TheaterFire

What was your favorite celebrity conspiracy theory from the 90’s?

Posted by impeesa75@reddit | GenX | View on Reddit | 46 comments

Marylyn Manson and his ribs come to mind

Reply to Post

46 Comments

allisjow@reddit

I mean, Richard Gere and the gerbil was pretty wild.
View on Reddit #30022527

Mr_Auric_Goldfinger@reddit

I heard that one in the lunchroom of a Catholic school in the early '80s.
View on Reddit #30092562

doomrabbit@reddit

Newsgroups were big in the day when this spread, proto Reddit. A meme that spilled back into real life. Comic Book Guy in The Simpsons was also purportedly a tool to poke fun at the newsgroups bear. If only they knew how bad it would suck 30 years later.
View on Reddit #30081620

kalitarios@reddit

Wasn’t that just total bullshit someone made up?
View on Reddit #30023870

ricklewis314@reddit

It is amazing that it still spread like wildfire pre-internet.
View on Reddit #30056297

Thirty_Helens_Agree@reddit

[Dan Savage explained in 1998.](https://savage.love/savagelove/2013/03/20/gerbils-again/)
View on Reddit #30038959

ShaneBarnstormer@reddit

Isn't Dan Savage that pervy guy who wrote an article saying sexting your cousin isn't incest?
View on Reddit #30039878

allisjow@reddit

Yes. It started after “Pretty Woman” came out. There were rumors that Gere was gay, which then morphed into a story about an emergency "gerbilectomy." An anonymous prankster flooded fax machines in Hollywood with a phony "press release" purportedly issued by the Association for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals.
View on Reddit #30024634

gordigor@reddit

How do we all know that? There was no internet (for the most part), yet I somehow know the Richard Gere, Rod Stewart and Ozzy "meme"s
View on Reddit #30024446

allisjow@reddit

I have no idea. I must have read it in a magazine maybe. I don’t remember a friend telling me, which I think would have made a big impression.
View on Reddit #30024830

IngvaldClash@reddit

Came here to say this. Rod Stewart having his stomach pumped and Ozzy killing puppies on stage were the 80s.
View on Reddit #30023061

bogojeg@reddit

Mr T died poor and of cancer Marilyn Manson was the kid in the Wonder Years
View on Reddit #30038761

SheriffBartholomew@reddit

Mr. T is still alive though...
View on Reddit #30088679

texicali74@reddit

Tupac and Biggie are sipping drinks on a private island somewhere.
View on Reddit #30023815

SheriffBartholomew@reddit

Are Elvis and Jim Morrison there?
View on Reddit #30088602

MyriVerse2@reddit

I didn't know any of them.
View on Reddit #30025476

MissKhary@reddit

You're the one that answers "I don't know" on those Amazon products questions aren't you?
View on Reddit #30065045

Batgirl-1966@reddit

The newspaper in Hagerstown, MD ran an article back in the mid 70’s stating that Gene Simmons had a cow’s tongue grafted - along with a photo of Gene. I remember the first time I ever heard someone say, “Don’t believe everything you read.”
View on Reddit #30059669

UncleDrummers@reddit

I use to listen to Chuck Harder and all that conspiracy nonsense. Most of the Clinton and Vince Foster conspiracies, the Bush New World Order, stuff like that.
View on Reddit #30042858

LeoMarius@reddit

Mikey died eating pop rocks with Coca Cola..
View on Reddit #30033275

raisinghellwithtrees@reddit

I told this one to my son last week as he was eating pop rocks.
View on Reddit #30041531

Strangewhine88@reddit

Tom Cruise in Dallas. To be fair, this was 80’s 2nd degree rumor as fact. I just heard it from way too many people in random places…
View on Reddit #30023188

MowgeeCrone@reddit

Please, do tell ?
View on Reddit #30040819

mmobley412@reddit

-Richard Gere and his love for gerbils -Marilyn Manson was the older brother on the show Mr Belvedere - Michael Jackson slept in an oxygen chamber and that he and his sister were the same person - Jamie Lee Curtis was born a man
View on Reddit #30040681

gothfru@reddit

That the song “I Can Feel It Coming in the Air Tonight” was about an experience Phil Collins had where someone died (drowned, I think?) and the person who could have saved them just walked away. The rumor was that Phil invited the person to a concert to play it for them to get them to confess.
View on Reddit #30039870

Crescent-Fresh774@reddit

“Smart and accomplished people don’t lie” is certainly a take. 😜
View on Reddit #30039794

Historical_Chip_2706@reddit

Courtney killed Kurt
View on Reddit #30023362

WilliamMcCarty@reddit

I mean....
View on Reddit #30029587

GreatGreenGobbo@reddit

She didn't pull the trigger but she was the cause.
View on Reddit #30030789

WilliamMcCarty@reddit

Now by "cause" do you mean she drove him to it or you mean she caused it by hiring someone? I could believe either version, honestly.
View on Reddit #30030859

UnitGhidorah@reddit

Got him on drugs and was behind it.
View on Reddit #30039546

GreatGreenGobbo@reddit

Drove him/influenced with the drugs.
View on Reddit #30030922

editorgrrl@reddit

There was a rumor in the early 1990s that Les Claypool, Primus bassist and singer/songwriter, had died. This was before 1994, when Kurt Cobain died, and before I had internet access. I heard from a friend who heard it from a friend and so on and so on…
View on Reddit #30037166

jeffpollard@reddit

Ozzy biting the heads off of birds at his concerts..or wait, did he actually do this?
View on Reddit #30030463

Gamelord666@reddit

Yes, yes he did. The story was he thought it was fake until he bit into it.
View on Reddit #30032810

MintyRosa77@reddit

My moms bff (79 or 80F) claims that when Ronald Reagan was running for governor or president somebody found a pornographic movie that he did in his twenties that had some kind of same sex action. She’s a long term San Francisco resident and says it was played at the Castro theater and she watched it with a small group of people. I’ve looked online for any mention of this movie and have only seen one clip on like Alex jones type show from a very disturbed sounding individual and it sounded more like he got pegged by a woman (in this persons description) My moms friend is a very smart and accomplished woman so I don’t think she made it up but maybe she heard it and it repeated it as her own story. She even described the scene.
View on Reddit #30025483

Agent7619@reddit

Michael Jordan retiring to play baseball was a double secret gambling suspension from the NBA.
View on Reddit #30022715

gordigor@reddit

TIL
View on Reddit #30024359

Strangewhine88@reddit

And it Was.
View on Reddit #30023127

Away-Equipment4869@reddit

I can't believe no one has mentioned how we all thought Snoop killed a little girl
View on Reddit #30024290

Rhusty_Dodes@reddit

Marilyn Manson having a rib removed so he could fellate himself. And that he was the kid from Wonder Years.
View on Reddit #30023745

8Deer-JaguarClaw@reddit

Zack Morris died in a motorcycle accident.
View on Reddit #30023525

Strangewhine88@reddit

Kindly fuck off.
View on Reddit #30023107

lawstandaloan@reddit

"Andy, are you goofing on Elvis?" [Andy Kauffman faked his own death](https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/andy-kaufman-hoax/#:~:text=Andy%20Kaufman%2C%20by%20all%20accounts%2C%20is%20alive%20and,recent%20interview%20with%20ABC%20News%20at%20his%20apartment.) as part of an elaborate performance art piece and will be letting us in on the joke any day now.
View on Reddit #30022546

LastBuy4318@reddit

Richard Gere + Gerbils
View on Reddit #30022543

drNeir@reddit

Nirvana was a good band, can still here this troupe to this day!
View on Reddit #30022370