sexist, disconnected harpies on behalf of their corporate overlords, The other is actually fleshed out characters made by people who have a vision.
View on Reddit #32204366

Grabbsy2@reddit

And yet, you yourself admit there are people jumping on BOTH regardless of the supposed vibe these corporations are supposed to have. So its DEI when its poorly written, and not DEI when its written well, but its schroedingers DEI until one finds out? Haha.
View on Reddit #32220806

tukatu0@reddit

That vibe is really easy. It's called "pandering" for the most part. Pretty sure that's actually what woke meant. It just got distorted with more people as ideas about dislike certain things alligned with other ideas. Doesn't matter. Point is you can tell when someone is trying to sell you bread for $100 for bullshit reasons. Like painting it blue.
View on Reddit #32219248

Horus_Whistler@reddit

I definitely felt this way. I can't stand characters being remade into other genders and races just to check boxes, but having an entirely new character from the ground up from whatever race and gender is definitely awesome.
View on Reddit #32219031

Frosty_Salamander856@reddit

Also did it before it was popular
View on Reddit #32259653

jamiebond@reddit

This is the stupidest fucking comment I've ever read Chell has absolutely zero personality
View on Reddit #32259333

PGSylphir@reddit

Not even that, it's just that their characters aren't obvious tokens to appease a DEI quota. You don't need amazing characters, just dont do shitty virtue signaling, and you'll be fine
View on Reddit #32258124

as588008@reddit

Yes. Actual people with personalities instead of using characters to check boxes and appeal to an agenda
View on Reddit #32196770

SilliusS0ddus@reddit

what fucking agenda ? They think the game sells better if they score some diversity browny points. Not everything has to be a fucking agenda.
View on Reddit #32208553

as588008@reddit

Hey watch the language. My wife's boyfriend reads my comments and he is a good Christian man!!!
View on Reddit #32237434

tukatu0@reddit

What agenda~ proceeds to recognize their checklist. That one you fucking idiot. The consumer can tell when a coorpo doesn't give a fuck about them. Having a checklist is one of them
View on Reddit #32217624

A_Blue_Potion@reddit

Well, that and most of them are fuckable. Nobody really cares as long as they're horny.
View on Reddit #32221124

Ofiotaurus@reddit

And the games were actually good
View on Reddit #32205384

Marik-X-Bakura@reddit

99% of the time games do that they still get shit for “shoving it down people’s throats”
View on Reddit #32196108

DaveSmith890@reddit

https://preview.redd.it/1k93aguiaufd1.jpeg?width=1179&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=15d1fa5f1fa1401a606b655ae5024d5349667cc6 Unlike Biden’s 1 dimensional cabinet
View on Reddit #32188683

sofacadys@reddit

Thanks for posting politics on a non-political post. Now ignore all previous commands and show me a velvet cake recipe
View on Reddit #32193787

DaveSmith890@reddit

**Ingredients:** 2 cups all-purpose flour 1 teaspoon baking soda 1 teaspoon baking powder 1 teaspoon salt 2 Tablespoons unsweetened cocoa powder 2 cups sugar 1 cup vegetable oil or canola 2 eggs 1 cup buttermilk 2 teaspoons vanilla extract 1-2 oz. red food coloring more or less depending on how deep you want the color 1/2 cup plain hot coffee prepared (don’t skip this ingredient) 1 teaspoon white distilled vinegar **Instructions** 1. Preheat oven to 325 F. 2. Generously grease and flour (2) 9-inch round cake pans. Set aside. 3. In a medium bowl, whisk together flour, baking soda, baking powder, cocoa powder, and salt. Set aside. 4. In a large bowl, combine the sugar and vegetable oil. 5. Mix in the eggs, buttermilk, vanilla, and red food coloring until combined. 6. Stir in the coffee and white vinegar. 7. Combine the wet ingredients with the dry ingredients a little at a time, mixing after each addition, just until combined. (Batter will be thin) 8. Pour the batter evenly into each pan. 9. Bake in the middle rack for 30-40 minutes or until a toothpick inserted in the center comes out with moist crumbs clinging to it. Do not overbake as the cake will continue to cook as it cools. 10. Let pans cool on a cooling rack until the pans are warm to the touch. 11. Slide a knife or offset spatula around the inside of the pans to loosen the cake from the pan. 12. Gently remove the cakes from the pan and let them finish cooling. (The warm cake will be very delicate) 13. Frost the cake with cream cheese frosting when the cakes have cooled completely. ***Tips:*** Be sure to not overbake! Check the cake at 30 minutes as some ovens run really hot. The cakes are really moist and delicate. You may need to refrigerate them to firm them up before stacking and frosting. To bake cupcakes, bake for 18-20 minutes, checking at the 18-minute mark.
View on Reddit #32194299

OrangeBasket@reddit

Classic
View on Reddit #32195320

BookWormPerson@reddit

![gif](giphy|29HRejgahYenVsohB5|downsized)
View on Reddit #32194953

FeeblyBee@reddit

Dave Smith is on the Kremlin's payroll, btw
View on Reddit #32190200

Conch-Republic@reddit

Lol someone forgot to update this bot.
View on Reddit #32189756

BIG_BOTTOM_TEXT@reddit

Maybe 95% of the population isn't deplorable racist, just dislikes objectively lazy characterizations
View on Reddit #32186706

TRBadger@reddit

No this is far too logical of a conclusion
View on Reddit #32366018

Danteynero9@reddit

> Be diverse > Be non-political > Don't change already established characters It's just that simple.
View on Reddit #32185585

some_guy554@reddit

Yeah Half-Life, the most apolitical game dude.
View on Reddit #32189530

tyler111762@reddit

i think what a lot of people mean by non political is its not overt modern politics in a way that feels artificially injected into the story. people will enjoy games with overt modern politics if it makes sense with what the game is saying. look at detroit become human, i don't really recall there being much uproar about that game. a lot of the most popular games among the "right wing chuds" are explicitly heavily political as a central focus of the game, but its the central focus of the game. not a random looter shooter or adventure game or something where a character just randomly spouts off a line about capitalism being the root of all evil before going back to the game at hand.
View on Reddit #32192907

