Is the water crisis in Mexico City real?
Posted by AntiHyperbolic@reddit | collapse | View on Reddit | 202 comments
I caught a lot of flack from y’all about coming down to Mexico City. I’m sitting on the eve of the presidential election, apparently a few weeks from “day 0”, and everyone I’ve talked to says it’s all lies due to the election. It’s kind of bewildering, absolutely no one here seems to know, or care, that they could run out of water.
I’m a doomer, so I will continue to travel and see the world as I think there’s no turning around this carriage. I don’t think there’s much hope, and me enjoying the last couple decades/years/weeks ain’t going to make a lick of difference.
RelationshipMinimum9@reddit
3-31-25 "..For the first time in more than 80 years, the U.S. has denied Mexico's request for water from the Colorado River.." I hope this isn't true🥺
AntiHyperbolic@reddit (OP)
its pretty wild that a lot of their water infrastructure is literal water trucks. For a place that used to be a huge beautiful lake... to a giant metropolis...
Sinistar7510@reddit
They could be in denial themselves.
Soft_Match_7500@reddit
Everyone in Texas says there's no such thing as climate change because it's liberal, MSNBC propaganda
oMGellyfish@reddit
I work remotely but the rest of my team works in Texas. I am (currently as well speak) moving from AZ to MN for climate related reasons and they openly make fun of me for leaving and believing in this stuff. Some of them do believe me when I talk about it, but they won’t admit to it, it’s just a vibe I pick up on. Mostly they think I’m insane for picking up my entire life and moving. It was the right time for me though. Plus, eww, Arizona is pretty awful.
Soft_Match_7500@reddit
Everyone I grew up with and tell that we are moving to Wisconsin for climate reasons: same thing. They don't say anything too direct, but you get the vibe that you're crazy/unhinged for thinking there is anything to worry about
DesignerLocation9664@reddit
Your actions are verifying what that voice in the back of their mind is trying to tell them. As a general rule, the more scared they are the angrier they will be with you and those like you.
Soft_Match_7500@reddit
Yep, this I know. It still feels pretty bad to be the target of someone's pain from the inability to be present with themselves.
Bobandaran@reddit
Where in Wisconsin are you moving to?
Soft_Match_7500@reddit
Eau Claire
Hairy_Bloated_Toad@reddit
Lots of People from eau Claire have a unjustified superiority complex, stuck up, arrogant. seems to be the dominant attitude there
Soft_Match_7500@reddit
Where do you recommend
Soft_Match_7500@reddit
Yeesh, sounds bad
fiasco666@reddit
AZ is brutal esp if you work outside like me. I'm moving to Seattle next year to get away from the ever increasing summer temps..plus..its AZ.
DesignerLocation9664@reddit
What is it you do that you have to be outside?
Famous-Flounder4135@reddit
Are you SURE…. Seattle!?!?! I’m in Pittsburgh and have met several families who’ve recently relocated from Seattle bc they were choking on smoke from the wildfires ☹️. Shocked me and broke my heart bc I have very fond memories of Collecting in Portland OR , “88-92 and used to drive up to Seattle for weekends. Loved it. 😞
Aggravating-Value-79@reddit
Seattle is just a different hell. The grass isn't greener. It's just grass in another state.
Famous-Flounder4135@reddit
I know the homeless crisis and open drug use in the streets is a huge problem there and tourism is shot bc of feces in the streets. Same as San Francisco ☹️🤮. So sad to see beautiful cities die. I think we’re officially out of places to hide. Even if someone manages to find a “safe haven”, I’m afraid it will only be a very temporary “fix”, at this point. Good luck.
Aggravating-Value-79@reddit
Out of places to hide... you said it. Let's hold hands and jump off a cliff together.
Famous-Flounder4135@reddit
I’m afraid of heights. But I have a propane tank close at hand. And a bottle of apricot brandy….I like to sleep and not wake up. 😴😇😴😇😴😇
BenWallace04@reddit
Pittsburgh was also effected by the Canadian wildfires - last year.
https://www.cbsnews.com/pittsburgh/live-updates/live-updates-canadian-wildfire-smoke-clouds-pittsburgh-skies-air-quality-alerts-issued-for-western-pa/
Famous-Flounder4135@reddit
Yes, I know. I was here choking on the smoke. We just had to stay indoors for a week. It was very shocking. For EVERYONE. Especially poor Canada. Oh, well. No where will be safe, soon enough.
fiasco666@reddit
I'm originally from socal so im used to things being on fire.
Famous-Flounder4135@reddit
Yeah, I’m from San Jose and spent 30 ish years dealing with pretty regular (but highly controlled) Santa Cruz mountain fires. But I don’t remember them effecting us too much. At this point, we can only “escape” for so long and it’s always gonna be SOMETHING!!! I was shocked at how much Canadian fires smoked us out. 🙁
Aggravating-Value-79@reddit
You will regret the move. Seattle is a shit show.