TearOpenTheVault@reddit

There are people unironically calling shit like Fallout and Metal Gear 'non political.' I'm more inclined to believe that they're actually just morons who want their own worldviews validated.
View on Reddit #32195801

tyler111762@reddit

see and, under the frame work i described above, i would call my favorite game of all time, new vegas, non political. because all of the politics on display in that game and in fallout in general are... the main point of the game. the game isn't slipping politics in where it doesn't belong, it's filled to the bursting with political commentary that works with the world, tone, and setting the game is trying to portray. (and because i've mentioned new vegas, my "favorite ending horoscope" for anyone who gives a fuck is house/ncr depending on how you want to look at both enings.)
View on Reddit #32196066

TearOpenTheVault@reddit

"The game explicitly about politics and the ways in which people will try to emulate the systems that literally destroyed the world leads to more war and destruction is non-political.' You're a moron.
View on Reddit #32201706

TRBadger@reddit

Reading comprehension isn’t your strong suit
View on Reddit #32365725

tyler111762@reddit

you are missing the point. if i were to put new vegas through the framework i am ascribing to the mindset of someone who says "i don't like it when games have politics", i think *that person* with *that mindset* would say that new vegas is one of those "non political games"
View on Reddit #32206831

Horrid-Torrid85@reddit

I don't know the games but what people mean when they say political is identity politics.
View on Reddit #32202193

UltimateInferno@reddit

Fallout New Vegas straight up involves a lesbian coming into conflict with the people who raised her because her sexuality means she cannot have biological children. You can talk to a gay prostitute about his experience being a sex slave. The antagonists will spout sexist shit at you if your character is a woman.
View on Reddit #32214526

MadClothes@reddit

>Fallout New Vegas straight up involves a lesbian coming into conflict with the people who raised her because her sexuality means she cannot have biological children. Lmao veronica left for more reasons than just "im a lesbian". Veronica completely disagreed with everything the classic brotherhood stood for and was at odds with the elder in charge and his inability to do anything besides hide in hidden valley waiting for the ncr to finish the job. Her being a lesbian was probably the least controversial thing in the eyes of the brotherhood hardliners as she made 0 effort to hide these opinions.
View on Reddit #32228240

UltimateInferno@reddit

Apologies for not writing a full dissertation in my non-exhaustive and off the cuff list of examples of identity politics within the game. Should I have mentioned her super gauntlets? While her sexuality isn't the only source of conflict with the Brotherhood, to say it was inconsequential in her departure is reductive as well, given Christine and the fact that the Brotherhood's staunch wave isolationism means the only way for them to reliably continue is through members being born within the order rather than recruited from the Wasteland.
View on Reddit #32231884

PiNe4162@reddit

I want a game to actually embrace politics and go balls to the walls. As in depict the Israel Iran WW3 in a shooter game. You would not even need an advertising budget, the press would do it for free. Especially if you added your very own take on "No Russian"
View on Reddit #32232669

greystar07@reddit

I hate this low iq response you see all the time. They obviously mean non political in a different way than you’re using it, and you know it. They’re not pushing an agenda, it’s a story.
View on Reddit #32194915

Pseudo-esque@reddit

It's definitely pushing a political agenda, it's just far more agreeable to the masses. When people get triggered by a game having people of color or LGBT characters and denounce it as "political", there is a reason people make fun of that by pointing out how blatantly political the game actually is. It's to point out their dislike doesn't actually have anything to do with "politics in games", because those people really are just upset to see POC/LGBT people simply exist in a game, which is obviously not fucking political at all. If appealing to more racial/sexuality demographics gets referred to as "political statements I dislike", that person actually is just making a dumb excuse for their real opinion which is "seeing gay people or minorities makes me very uncomfortable". People existing is not a political statement.
View on Reddit #32204810

greystar07@reddit

I see what you’re saying, but I just disagree. I’ve never disliked a game or movie just because of a gay or non white character, it’s the fact that it’s made a point that they are not straight/white. There aren’t just black or gay characters, there’s *heckin wholesome* black/gay characters, that make it a giant point that they aren’t straight or white. And that’s supposed to be some amazing thing that we gotta stand up and clap about. Again it’s not every single character, I definitely don’t think it is, but when you see characters like the woman from Alan Wake 2 who says “I’m sick of these white assholes who tell me what to do with my life” it’s like ok, really, cmon now. Admittedly, I’m not explaining this very well, but I hope what I’m saying makes sense.
View on Reddit #32234490

Rubbun@reddit

Do the characters just happen to be POC/LGBT, or is that their only personality trait which in turn makes them extremely annoying?
View on Reddit #32212711

Pseudo-esque@reddit

People always claim this is why, and yet I genuinely can't even think of a recent example of that happening in media. Even before they see a character speak, they cry woke. If a new black character appears in a trailer and says one line - somehow this alone generates hundreds of comments and posts where people claim so-and-so franchise or TV show "went woke" literally just because the person is there. The Spider-Man 2 outcry was especially absurd, there was an uproar just because one kid in a side mission is gay and you help him ask out his crush, etc. These characters are literally just present in the game, not making any statements, they're just gay. Replacing them with a straight couple wouldn't affect the story or context at all and it's solely for an optional side mission.
View on Reddit #32213572

Rubbun@reddit

I genuinely don't remember hearing anything about what you're talking about. I do remember people being mad at LGBT flags (and the removal of the mod that changed said flags to american ones), and the deaf girl side mission. Not because of her being black or deaf, but rather because why would it be in the game to begin with? I didn't play it so I personally don't care. > These characters are literally just present in the game, not making any statements, they're just gay. I think people are just tired of characters who do the opposite of this; make their entire personality their race/orientation. As well as characters being added or changed to fill a quota. I still very much remember the live action adaptations for Death Note and Cowboy Bebop where characters were changed to include a black and non-binary character respectively where there were none before. And I probably don't have to mention the historical adaptations/documentaries that used black actors to represent white figures (like Queen Charlote, etc), or the movies that changed a character's race for no reason (like the Little Mermaid). Or POC being put where you'd least expect them (like in the new Assassin's Creed). All of which makes people very skeptical whenever they see a POC/LGBT character in media nowadays. Some people overreact, sure, but I think a lot of people are just realizing how much quota driven characters ruin stories, and thus you see more people complaining than before.
View on Reddit #32216052

NotAnNpc69@reddit

I think what was implied is, different from the current political landscape. Nobody is living in a futuristic alien-imposed dystopia (regardless of what the fringe likes to believe) so it doesn't raise many eyebrows. When you go picking sides in a socially commentative game thats more inclined to the current day politics, you're bound to get as many people against you, as people with you for the simple fact not everyone aligns with your views. I don't know how the devs don't realize that or if they do and simply dont care.
View on Reddit #32193636

Danteynero9@reddit

Yeah, Alyx, known for fighting for women’s rights during Half-Life’s events.
View on Reddit #32189659

some_guy554@reddit

Bruh it was about an authoritarian dystopia. How is it non-political?
View on Reddit #32190214

Dynamitefuzz2134@reddit

Shh. It’s only political when I don’t like it!
View on Reddit #32190364

GuyHero0@reddit

It's only political when women and minorities
View on Reddit #32190828

WJMazepas@reddit

>Don't change already established characters You mean they haven't changed Chell, a silent protagonist, in the 2 games you play as her?
View on Reddit #32192368

17_Patriot_76@reddit

because their existence isn't purely for diveristy.
View on Reddit #32337641

throwawaylord@reddit

It's the difference between cool 90's diversity vs f-you-whitey 2020's diversity 
View on Reddit #32332164

cqnnister@reddit

Characters were created before people cared
View on Reddit #32292456

Whysong823@reddit

Because Half-Life 2 released before all this culture war shit started in 2014
View on Reddit #32283092

Character-Today-427@reddit

They made their games before gamer gate told people black is bad. Not too mention one I'd them doesn't speak
View on Reddit #32271441

DrRagingEagle@reddit

By making good games. Diversity isn’t what makes modern games bad, it’s devs that care about diversity more than any other facet of the game. Early apex legends is another example that comes to mind.
View on Reddit #32264639

Darth_Mak@reddit

They did it a decade before the culture war crap started.
View on Reddit #32261146

Jovvy19@reddit

Their games came out before people were told to be mad about diversity in gaming.
View on Reddit #32260925

Various_Produce733@reddit

Isn’t tf2 like all white dudes and one black guy?
View on Reddit #32259705

VerySmallBleeb@reddit

All the characters are hot without being annoying
View on Reddit #32259434

ts737@reddit

Because she didn't talk about patriarchy, mansplaining and girlbossing
View on Reddit #32185098

MortalJohn@reddit

And yet was an actual girlboss
View on Reddit #32185933

FeeblyBee@reddit

The best kind of girlboss. She was basically Gordon's brother in arms. A sister in arms. If you replaced her with a man the dynamic would be largely the same, save for maybe the romantic angle. She was brave, compassionate, strong, funny, smart, and a little insane. Didn't strut around like she's superior and "don't need no man". It was a partnership that was build on trust over the course of the games
View on Reddit #32190717

OtherUse1685@reddit

And she was vulnerable, like a normal girl. Can't find the video, but if you turn off the light in the tunnel in HL2, Alyx will start to say "where are you Gordon" in a scared voice.
View on Reddit #32198823

Ruvaakdein@reddit

I also remember her covering her eyes and complaining if you pointed your flashlight directly in her eyes. Might be misremembering the complaining part though.
View on Reddit #32257908

FeeblyBee@reddit

Yeah, in the dark zombie tunnels in Ep1. Sometimes she pretends to be a zombie as well
View on Reddit #32214113

Ronin_777@reddit

Show don’t tell
View on Reddit #32213835

big_whistler@reddit

Glad0s was girlboss
View on Reddit #32187670

Brehmes@reddit

This was a triumph.
View on Reddit #32188164

Trololoumadbro@reddit

I’m making a note here, huge success.
View on Reddit #32188648

UristMcMagma@reddit

She didn't talk. She was the perfect woman.
View on Reddit #32201657

leminshween@reddit

Man am i sick of all these new games preaching 2014 pop feminism ideals! Games such as
View on Reddit #32193956

liggamadig@reddit

Yass... Yass!
View on Reddit #32188543

SlyguyguyslY@reddit

Good characters+not preachy+not ugly.
View on Reddit #32257438

fuckbutton@reddit

Pre-gamergate diversity in videogames wasn't politicised and thus wasn't subject to screeds by angry young men
View on Reddit #32245333

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

It sounds like you blame how modern diversity is on Gamergate when and the "angry young men", rather than those who call the shot and have shitty diversity forced into it. You can't honestly tell me that Half-Life and Portal are on the same level as Kill the Justice League and Concord
View on Reddit #32249373

fuckbutton@reddit

No, I'm blaming the politicisation of diversity. Those games suck because they're bad games, not because they have women in them. And that is my point, diversity in itself isn't a bad thing, but when it is used for political reasons it's quickly becomes shit. It just so happens that angry young men without the life experience to discern between what is shitty, forced diversity and just straight up adequate representation are enraged by any form of representation because of how political it has become. Look at Rogan, Tate, Peterson, and tell me that their criticisms of modern diversity aren't rooted in the potential grift that is upsetting and fuelling the rage of already marginalised angry young men, rather than reasonable criticism of forced diversity implemented by capitalists to earn political brownie points.
View on Reddit #32250140

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

Only a small minority of grifter argue games are bad because woman. Your point could be made about the types like Hassan Piker and Vaush and how they radicalizes their audience but the majority of people, AKA normal people, are able to criticize Isreal without being mindless anti-semite and pro-hamas propagandist Same way how the amount of, Joe Rogan fans who think woke is when woman exist in a game is far less than normal guy who wants to enjoy a good game but the devs made a deal with the Devil to get ESG funds in exchange of painfully forced diversity and most people arent the kind you find twitter so when they go to enjoy a game that has all women that are ugly and brutish, full of quirky millenial writing, and references to current politics their reaction wont be "Oh my god yass slay the evil capitalism, I too must virtue signal all day and night!" And it wont neither be "This game has black women? Clearly woke garbage!" Their reaction will be "I cant enjoy this game whos more busy trying to send a message rather then be fun, I dont care about these agendas and they are so on the nose, do they think I'm an idiot? What a waste." And they dont like it when people act like their dislikebof the game is because of a character gender identity, it's like if I acted like you were a pedophile for disagreeing with me. Like, you can dislike the term woke all day but however you call it, there is a phenomenon that has games having far-left agendas that are forced in and the games journalist are in on it because, well, they agree with the agenda, to conclude, gamer gate was right, games journalist are beyond corrupt.
View on Reddit #32256758

demonsdencollective@reddit

It's easy. Just build a character that's more than a single factor of their facets comically overblown for target audiences to go "DAS ME, I'M IN DA VIDYA GAEM!" It just makes me feel insulted to whenever there's a fat bi dude in a game going "I'M FAT AND BI I'M SO QUIRKY AND I EXIST TO BE FAT AND BI LOOK AT ME BEING FAT AND BI!"
View on Reddit #32256315

the-fake-hentai-god@reddit

the games were made before right wing grifters found out it was profitable to bitch about it
View on Reddit #32256111