CrustyShoelaces@reddit
you won't regret the move
DesignerLocation9664@reddit
I've lived here for 38 years. It is getting WAY hotter than ever before. If I need to do anything outside I have to wake up at 0400 and stop before 1100, 1000 usually. If you can get out. do it while you can.
elsord0@reddit
You in Phoenix? It has always been a miserably hot place but at least it used to be dirt cheap. It blows my mind that so many idiots wanted to spend the kind of money houses are going for there now. There's no way in hell I'd ever buy a house there.
I'm currently in Bisbee. Lots of "homesteaders" out here weirdly. There's no water and it's still a desert so growing food isn't going to happen to any large degree. Climate is nice enough if it got the moisture but it doesn't. All these clueless people that think living in a home depot shed (or maybe a yurt) with no electricity or running water is "homesteading", meanwhile they all still go into town to buy groceries. They aren't homesteading, they're living a life of voluntary poverty. Which is fine but it ain't homesteading.
oMGellyfish@reddit
Sometimes, as a poor, just having the land first is the goal. Everything else can be built after. Of course you couldn’t convince me to buy anywhere in Arizona, though Bisbee is a very cute little town and has a cute vibe and rich history. Last time I was there the community was very tight too. I liked it.
I came to Phoenix homeless 3 years ago because it was too cold for me to go anywhere else at the time. I got on my feet and got a place to live but I just got priced out so now I am leaving homeless too. That’s okay, I guess, but I think people like me are just going to keep getting priced out over and over.
And before people make assumptions- I work full time remotely and make about $20/hour. But I am also the only income and have kids, and don’t have any family to rely on or ask for help.
elsord0@reddit
Well, half of them are just living on someone else's land. Idk, this seems like a bad place to attempt this. A lot of them moved from areas where you can actually grow food. In my eyes you at least start putting stuff in the ground, tomatoes, potatoes, asparagus, whatever. And get some chickens. If you aren't at least doing that you're not really making a serious attempt at homesteading. Chickens aren't very expensive to acquire and you just need a simple enclosure. And tomatoes grow like weeds here. I have some tomato plants growing on my terrace. Plan on filling the area up with planters to grow some veggies. I'm definitely not homesteading but figure since I got some space might as well start growing something.
thisquietreverie@reddit
This Texan salutes your action and foresight.
plzdontlietomee@reddit
Welcome to MN soon (where we subsidize Texas' failure to prepare for climate change)
markodochartaigh1@reddit
I'm in my 60's. I grew up in Amarillo Texas. In high school, in health class, we were taught that smoking causes cancer. Of course a lot of kids had already started smoking but almost all of the kids made fun of the kids who didn't want to smoke. There was no point in talking about it with most adults either. There were doctors on TV commercials recommending particular brands. And drunk driving. It wasn't encouraged, but it certainly wasn't seen as a big deal as long as you didn't get a ticket. Like I said, I'm in my 60's. Almost one quarter of my high school graduating class didn't make it to 65, and those are the ones who graduated, I can't imagine those who dropped out did any better.
kakapo88@reddit
Denial is everywhere. I've got a distant cousin in California whose town burned down a few years back, due to mega-fires. They've rebuilt but complain about ongoing smoke from other fires, heat, and so on.
And climate change isn't real, because "It's not in the bible" and "it is all made up by Soros". Verbatim quotes.
I've pretty much given up on human beings, as a group. Sure, some people read and are aware, but the most are happy with ignorance and fantasies.
walkinman19@reddit
Funny how people never actually seem to read their bibles.
Revelation 16:9 And men were scorched with great heat, and they blasphemed the name of God who has power over these plagues; and they did not repent and give Him glory.
DesignerLocation9664@reddit
True, many profess to hate the Bible and yet know nothing about it.
Soft_Match_7500@reddit
I fantasize about dying gloriously on the Fury Road
DesignerLocation9664@reddit
Just drive on I-17 through Phoenix, there is your Fury Road.
Aggravating-Value-79@reddit
That kind of happiness is infuriating.
perplexed-moose@reddit
They don't know their Bible very well.
Micah 7:13 "The earth will become desolate because of its inhabitants, as the result of their deeds."
kakapo88@reddit
Dang, I wish I had known that verse when I talked to them!
But I will definitely remember it for next time (I have a very religious family, and there will be a next time). Thanks!
pegaunisusicorn@reddit
don't forget Numbers where moses says to kill everyone but the young girls. stay classy moses!
knowledgebass@reddit
Maybe it is partially the ignorance and fantasies that keep people happy. 🤔
Aggravating-Value-79@reddit
That kind of happiness is infuriating.
Aggravating-Value-79@reddit
Amen
Bigtimeknitter@reddit
I came to say this-- I'm a Californian and basically people do NOT want to talk about it. This pairs probably with all the comments that ratings of media addressing climate change are received poorly / get low engagement
DiscombobulatedWavy@reddit
Everyone? Watch out with that broad paintbrush you’ve got there.
Soft_Match_7500@reddit
I usually assume the term 'everyone' in a context like that is pretty clearly hyperbole. Everyone in a state having the same perspective, even general, would be more than a bit improbable.
Aggravating-Value-79@reddit
Policing absolutes like "everyone" is deplorable. Language was not designed for accuracy. It was designed to communicate.