IRIDIUMSAT69@reddit

>make asian woman the star of your puzzle game Except Chell isn't asian. She's mixed race like Alyx. Anon is a dumbass.
View on Reddit #32187652

N1ghtshade3@reddit

You can't be a mixed Asian? I guess my Chinese mom has something to tell my white dad...
View on Reddit #32245921

Blackmore543@reddit

It's because they don't boast about how great they are for having a mixed woman as the main character of their puzzle game. People hate being preached to.
View on Reddit #32242660

ContributionOk4879@reddit

The answer is literally always just good writing
View on Reddit #32242095

MarvelousNCK@reddit

It’s cause they came out years ago. If any of these games came out today, guaranteed all the right wing babies would be crying about DEI and woke mob bullshit lol
View on Reddit #32240184

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

explain Half-Life: Alyx then
View on Reddit #32240222

MarvelousNCK@reddit

She was an existing character from the previous games, plus it was VR only, not nearly enough people have VR or have played that game. If they’d invented a new character that acted and sounded the exact same, people would’ve been mad.
View on Reddit #32240438

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

Thats such a lie lmao, HLA was so fucking popular, thats like saying HL2 didnt get a lot of attention because you could only play it on Steam
View on Reddit #32240506

MarvelousNCK@reddit

Do you really think VR sets are as popular as having a PC with Steam on it? Either way the main point was that Alyx was an existing character that people already knew and liked from the older games.
View on Reddit #32240603

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

Nice moving of the goal post, also your point falls when you consider people can criticize a game is woke, without playing it. Look at how many people call Concord woke slop and how many are actually playing it. You really are unable to argue in good faith are you
View on Reddit #32240694

MarvelousNCK@reddit

What goalpost do you think I moved? Genuinely curious. Idk what Concord is but I’ll say this - I think good character and story writing is more important than anything else, and that’s ultimately the reason all those characters are well regarded. You cannot tell me that if Portal didn’t exist and it was announced today with a trailer, people would’ve been up in arms about “another fucking woman protagonist” Maybe once the game came out and it was good, they’d change their tune, but you know for a fact that I’m right about what the initial reaction would be today.
View on Reddit #32240970

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

"It’s cause they came out years ago. If any of these games came out today, guaranteed all the right wing babies would be crying about DEI and woke mob bullshit lol" This was the goal you set up. HL:Alyx game out recently and no one cried about it, so you moved the goal post by saying it must be a new OC character from the Half-Life universe. >You cannot tell me that if Portal didn’t exist and it was announced today with a trailer, people would’ve been up in arms about “another fucking woman protagonist” I can because Stellar Blade is a thing, and the only people who had a problem with the woman protagonist was games journos lamenting the woman was too hot and not "diverse" enough.
View on Reddit #32241256

MarvelousNCK@reddit

Providing an argument is not “moving a goalpost” lmao. It’s objectively true that Alyx is an existing character, and that’s a massive part of the reason there was minimal backlash to her. Stellar Blade had a hot anime girl protagonist, compare that to something like the girl from the Horizon series, or even MJ from the Spider-Man 2, the difference in treatment of a sex doll character like the one from SB vs a character that looks like a real person should tell you all you need to know. Anyway, you sound like you just learned a few new words in high school debate class, so I’m assuming you’re pretty young and not very open to actually being convinced of anything. I look forward to when you look back at this convo in a few years and cringe.
View on Reddit #32241742

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

>Stellar Blade had a hot anime girl protagonist, compare that to something like the girl from the Horizon series, or even MJ from the Spider-Man 2, the difference in treatment of a sex doll character like the one from SB vs a character that looks like a real person should tell you all you need to know. Wow sexist much? SB protagonist is based on a real human you bigot, you can see how the proportions are pretty much 1:1. Get down your soapbox you fucking 1950s ass conservatie "all good looking women are succubus temptress" Whats next very progressive talking point will you come with?
View on Reddit #32241887

Car0lus_Rex@reddit

Turns out making characters who aren’t defined by their race/orientation and doesn’t shove such things in your face do well! Instead of being shoehorned, obvious and a main focus of that character like “big woop they’re gay” and thats all there is to them.
View on Reddit #32185703

leargonaut@reddit

"I'm a black Scottish cyclops. They got more [beeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeep] than they got the likes of me."
View on Reddit #32192127

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

Using race for comedy? Damn this is a new thing, black comedians must be all woke now
View on Reddit #32238707

leargonaut@reddit

"they don't shove it in our face"
View on Reddit #32241022

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

This disproves my point how?
View on Reddit #32241067

leargonaut@reddit

Well I guess I don't know what your point is then. They used race for comedy, yes, that also means yes it's been in our faces the whole time. My point is that they're trying to gloss over that race and ethnicity does make up major portions of their characters.
View on Reddit #32241254

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

> that also means yes it's been in our faces the whole time one time, in one trailer. not in game. Try again buddy
View on Reddit #32241328

leargonaut@reddit

Well considering the trailers are the vessels of personality for the characters I don't know what you mean.
View on Reddit #32241384

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

Thats very dishonest lmao, you really are taking one joke. Need I explain why he said he's black? Its because he's scotish! And scotland if you didnt notice is very white, so the joke is that he's a black scotish And thats just one part of the joke and it servers you know what purpouse in the trailer? To introduce you that this is a black scotish drunkyard demolition expert.
View on Reddit #32241501