DiscombobulatedWavy@reddit
I get it, but half of people probably don’t have that level of nuance to discern hyperbolic statements. And it totally triggers the rest of us that are stuck in the state trying to make this situation better for future generations.
Soft_Match_7500@reddit
I've been doing that for 17 years. I don't get triggered at all by somebody referencing how fucked Texas and Texans are. Never have. I say it more than anyone
Aggravating-Value-79@reddit
How does someone deny mathematics
kellsdeep@reddit
I moved my family to Idaho from Texas for climate reasons with the full support of the extended family I left behind. Texas is at least 50% hard R but I knew plenty of people with a good head on their shoulders. I can't blame people for not knowing that collapse is coming, that's a large bitter pill.
Regular-Choice-9558@reddit
Laws in Idaho are insane. Why not Washington? Just curious.
kellsdeep@reddit
What laws?? Washington is overrun with homeless and a bunch of weird policies itself. Idaho has been tested the number one outdoors recreation state for like twenty years straight. We live in the panhandle. The weather is freaking awesome year round for us. I've researched the ten year forecast for this area and it could potentially be a last haven after climate disruption.
Regular-Choice-9558@reddit
Womens rights, near abortion ban, marijuana laws .. just to name a few... the OB-Gyns are leaving the state... passed a series of bills targeting LGBTQ+ residents this year
BitchfulThinking@reddit
I feel like the entirety of Idaho is actually a sundown town, like the weird little Christian culty areas here in California, or the not-Portland parts of Oregon.
kellsdeep@reddit
All the more reason to push out those politics with better votes. There are waves of people moving here from the Southwest, and they are voting blue.
Famous-Flounder4135@reddit
Really??? I’m surprised it’s not way high up there for kindling…. I mean forest fires(??)
kellsdeep@reddit
There is significant potential fire hazard, that's true. I'm mostly concerned about severe storms and life threatening heat. The current models show this pocket of the Continental US as one of the safest bets. I wish I had time to post sources but I'm at work. I encourage everyone to look into it. Bottom line is nowhere is completely safe, that's unreasonable, and we're all at threat of famine and pestilence among other things. My decision was based on overall quality of life while things are still fair based on my families wants and needs. So far it has been very rewarding for us!
Famous-Flounder4135@reddit
That’s good. I did my thorough research for safest and best places to move 15 yrs ago and Pittsburgh won out. Elevation was good so oceans can get us, and changes is weather systems were predicted to be mild. And no shortage of water…. So far, so good. And not remote boondocks, so I still have access to my beloved Trader Joe’s, etc. 15 yrs later, my kids are grown and I’m free to roam around. Maybe I will.
kellsdeep@reddit
That's the difference between you and I. We were actively seeking boondocks
Famous-Flounder4135@reddit
👍
nagel33@reddit
So from one blood red state to one that's worse? K.
kellsdeep@reddit
Not sure what your attitude is about, wherever I live, hopefully it's far away from people that have an issue with my personal decisions for my family... K?
kellsdeep@reddit
There's no hope for Texas, Idaho has a large liberal population despite what is reported. Source: I live here. There are gay pride festivals, community programs, good state insurance that is easily attainable, it's way better than Texas.
Soft_Match_7500@reddit
It is, but I feel resentment for lifelong friends and family who just ignore what I'm telling them and react like I'm crazy.
kellsdeep@reddit
That must suck, I don't really have any friends so there's that.
jsc1429@reddit
I'm in Texas and I believe in climate change. I'm trying to make my exit soon but it's difficult with wife and kids.
Soft_Match_7500@reddit
Got the wife on a board a year or two ago. Just wanted to let the kid finish middle school. He is not on board at all, but we're doing what we can to help him understand
jabblack@reddit
Where are you going to move, Great Lakes?
Soft_Match_7500@reddit
Por supuesto
jsc1429@reddit
I’m having a hard time with the wife, I don’t get how she can’t see how bad it already is and will get here (she’s not on Reddit and really follow any climate news, even though she knows it’s real and happening). The main issues come to family, school, and friends and it’s been a struggle
hysys_whisperer@reddit
Honestly it was Uvalde that really did it for me. Honestly we both mutually agreed that we would have caught a charge for doing whatever we had to to try to get into that school if our kid was inside.
That's when they got on board with moving. We had talked about it in abstract prior to that, but that made it real.
jsc1429@reddit
We had a trip down to the Uvalde river planned the week after it happened and we drove by the school. It was such a surreal experience. I don’t know if you’ve ever walked into a place and just got a “vibe” from it, but just driving by I felt this sense of evil around it. It was crazy….i bring this up and all the other political bs, power issues, escalating heat, water shortages, and the possibility of millions migrating from Houston/coast area and Mexico as a reason to leave but the situation hasn’t gotten “real” enough for her I guess
gobeklitepewasamall@reddit
By the time it gets “real” enough for most, they won’t be able to leave, except as a refugee.
Liquidate real assets at risk (which is a lot down there) and take whatever you can to somewhere safer.
Granted I’m from a small religious minority that’s had to survive by moving instead of fighting, my s/o chides me for it like “your people leave, my people stay and protect our land.”
ReflectionCalm7033@reddit
Nothing should shock me anymore, but watching that unfold, I was screaming at the TV and that useless police chief/sheriff..
hysys_whisperer@reddit
I was shaking mad.
I literally had to leave work when they arrested parents for trying to rush in after seeing dozens of police doing nothing and I know nobody there.
While I am able to think rationally about it now, I was not then, and I know when it happens again, if I am nearby I will do something stupid. So we moved.
maevewolfe@reddit
The anniversary was just the other day. Still makes my blood boil thinking about it.
TheMotherTortoise@reddit
It’s like the whole, HORRIBLE event just went away. I think about those kids and their teachers…and the families…and I have not forgotten. I thought watching George Floyd being murdered was the worst thing I’ve ever seen, and it was horrific, but Ulvalde? And how it all has played out, and the fact that no one talks about it anymore, just like it is forgotten? 😭 Breaks my heart. 💔
Famous-Flounder4135@reddit
Better now than later (probably), only seems to be getting worse. Your wife a kids will be easier to move while they can still get themselves into the vehicle…….. 🥵…..and there’s still some bottled water available for the road trip. 🤞
I_Smell_A_Rat666@reddit
Yes, literally everyone says that here. Also, blue state people never move here and drive up the cost of living for the locals, and Californians in particular should continue to avoid the lower cost of living here as we all live in the Stone Age. By the way, the weather is terrible.
INDO_214@reddit
Correction: everyone in Texas believes that climate change has happened is happening and will continue to happen no matter what the egotistical human believes. The liberal propaganda is the politicians saying we're the CAUSE of the ice melting when the ice age has been over for a couple of centuries. The propaganda is not acknowledging the fact that coastal cities have and will continue to be engulfed by the rising seas. And ignoring the vast amount of underwater skunked civilizations who probably thought they were the final society. The chosen ones 😂
kaoc02@reddit
Are you serious?
Climate change is humand made and proven over and over again. That the ice age is over has nothing to do with the exponentially temperature rise we are witnessing
Just read some science papers lol!
Scientist are telling sience decades that sea levels will rise and coastal regions will be lost but many many more bad things are happening. There is more than just one tipping point.
Your right wing propaganda will put you in a bad position when people start truly suffering. I don't want to be in your position because the shit that will fly towards you and your loved ones will be huge. Read some science papers and less facebook and telegram groups and put yourself into a better position.... at least give it a chance. For your loved ones.
INDO_214@reddit
The shit is gonna fly regardless. It flew for the Romans. It flew for the mayans. It flew for the ancient Egyptians. Who are you to feel like your society should've been permanent? Every society had something to blame. Some blamed the gods, others blamed the stars, now we blame cow farts. In the end it was over consumption and permanent settlement. Humans always used to follow the green pastures. Now they settle and cry when the cycles of drought hit them and they can't do what living things have done for millions of years, move. My right wing propaganda didn't sink all those forgotten civilizations. The Republicans didn't collapse the ancient Mayan agriculture. The green movement was not gonna stop the ice caps from melting. The north pole ice has been shrinking for thousands of years. There used to be a bridge from Russia to Alaska. I promise you that the human campfires didn't start the melting of that water in that land bridge 😅
collapse-ModTeam@reddit
Hi, INDO_214. Thanks for contributing. However, your comment was removed from /r/collapse for:
Please refer to the Climate Claims (https://www.reddit.com/r/collapse/wiki/claims#wiki_climate_claims) section of the guide.
Please refer to our subreddit rules for more information.
You can message the mods if you feel this was in error, please include a link to the comment or post in question.
nagel33@reddit
This is not the same at all.
INDO_214@reddit
Who are you for your society to have been permanent? 😂😂 Out of al the fallen empires?? Down voting this won't cool the earth down either 💦💦
collapse-ModTeam@reddit
Hi, INDO_214. Thanks for contributing. However, your comment was removed from /r/collapse for:
Please refer to the Climate Claims (https://www.reddit.com/r/collapse/wiki/claims#wiki_climate_claims) section of the guide.
Please refer to our subreddit rules for more information.
You can message the mods if you feel this was in error, please include a link to the comment or post in question.
collapse-ModTeam@reddit
Hi, INDO_214. Thanks for contributing. However, your comment was removed from /r/collapse for:
Please refer to the Climate Claims (https://www.reddit.com/r/collapse/wiki/claims#wiki_climate_claims) section of the guide.
Please refer to our subreddit rules for more information.
You can message the mods if you feel this was in error, please include a link to the comment or post in question.
knowledgebass@reddit
Like you have any clue about how any of this works 😂
PolitburoInsider@reddit
GHG’s and science are liberal. All the climate change bullshit can easily be discredited with pseudoscience.
FantasticOutside7@reddit
We’re in an Ice Age 🙄
nagel33@reddit
^ Perfect example of why everyone makes fun of Texans.
PrimaryDurian@reddit
Yes, every single Texan says this. It's part of the oath we all recite every morning before our compulsory daily shoot outs.