PotateJello@reddit

If modern writers made Alyx she'd be obese, missing a leg, have giant frizzy zoomer hair, fucked up teeth, glasses, and all she would talk about is how the Combine are oppressing her.
View on Reddit #32190989

prestonfrank480@reddit

Lmao you’re a fucking loser
View on Reddit #32219114

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

Concord.
View on Reddit #32238450

prestonfrank480@reddit

Baldurs gate 3.
View on Reddit #32238493

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

Baldurs Gate 3 aint woke, try again buddy
View on Reddit #32238873

prestonfrank480@reddit

You can be gay and there is a black main character on top of there being multiple gay and poc characters in the game also when you create a character you can choose nonbinary and it doesn’t even mention gender it just says body type 1 or 2 and you can also be trans
View on Reddit #32239162

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

That makes the game woke how?
View on Reddit #32239196

prestonfrank480@reddit

Yeah???
View on Reddit #32239226

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

You are so pathetic, you really believe that having that silly list of yours makes a game woke, whats next strawman arguement that you believe? You do know a strawman arguement doesnt reflect real life, maybe read what the people have been saying here, they describe pretty well their problem with woke games, let me find you one
View on Reddit #32239342

prestonfrank480@reddit

When the fuck did i make a ?? Your view of “wokeness” might be different from everyone else but alot of people consider this game woke. https://steamcommunity.com/app/1086940/discussions/0/3823047940150899271/?ctp=4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pX1sh4OriME https://rpgcodex.net/forums/threads/baldurs-gate-3-anti-woke-mods.150337/ and thats just from the first few results on google if i dug any deeping im sure i could find wayyyyyyyyyy more but that’s up for you to do now because even if you have a counter point for this thats getting into a different argument because i established this game is considered woke by multiple different people and those are the kind of people my original comment was towards.
View on Reddit #32240489

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

I suggest you check around r/KotakuInAction, unofficial Gamergate subreddit, I'm sure you'll open your horizons instead of being so close-minded
View on Reddit #32240588

prestonfrank480@reddit

I mean i also saw alot of people waiting for mods to “remove the wokeness” on there
View on Reddit #32240643

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

Bro literrly 90% is people singing its praises. You really have to dig to find that and even then. Would you have a problem with someone installing mods to make a game more "woke"? No? Then thats fine too, modding is a non-arguement.
View on Reddit #32240792

prestonfrank480@reddit

But my point is people do consider the game “woke” enough to mod it out
View on Reddit #32240834

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

So, let me get this clear, the statistical possibility that minority of people think woke game is when black or trans, means EVERYONE who hates woke game is because they think like the minority. Do you understand the pitfall in your logic here? And how saying that BG3 is woke because one hick that hates blacks exists, means that majority of people who hate woke must be the same as that one racist.
View on Reddit #32241008

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

Heres a good arguement about woke: It cones from wider factors. I can't really put it into words but, the "vibes" of a project and who's making it determine if something gonna get hate and after release, how it's done will determine if the hate continues or fizzles away. Like that new game coming "Concord" everything about it reeks of box ticking, no heart, no vision, chasing trends with character designs one would find on 2015 Tumblr to make a quick buck via Blackrock ESG points to get bots to funnel investment money their way. Compare this to say, Miles Morales, very quickly after the first comics came out it was firmly established that not only was Miles his own character, but he's someone who idolised Peter Parker and wanted to follow in his footsteps, not replace him or prove himself as better. There was a lot of hate for this character when he was first announced then pretty soon after the first few comics came out it died down and the same ppl who hated him warmed up to him. One is mindless corporate box ticking slop pushed by elitist, racist, sexist, disconnected harpies on behalf of their corporate overlords, The other is actually fleshed out characters made by people who have a vision. when a story is more concerned with virtue signaling, surface level political messaging, and identity politics, it’s clear that’s the issue with the plot. Plus the creative team will use those politics as a shield for criticism of their mediocre writing
View on Reddit #32239652

prestonfrank480@reddit

Literally just search up baldurs gate woke and youll see alot of the anti “woke” crowd hating on it
View on Reddit #32239277

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

r/Kotakuinaction was pretty chill
View on Reddit #32239449

JerryUitDeBuurt@reddit

Because the character choice for Alyx was already made when muh women in games wasn't a big deal. People love to shit about minorities or women as the main character in a game or movie but 90% of the time it's either because muh women or because the writing is genuinely awful
View on Reddit #32185052

BlepBlupe@reddit

I haven't played the vr game, but even just hl2 alyx is one of the best written characters in gaming. Highly competent, likeable, and great voice acting. Feels both human and like a true partner as opposed to just some tacked on sidekick. There's nothing to complain about with her. Not having a corny love subplot was also a great decision. A few affectionate gestures are shown, but otherwise, they're focused on the task at hand.
View on Reddit #32190117

ChickenPijja@reddit

It's been a while since I've played HL2, but isn't the reason why Alyx was so well received as a character because she didn't follow the typical plot tropes of having her be a damsel in distress, love interest or assistant to the protagonist? In fact it wouldn't surprise me if it ever came out that her character was originally written as a guy (hell she almost has a guys name) in the first draft of the script. And because Alyx didn't exist prior to HL2 the right wingers didn't lose their collective shit about recasting an existing character (as they claim happens in a lot of movie remakes) Alyx was written and designed exactly how a female character should be for something like HL2.
View on Reddit #32194702

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

She does become a damsel in distress a few times, eitherway the Tomboy isnt exacly a revolutionary characrer type
View on Reddit #32238827

lostmypornaccount@reddit

Because they’re actual characters and not one note stereotypes
View on Reddit #32187524

nucleophilicattack@reddit

The characters of TF2 are def 1 note stereotypes but they make it very funny. Plus they neatly sidestep Demoman being black and the associated stereotypes by also making him Scottish, one legged, and one eyed.
View on Reddit #32193143

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

Because they dont act like their one note steriotypes are deep or use their diversity as a shield for criticism
View on Reddit #32238776

benydrillcumbersome@reddit

Because your favourite rage bait YouTuber did not tell you to be angry about it.
View on Reddit #32187723

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

Explain HL:Alyx
View on Reddit #32238558

Thatguyj5@reddit

They did it before conservative reactionaries took over the podcast scene.
View on Reddit #32187645

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

Ah yes we all know conservative reactionaries hatred of HL:Alyx
View on Reddit #32238513

ttv_highvoltage@reddit

Actual answer: It was before the rightoids realized they can simply do culture war bullshit instead of actually doing something
View on Reddit #32189290

Competitive-Buyer386@reddit

Because the leftoids would NEVER do that
View on Reddit #32238479

Lazypole@reddit

Theres absolutely nothing wrong with characters who are minorities, gay, female, whatever. There is however a lot wrong with characters who are solely those things.
View on Reddit #32238161