DiscombobulatedWavy@reddit
Right before we get on our horses to go to work. We have no paved roads here either.
pajamakitten@reddit
People in the UK think the rain we have had this year is normal for the UK, even when the news has said that September 2022-March 2024 was the wettest 18 months on record. People worldwide ignore facts when they do not back up their opinions or feelings.
TheMotherTortoise@reddit
I live in Texas and believe in climate change. Very much so, because everything has changed since I was a child (lived here all of my life).
I would LOVE to leave and end up in the PNW, but I can’t afford that anymore. My next choices would be Minnesota or Michigan where family is. But that, too, is expensive and requires a lot of planning. I am in my 60s, and will have to sell my home and property to have the funds to move and buy a new place. Completely start over and leave my grown children and grandchildren who are all here in Central Texas. Also, where I am is very, very special to me, and there is no way I can buy what I have somewhere else, if that makes sense.
Anyway, please know there are people in Texas who care, who observe, who know things are changing and would love an opportunity to go someplace else. It’s just not easy to pick up and leave, sometimes. If it were, I would have left in 2017.
flortny@reddit
Some are surely waking up, https://www.theguardian.com/world/article/2024/may/31/texas-storm-snow-hail
Soft_Match_7500@reddit
Not that I've notices, but some hopefully
thesagaconts@reddit
While also saying “y’all notice we’ve had more tornadoes lately.” If you live in or near Houston, you’ve heard this before.
pippopozzato@reddit
DENIAL - Self-Deception, False Beliefs, and the Origins of the Human Mind- AJIT VARKI AND DANNY BROWER is actually a really good book and yeah when humans are confronted with some idea that conflicts with their world view they usually dismiss it.
knowledgebass@reddit
People are dumb and will believe almost anything if it aligns with their motivated reasoning.
bengringo2@reddit
We just had a major sports event happen where a team had diarrhea for two days straight and got destroyed in Mexico just a little ways near Mexico City and people are laughing instead of asking questions (CONCACAF Champions Cup).
Literally a global stage event (FIFA) and nothing on the news.
There’s no hope for Mexico at this point until it’s a crisis.
HulkSmash_HulkRegret@reddit
The closer to uncontrollable yet everyday danger people are, denial tends to be the go to mode. We see it with driving, whatever the exotic weather hazard is in the places it’s common (tornado, hurricane, blizzards, etc, the locals aren’t phased by it), the Covid risk denial that everyone eventually defaulted into us the best example, and of course catastrophic climate change within our lifetime. Same with Ukraine right before the Russian invasion, and Afghanistan right before the Taliban took back power. The pattern is as the unavoidable danger gets closer, the sense of calm about it also increases, then when it arrives people are shocked pikachu
HillSprint@reddit
It depends on how deep you are in the sauce. The tens of millions of Mexicans will continue to try to make things work. I'm not sure who told you it's end of times yet.
The facts are that reservoirs are low, well depths are far extended, water reclamation is mismanaged, and heat is above average there.
Will this wipe out Mexico city? Not soon. Could there be higher and higher water related illness, yes. Could there be mass casualty events from heat waves? Perhaps.
idkmoiname@reddit
How would it? As long as you can buy bottles to drink people won't die in masses, which will lead to increased prices and subsequently more and more pissed off people that will just leave. It's population eventually sinks and that will be it.
Solitude_Intensifies@reddit
Lack of running water will lead to disease outbreaks, could see significant deaths from that alone.
pegaunisusicorn@reddit
Silver lining: No cholera!
Glancing-Thought@reddit
There is also the possibility of focusing on critical water use. Just drinking water and health-care would use much less water than the city does now. Most water is used for industrial processes, stuff like fountains and irrigation of parks/golf-courses, ect. We actually use very little of it for drinking in general.
Decon_SaintJohn@reddit
I predict, at some point there will be a mass exodus of the Mexico City population due to a severe lack of water and other resources, and for economic and political reasons. Guess where they will all be heading to? Hint: it won't be to the south.
Glancing-Thought@reddit
Every time I hear about a "mass exodus" I worry. Those never end well.
SomeonesTreasureGem@reddit
To add to this, Mexico is entering its rainy season so that should help somewhat but the levels are lower than they’ve been in decades so it’s worth noting.
In 2014, São Paulo nearly ran out of water. Schools closed, crops faltered and reservoirs were left at a tiny 5 percent of their capacity for the city and its surrounding population of 22 million. It was the worst drought in eight decades. The dry season of 2018 raised fears of another water crisis.
Water in Mexico is also distributed in such a way that not all areas have continuous access to clean drinking water, especially rural Mexico. Mexico City is far from the canary in the coal mine in Mexico in terms of water accessibility given its geography/proximity to water but the fact it’s the largest metro area in North America as well as such a huge cultural and economic hub for Mexico makes this more headline worthy news.
airhostessnthe60s@reddit
Yes.
Aggravating-Value-79@reddit
Unfortunately, I think the truth is that we may not want to be here for what's next. We think we want to survive it... what kind of human beings are going to be left?
CarefulObligation626@reddit
Denial. Even rich people in affluent neighborhoods won’t understand that you can produce water out of thin air just because you have money until reality hits them hard on day zero and all are equally deprived of water because simply there isn’t any available.
Glancing-Thought@reddit
You can actually truck the water in in the worst case. For drinking water at least. Thus affluence would indeed help. So enough to drink but all the factories would shut down and the crops wither.
canibal_cabin@reddit
But they can buy the last drop and kill the Poor's doing so, it's a win win for them.
astral_cowboy@reddit
It's been slowly coming for years, but it's just making the news. Besides aquifers starting to get depleted, Mexico City has increasingly needed to bring its water from further and further away.
gangstasadvocate@reddit
Yes. I would recommend working with the cartels, making sure your drugs are stocked up. That way if the water gets really low, you’ll have something to trade for it.
astral_cowboy@reddit
I hope this is sarcastic.
PrimaryDurian@reddit
Username checks out
slackboulder@reddit
I drove through Mexico last year and didn't notice a water shortage until I got to Monterrey. That city is in a much worse situation than Mexico City, but no one is talking about it. Most likely, you are in the tourist areas, and they will be the last places they shut off the tap. Mexico City is a very segregated city by wealth, and the central areas are just stealing water from the poorer areas and trucking water. You will see the water trucks all the time.
astral_cowboy@reddit
We (inhabitants of Monterrey) are definitely talking about it. I even posted about it on a weekly collapse thread and IIRC someone even posted an article about it here.
Right now we're mostly OK-ish, but we need a good rainy season to fill up our reservoirs.
srr210@reddit
Part of the Monterrey issue is the increase of nearshoring and other industrial projects and big brewers that consume a lot of water. Some businesses are relocating to Yucatan because of it. Not sure if that’s going to work out so great given the heat in Yucatan.
mrpickles@reddit
I'm starting to think humans are catastrophically stupid. They only seem smarter and more capable than they are. Some of them really are intelligent, capable of invention and higher planning. But the vast majority are more like worker ants, just doing what their biology programmed them to do even if it means death.
AntiHyperbolic@reddit (OP)
There are plenty of documented civilizations that ran out of resources and died off as a result. The Mayan, the Indus River Valley civilization, The Anasazi.
And there’s no doubt that they had knowledge of the oncoming catastrophe, especially in the case of the Mayan. But, ultimately, it’s almost impossible to shift the direction of society.
The ultra wealthy made their money on oil and gas, and continue to do so. They control the governments all over the world, and will never give up the money faucet that they get their extraordinary lives from.
It’s just so agitating that we can’t all accept the oncoming catastrophe and actually do something about it.
We are extraordinarily stupid as a species.
jjconstantine@reddit
Id love to read a story about some modern day superhero who destroys extraction equipment and kills oil executives
ArtisticEntertainer1@reddit
Planetina from Rick and Morty
PoutyParmesan@reddit
Morty was a pussy bitch for ditching her. He's done worse to boot.
jjconstantine@reddit
I haven't watched far enough to have seen that one
andresni@reddit
Here's one (if you can find an English translation): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mengele_Zoo
Although not a hero with superpowers, definitely a hero. A trilogy of 3 books, with the first one being almost exactly what you ask for. Great books!!
Betty_Bookish@reddit
I would read that!
throwawaylurker012@reddit
one of the few things i will say OP is that if you google back far enough, its been a common headline for years that they are in a water crisis
so part of it is low level noise and think relative to other places, not as shocking as it should be esp for this sub
deleted_by_reddit@reddit
[removed]
collapse-ModTeam@reddit
Hi, Forsaken-Ad-1805. Thanks for contributing. However, your comment was removed from /r/collapse for:
Please refer to our subreddit rules for more information.
You can message the mods if you feel this was in error, please include a link to the comment or post in question.
bernpfenn@reddit
you are on to something
lackofabettername123@reddit
Mexico city has an affluvia problem too, generations of sewage in the soil that eats away at building foundations, and when it rains throws up a fine mist of it.
AntiHyperbolic@reddit (OP)
Wow… I’m going to read up on this. This would make sense. I’d assume as the earth compacts due to the aquifer draining, it would exacerbate the situation.
CatchaRainbow@reddit
Mexico City is subsiding at a high rate due to the aquifers being drained.
Nathan-Stubblefield@reddit
What if my town uses lake or river water and has no wells, and it rains a couple of times a week to percolate into the aquifer. Would the ground level gradually rise?
dumnezero@reddit
https://www.wired.com/story/the-ongoing-collapse-of-the-worlds-aquifers/
Curious_A_Crane@reddit
Just a guess, but I suspect the reservoir would get bigger from below and not push out from above.
Gemmerc@reddit
Generally, no. Not even with high pressure pumping. The subsiding process results in compaction of the voids where water was once taking space. Some underground acquifers maintain their structure and percolation can add over time, but then it is a question of rate of percolation vs rate of consumption. In all of these cases, the consumption is orders of magnitude bigger than what natural processes can support and there isn't any political strength to stop the damage because the dependency has become too great.
candleflame3@reddit
So... POO mist?
lackofabettername123@reddit
Yes but it is just when it starts to rain, you know that rain smell when it's landing on dry pavement that everybody loves? It is that but with aerosolized shit particles mixed in.