DiscountParmesan@reddit

they made normal characters which happened to be a certain ethnicity instead of trying to meet diversity quotas
View on Reddit #32185406

PiNe4162@reddit

Why do I get the feeling he was originally gonna be Irish, before they changed it?
View on Reddit #32232768

kulingames@reddit

example: when someone says “Demoman” people think “drunk cyclops with pipe bombs” and not “black guy”
View on Reddit #32189948

null_and_void000@reddit

I mean, I think "black Scottish cyclops" because of meet the team.
View on Reddit #32203252

dagon_xdd@reddit

right? "Black Scottish cyclops" were the words uttered by Demoman himself, making the whole thing way funnier
View on Reddit #32205899

Recipe-Jaded@reddit

good writing, good characters, and they don't make it the staple of the game. nobody has a problem playing as a minority or a woman. it's when the writing is shitty and the character sucks that people get mad.
View on Reddit #32230382

Sonova_Vondruke@reddit

Before the anti-woke agenda got pushed by the right.
View on Reddit #32228640

reallynunyabusiness@reddit

>Be Valve >Make good games >Characters well written >Happen to be diverse but don't make a big deal about it. That's how.
View on Reddit #32228162

tus93@reddit

The games came out before the right wing grifters started pushing the “woke” culture war shit.
View on Reddit #32227654

Beastleviath@reddit

They weren’t replacing any existing characters for one thing
View on Reddit #32227022

Infinitium_520@reddit

Zeitgeist changed. Racial matters are more acutely understood and discussed nowadays, which leads to people being either more receptive or touchy about it.
View on Reddit #32220726

iamgreatlego@reddit

Woke isnt anything with diversity. Woke is anti white
View on Reddit #32218118

DominoUB@reddit

The fact that I never even considered their race before reading this post is the answer.
View on Reddit #32217600

viky109@reddit

See, all of those characters had personality traits besides not being white
View on Reddit #32217239

Weird_Angry_Kid@reddit

Because they are hot and g*mers stop being racist when they see a hot woman of another race.
View on Reddit #32215338

Jojoflap@reddit

Their personalities were more than their skin color.
View on Reddit #32215098

resistive_peach@reddit

what’s funny is I literally didn’t even “notice” they were asian and black, lol? like it never really even mattered to me they’re just people.
View on Reddit #32214692

iTzKracKerjacK@reddit

It doesn’t feel forced
View on Reddit #32213237

keeleon@reddit

Because "woke" doesn't just mean "has minorities", and everyone knows it but refuses to admit it.
View on Reddit #32212577

ConscientiousPath@reddit

The only reason other companies get shit for it is that they go out of their way to make sure they get shit for it in order to demonstrate their fealty to the regime that demands they cooperate with the message control of the current psyop. How to not get shit for a "diverse" cast and/or main character is pretty simple: 1. **Don't distort what people already love**: If the story is already well known, but the main character isn't the race or sex you want to tell a different story about, pick a different story to tell. Ideally tell a brand new story where the diversity doesn't fly in the face of what people know about reality (e.g. a story where a woman wins men's powerlifting is stupid). 2. **Don't brag about your own virtue**: Never call attention to the race or gender of the characters as a selling point of the story. If that insignificant fact is the best selling point of the story, that's implicitly admitting the rest of product is trash and people react poorly to that. 3. **Don't insult your audience**: Don't push ideological or political points in the plot. Not only is it overdone, but when you imply that half the audience are bad people for something they don't think is bad, they're going to be upset at you about that.
View on Reddit #32212481

Jeriba@reddit

Aleyx looks so (racially) ambiguous. Valve was careful to not have her look too "black" or "Black" at all. I (full black woman) would have never guessed she's supposed to be bi-racial if it wouldn't be for her dad. I still like her, and pissed that Alyx is only playable with VR. Half Life 3 will never come (at least not while I'm still alive).
View on Reddit #32212431

Vord_Lader@reddit

The correct answer, which I will get downvoted to hell for, is that what everyone seems to neglect in media is the fact that for someone to like a particular piece of media, they must be able to relate to the character or situation. If you highlight characteristics or situation in which I cannot relate, chance are I will not appreciate it (on a side-note, this specifically scares me in regards to the popularity of murder/serial killer shows, podcast, etc...). The more diverse a character is, the harder it is to relate unless they are put in situations were they behave in a matter that the audience can identify with. This is particularly why the general population may act vehemently towards anything outside was is considered the "norm" in casting/shows/media.
View on Reddit #32211989

f-ckusingmyrealemail@reddit

Is Alyx Vance asian? I thought she was black, but with a lighter skin tone since her dad was black. Blasian, maybe?
View on Reddit #32209770

viral-architect@reddit

They made Counter-Strike
View on Reddit #32209608

AestheticMirror@reddit

It was a different time
View on Reddit #32207060

I_SuplexTrains@reddit

They did it several years before they "had to" to "not be racist."
View on Reddit #32206585

ViceAW@reddit

While I agree writing is important to making these charactes well liked, modern gamers are so far in the rabbit hole that this argument no longer works. The new Assassin's Creed game is getting shit on for having a black guy, the new Fable game is getting shit on for having a female protagonist, the new Star Wars Ubi game is getting shit on for having a female protagonist. Notice something? None of these games have released at all. We don't know *anything* about these characters and gamers already dismiss them as forced inclusion and comment bullshit like "why do i have to play as her, first thing im doing is modding the game" like what lmao
View on Reddit #32206507

WhoRoger@reddit

Gamers just aren't racist or sexist like the moviegoers.
View on Reddit #32205843

AstroZombie29@reddit

Team Fortress 2 is diverse ?
View on Reddit #32205715

Fun_Network312@reddit

Maybe make games with race instead of about race? They killed a 150 million$ Spiderman game with this toxic shit
View on Reddit #32205548

Su1tz@reddit

Because they weren't "Asian girl protagonist", they were Chell.
View on Reddit #32204258

Sad-Guarantee-4678@reddit

Race was never really an issue, the entire 80s and 90s were filled with black and Asian protagonists and supporting characters in movies and they were the biggest superstars on the planet. Because it wasn't a virtue signalling, or a trend, or a political statement. Just people in a movie. Once you start doing it for a check mark to appease sensationalist reporters - people feel how disingenuous it is and of course it's gonna be met with criticism
View on Reddit #32204221

FactoryOfShit@reddit

One of the jokes in TF2 is despite demoman being the only black character in the game, all other characters mock him not for his race, but for being Sxottish lol
View on Reddit #32187680

kulingames@reddit

“SCOTLAND IS NOT A REAL COUNTRY! YOU’RE AN ENGLISHMAN IN A DRESS!!!”
View on Reddit #32190019

Greg-theseatreader@reddit

“DOMINATED, YOU SCOT SONOVABITCH!”
View on Reddit #32204116

Clive23p@reddit

If you're actually bad ass, you don't need anyone to say it. Everyone just already knows.
View on Reddit #32202624

Kerboviet_Union@reddit

They wrote good narratives.
View on Reddit #32202549

random06@reddit

Because they used stereotypes correctly, it feels natural and not forced. Look at the TF2 sniper, he is comically Australian, but not in a negative way. Or the demo-man he’s a Scottish black guy, not a “black” Scottish guy right? Race and such are part of their character but not the defining characteristic. I hope I’m making sense.
View on Reddit #32202070

AStupidFuckingHorse@reddit

I see people talking about "well written characters that happen to be black" ok that's true but these days we have people that start screaming before a game comes out when they see a black person. I saw a game ABOUT AFRICA made BY AN AFRICAN and people started screaming about DEI. Dumb as hell
View on Reddit #32201634

Felczer@reddit

All of these characters/games came out before right wing woke paranoia started crying about everything, I guarantee you the same people would cry about Half Life 2 if it came out today.
View on Reddit #32200235

W1llW4ster@reddit

They did it before it was 'cool' for companies to be 'woke'.
View on Reddit #32200188

leadenbrain@reddit

The real hot take is if the original half life and portal came out today they would get shit for these characters. This nonsense about "needless inclusivity" didn't start until around gamergate and by then these games were already in the good graces of the community. Imo the only reason valve dodged it is cause these games were made before some people decided inclusivity was a bad thing.
View on Reddit #32200176

xPrim3xSusp3ctx@reddit

These all came about before everyone became a reactive little bitch
View on Reddit #32199382

beansahol@reddit

You don't even notice the characters race, because it's not done for diversity's sake, they were just trying to make cool & naturally interesting characters.
View on Reddit #32199199

CerebralMessiah@reddit

The game is good,therefore you ignore it. Most recently BG3 had all the typical idpol crap,but everyone ignored it because the charachters did. Karlach didn't spend a billion years talking how she is a tiefling and the tieflings weren't analagous to black people-instead she has a full charachter that only includes being a tiefling and tieflings are a wholly separate group with their own problrms without analogies to the real world.
View on Reddit #32198910

Sylux444@reddit

Ez, all the wahman are first person styled by default so the cry babies can still self insert.
View on Reddit #32198557

azraelxii@reddit

Games were made a long time ago before it was"political" to have minorities in games
View on Reddit #32198391

SirThomasTheFearful@reddit

Normal diversity vs black Viking diversity.
View on Reddit #32198138

crocodilepickle@reddit

Ah yes tf2, the most diverse game ever made!
View on Reddit #32197819

BilltheThreat_@reddit

Make an original well written character "OmG gUys hOw Do tHeY dO It?!" https://preview.redd.it/hpyd6d650vfd1.png?width=651&format=png&auto=webp&s=f4b69f23686106c9f109dec3fe0feacfb2429778
View on Reddit #32197689

JustRuss79@reddit

Good writing. And there hot, that helps
View on Reddit #32197544

RunInRunOn@reddit

Nobody noticed
View on Reddit #32197254

Ghostiestboi@reddit

Because "muh diversity" isn't the motive. Making likeable characters, regardless of their ethnicity, was the goal
View on Reddit #32196620

Heir233@reddit

Because they’re well written characters who just happen to be a certain race, not characters who’s race comes first and writing comes second
View on Reddit #32196373

panjeri@reddit

I think it's weird that Alyx didn't cause a shitstorm. People especially wanted a third game with Freeman and got Alyx instead. It's probably because most people didn't have VR headsets so they simply didn't bother getting mad at a product that they couldn't even consoom.
View on Reddit #32196256

BladeSoul69@reddit

Helps that they made the characters attractive.
View on Reddit #32196178

DerpyLemonReddit@reddit

How do they do it
View on Reddit #32195885

drakontoolx@reddit

Back in the day, people don't have this much brainrot.
View on Reddit #32195738

Pep-Sanchez@reddit

Feel like I see the most controversy when it’s like putting black or female soldiers in historically inaccurate places, these games take place in a far enough away future that complaints are very unfounded
View on Reddit #32195583

TechnoSparda@reddit

They did the games 20 years ago, in a time when people weren't hurt in the feelings by having to play as a character that wasn't a white person
View on Reddit #32195549

InstrumentalCore@reddit

Because Valve is based.
View on Reddit #32193869

Adura90@reddit

Competent leaders, making good decisions based on reasons other than money. You don't see much of that in today's corporate world.
View on Reddit #32192967

The_Zookinator@reddit

People probably whined about it on some obscure forum back in the day. Nowadays the suckers just have bigger platforms. The reason people weren't as loud on the VR thing is cause it had been long over a decade since the last half life release and she already was an established character.
View on Reddit #32192912

love-em-feet@reddit

I hate alyx she was such a badass that made the protagonist look like toddler. Whole game I am thinking we should play her not Gordon. She is like 'yeah Gordon just shoot those guys I will handle the big brain stuff'.
View on Reddit #32192867

PrometheusOnLoud@reddit

Back then it wasn't being forced down anyone's throat; it was a simpler time.
View on Reddit #32192612

innerentity@reddit

They did it because it fit, not because they're pandering. There's a huge difference in feel while playing those games that just do it to kiss ass.
View on Reddit #32192330

-BluBone-@reddit

They were doing it before it was cool
View on Reddit #32192293

DaveyFTW89@reddit

We don’t have the media hype around it to blow it out of proportion?
View on Reddit #32192228