It is a big problem in many cities like Cairo and ilacross South Asia..
dumnezero@reddit
Pootrichor?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Petrichor
LonnieJaw748@reddit
The smell we love when the rain first hits is called petrichor
lijitimit@reddit
And thus a new word was born... Poo-trichor
MangoMind20@reddit
An excellent poo-manteau
JonathanApple@reddit
Poo water.....ewwwwwww
rlaw1234qq@reddit
Eau de Colon
DiscombobulatedWavy@reddit
By Cristobal
PrimaryDurian@reddit
*effluvia
Why is there sewage in the soil?
lackofabettername123@reddit
Not having proper septic systems. It will eat away at concrete.
I am pretty sure where I read it was spelled with an a, in a book that covered five cities years back, but I do not doubt it is also spelled with an E amongst other groups.
TheKindestGuyEver@reddit
Yes
Historical data of the water levels prove it. The U.N has stated they have until 2028. But as we are all learning in this community it's going to happen faster than excepted.
Absolute-Nobody0079@reddit
I am an Asian immigrant and I am seriously considering moving out of California. I'd love to move to the midwest, but not sure which part of the region will welcome a guy like me.
badmintonGOD@reddit
Chicago
Absolute-Nobody0079@reddit
umm...no. somewhere closer to nature.
Maybe I should try PNW instead...
badmintonGOD@reddit
PNW is full of crime and homelessness, you can go visit Seattle subreddit to see for yourself.
Absolute-Nobody0079@reddit
I am thinking about Salem OR.
Classic-Today-4367@reddit
I'm in Asia. Work with mainly local staff but recently added a few expats from different countries.
One guy is from Barcelona (Spain), which is apparently also in a water crisis. He has been back twice in the past 6 months and thinks' I'm crazy when I ask him about the water restrictions.
I guess part of it is that he is happy to be back home and isn't taking notice of things. But our other colleague from a different part of Spain says his brother had been traveling around the country and the water crisis was in full evidence in several parts, including Barcelona.
I guess people only see what they want to see.
p3n3tr4t0r@reddit
Soy de México wey, si es real. Actually the city has run out of water for a while. The biggest problem is now there's no more water in Estado de México neither Michoacán (Presa Del bosque in Zitacuaro), so it's even worse, Michoacan doesn't have a border with CDMX and they sucked the water from that far away. That city has been at the border of hydric collapse for a couple of decades now.
Hairy_Bloated_Toad@reddit
Well I could full of crap
Vegetaman916@reddit
I originally commented in response to someone making a statement about "privileged" people destroying everything by going to distant locations to study local effects of climate change. What I said was:
"People can travel without being "privileged," lol. Often, it is a necessary thing. And in the case of OP, going to see for yourself is about the best action you can take. In fact, going to see for yourself was once the only action you could take. It's called exploring the world, and it is a much more worthy thing to do than sit around at home stuffing yourself with Big Macs and going to work at Raytheon to make "environmentally friendly" missiles.
Traveling somewhere to find the truth of a situation and to research the reality on the ground is a good thing. OP is "contributing" to our collective knowledge and preparation for collapse, and these days there can be no better contribution.
I'm actually planning a long-term backpacking trip through the Joshua Tree national forest later this fall, just to see some things for myself regarding changing climate effects, drought, and damage from fires. Having done this before several times, it is actually useful for my own research to get out and physically see the world, not just read about someone else's opinion on it.
It's also nice to disconnect from society and the internet for a few weeks, lol."
There was a reply that was then blocked from further replies, necessitating me to repost this entire thing in this format. So, to continue...
This is in response to the reply by u/xXXxRMxXXx, which they have blocked from replies.
You said:
"So if you can't beat them, join them in their endless escapades to see the world that could have been seen from a TV or computer screen? Almost no one flying around the planet is doing it for the greater good, or even a good reason. I would argue staying in your area most of your life, experiencing your own community, and limiting long distance travel is the more worthy thing to do."
My response:
You definitely need to touch some grass if you think seeing the outside world is better via an electronic screen, my friend.
Every child should get to see the redwoods. They should all get to walk in the surf of the ocean, and run their fingers through hot desert sands, and catch wild tundra snowflakes on their tongues. Towering mountain cliffs and wide open flat savanna grasslands and all the wonders of the natural world should be accessible to all.
You don't have to be ridiculous and fly there. People were traveling across the widest oceans with only the power of sail long before we discovered the burning of fossil fuels. Nomads in the desert would walk hundreds and thousands of miles. Humans have always traveled.
The problem is too many humans, trying to do everything too fast. And modern civilization with its requirement that one work and slave for a living is to blame for that. We don't have enough time, because all of our time is stolen by work.
Not me, though. I chose a different path, and wish I had chosen it sooner. And btw, when I go to Joshua tree, as in the past, it will be with a mountain bike and a backpack. That is the whole point.