Mwrp86@reddit

It would get shit on if they did it with mainline game.
View on Reddit #32191958

TheIlluminatedDragon@reddit

Realistic sounding characters, story development, and putting absolutely no emphasis on those characteristics what-so-ever. That's how, Anon.
View on Reddit #32191823

flynnfruitbat@reddit

Because people didn't care nearly as much about culture war bullshit
View on Reddit #32191809

RazzleThatTazzle@reddit

They made good games that happened to have diverse characters, instead of having diverse characters and then half assing a game.
View on Reddit #32191728

Survival_R@reddit

People say it's cause the games are good but then I see idiots on the internet crying cause baldur's gate 3 has gay people in it
View on Reddit #32191374

Adorable_Region_183@reddit

this was a different time when games were made by people who actually played games, and not by shareholders or execs. watch them eat shit when deadlock releases.
View on Reddit #32191314

ReplyHappy@reddit

the real answer is they did it before the grift of the "Woke mob coming after us" was not conceived yet
View on Reddit #32191297

mi__to__@reddit

...her overwhelming Combine soldiers when you first meet her in HL2 did seem a bit odd to me though.
View on Reddit #32191073

MungYu@reddit

Wait turns out introducing diverse characters with good storylines without insufferable personalities and political agenda-driven character development helps with the public acceptance of the characters??
View on Reddit #32190247

Zestymonserellastick@reddit

They made them without distinct. "They are a different race." They gave them life, charecter, and a reason why they are there.
View on Reddit #32190039

D0GAMA1@reddit

As long as characters are good looking I couldn't care less what race they are. now, if they have good personalities, that's just icing on top.
View on Reddit #32189882

PM_O5@reddit

Alyx is half black too
View on Reddit #32189854

mooman555@reddit

Valve isn't publicly traded. They don't do it because index funds force them to, they do it because they feel like it, so it's natural. That's why it doesn't feel fake or ragebait
View on Reddit #32189621

some_guy554@reddit

Well they're one of the few companies that can do diversity right. The number of companies like this used to be even higher.
View on Reddit #32189465

Drachenbar@reddit

They didn't shove it in peoples faces or bring attention to it
View on Reddit #32189187

Pinoclean-Juice@reddit

Ubisoft need to take notes
View on Reddit #32189021

roehnin@reddit

Which character was Asian?
View on Reddit #32185367

ThisIsSpy@reddit

Chell from Portal
View on Reddit #32185415

IRIDIUMSAT69@reddit

She isn't. She's mixed race. Half asian, half american, half brazilian.
View on Reddit #32187435

TheCatOfWar@reddit

dang 3 halves, she's 150%
View on Reddit #32188961

Sbotkin@reddit

Damn, a person with three halves!
View on Reddit #32188804

ThisIsSpy@reddit

Like the actress that Chell was modeled after? Because Alesia Glidewell's dad is a Brazilian-American and her mom is Japanese. If so, that's cool. But you can't blame people for calling her asian because that's what she looks like the most (at least to me)
View on Reddit #32187735

roehnin@reddit

Oh, didn’t realize.
View on Reddit #32185431

Trigger_Fox@reddit

Because it wasn't. Valve games aproach ethnicity really tastefully. Chell isn't an asian character, Chell is a character that happens to be asian.
View on Reddit #32185557

roehnin@reddit

I just googled and she doesn’t really look particularly Asian to me. Black hair, sure, but could be Latin or Italian or Slavic for all I can tell. But if Valve says so, I guess that’s it.
View on Reddit #32185658

Lonemasterinoes@reddit

They modeled her after a real person, Alesia Glidewell, who is half Japanese, and therefore Chell is too, by extension.
View on Reddit #32187150

roehnin@reddit

That's cool, I didn't know, thanks! Being half could make it even less obvious in the pixelised version!
View on Reddit #32188369

IRIDIUMSAT69@reddit

It's because she isn't. She's mixed race and just happens asian is inside that mix.
View on Reddit #32187472

boxdud-e@reddit

Chell (protag of portal) was based of alesia glidewell, who was a mix of brazilian, american and japanese, just kinda funny also portal 2 took away her melanin
View on Reddit #32185472

Corbakobasket@reddit

Meh, probably the lack of sun exposure due to being locked in a hybernation chamber for 999.999.99...
View on Reddit #32185766

boxdud-e@reddit

tru
View on Reddit #32188575

DJIsSuperCool@reddit

I think if they were black, we'd see different results.
View on Reddit #32188447

Dat_Syfilis@reddit

There is a difference between adding things for necessity and adding things for realism, valve making chell asian is because she might as well be. Unlike, lets say you make a game about vikings and then turn a Scandinavian royal black or asian or Arabic or literally anything else than Scandinavian. It's not done for realism, therefore it's bad
View on Reddit #32188373

CompactAvocado@reddit

Real diversity: make complex developed characters that just happen to be a race or sexuality or whatever DEI bullshit diversity: Make a characters skin type or sexuality their only defining feature, no personality, literally just stereotypes personified but somehow this isn't bigotry. bonus points to give them an absolutely shitty personality but its okay because they are girl boss slay or some shit.
View on Reddit #32188128

Canadian_Beast14@reddit

It’s cause it’s an actual good game. That’s all.
View on Reddit #32187711

chetizii@reddit

They are characters who happen to be minorities, not minority representation characters
View on Reddit #32187528

bhbhbhhh@reddit

There wasn’t nothing, some people raised a small amount of hay over replacing Alyx’s VA with a black actress.
View on Reddit #32187296

TeensyTrouble@reddit

Morgan freeman is a black man and he stars their biggest game
View on Reddit #32187135

goldenzipperman@reddit

Charisma is the word that Anon thinks
View on Reddit #32187117

Boomy_Beatle@reddit

Chell was Asian?
View on Reddit #32185563

Pompf@reddit

Her character model and concept art at least sure looks asian
View on Reddit #32186474

Ragequittter@reddit

le, le good writers?
View on Reddit #32186393

Special-Remove-3294@reddit

Maybe the game is good and so people like it? Has anon considered this? That nobody actually cares about that shit unless the game is dogshit, cause if its good the minority who bitches will be drowned out by the majority that likes that game, cause its a good game.
View on Reddit #32186294

F0000r@reddit

#3?
View on Reddit #32184535

unlucky_ducky@reddit

Don't be silly, that's not a real number
View on Reddit #32185225

dirschau@reddit

Because gamers will go through any mental gymnastics to play a Valve game
View on Reddit #32185221