We here in this sub even talk shit about people going out to the Caribbean on vacation, but I can and have sailed out there on a very old Island Packet 40 foot sailboat that didn't even have an iron genoa. You can travel without destroying the world. People just choose not to.
And again, it comes back to the main problem. Too many people.
xXXxRMxXXx@reddit
Very cringe reply, I said to experience your own community first and foremost. "Every child should experience all of these things" is literally a first world problem. Children are dying in their homes from the heat due to human greed, not even able to experience their own cities, states, countries, etc. Once you come across knowledge it should change you. I'm not even arguing this, I'm just stating this as the fact it is.
Vegetaman916@reddit
Very cringe to say cringe, lol.
What you said is quoted exactly, except for the original comment which you conveniently deleted so people wouldn't see it. That one was basically a diatribe against people traveling to research climate related collapse issues, such as the water situation in Mexico City.
dovercliff@reddit
That's enough. This is heading into the area where we have to slap both of you for being nasty to one another.
dovercliff@reddit
That's enough. This is heading into the area where we have to slap both of you for being nasty to one another.
No, that was another user, not /u/Vegetaman916, and I was the one who removed it for breaching Rule 1.
imreloadin@reddit
It's all election conspiracy until water no longer flows from the tap.
hasanchez@reddit
They even have a website where you can find out the water supply schedule for your neighborhood. https://aguaentucolonia.sacmex.cdmx.gob.mx/#/home
I only checked a couple but it seems most of the city is on a very limited schedule.
HollyJolly999@reddit
What? Of course it’s real, this is wild. You trying to make yourself feel better by inventing a conspiracy to let you off the hook for traveling and using a scarce resource being redirected from locals is absolutely insane.
Vegetaman916@reddit
People can travel without being "privileged," lol. Often, it is a necessary thing. And in the case of OP, going to see for yourself is about the best action you can take. In fact, going to see for yourself was once the only action you could take. It's called exploring the world, and it is a much more worthy thing to do than sit around at home stuffing yourself with Big Macs and going to work at Raytheon to make "environmentally friendly" missiles.
Traveling somewhere to find the truth of a situation and to research the reality on the ground is a good thing. OP is "contributing" to our collective knowledge and preparation for collapse, and these days there can be no better contribution.
I'm actually planning a long-term backpacking trip through the Joshua Tree national forest later this fall, just to see some things for myself regarding changing climate effects, drought, and damage from fires. Having done this before several times, it is actually useful for my own research to get out and physically see the world, not just read about someone else's opinion on it.
It's also nice to disconnect from society and the internet for a few weeks, lol.
xXXxRMxXXx@reddit
So if you can't beat them, join them in their endless escapades to see the world that could have been seen from a TV or computer screen? Almost no one flying around the planet is doing it for the greater good, or even a good reason. I would argue staying in your area most of your life, experiencing your own community, and limiting long distance travel is the more worthy thing to do.
deleted_by_reddit@reddit
[removed]
collapse-ModTeam@reddit
Hi, SolidStranger13. Thanks for contributing. However, your comment was removed from /r/collapse for:
Please refer to our subreddit rules for more information.
You can message the mods if you feel this was in error, please include a link to the comment or post in question.
winston_obrien@reddit
Joshua tree is stunning. It’s kind of like going to another planet.
veinss@reddit
Uhm we know we have a water crisis, since like the 80s. Obviously its real. Every scientist knows, projects to deal with it are underway
Idk what you're reacting to. I haven't seen much if any fearmongering about water
Spascucci@reddit
Teh City Will not completely run out of water however some áreas Will experiencedñ rationing as the Cutzamala system that provides about 20% of the city water supply Is running dry
Helpful-Special-7111@reddit
As a species we won’t accept the reality until it is our reality, hence why we refuse to change until It’s too late.
shes_the_won@reddit
It's the matrix
Deadlyjuju@reddit
Every time someone says this I get a chuckle, because I drive a beat up old Toyota matrix.
FutureTA@reddit
Yes, it’s very real. There’s been a lot of covers for about the water crisis in the Mexican media. It’s been happening for years but has gotten more severe recently.
knowledgebass@reddit
No, all the stories in the NYT about it have been fake. 🙄
preciouschild@reddit
However many people you're talking to, it's an miniscule portion of the giant population of the megacity.
AntiHyperbolic@reddit (OP)
It is a terrible sample set, agreed. Just found it wild that it’s seemingly not in their top 10 concerns.
squailtaint@reddit
Mexico City is under a warning, not a water crisis. It’s not a crisis, yet. That’s the thing, until it actually happens, people won’t care or won’t believe it. And it may not happen, if they get the rain it’s all good. Just like California last year was in dire straights, but lo and behold, they got enough precipitation in time. Warnings fall on deaf ears, especially when people are warned time and time again and those warnings don’t come to fruition. It’s an interesting social phenom. Even look at Ukraine. There were people the day of the start of the war being interviewed saying they don’t believe Russia would do something so stupid, even though all the warnings were there. It wasn’t until it actually happened, that people started to believe and understand that it is and can happen.
MavinMarv@reddit
The Ukraine invasion really woke up the masses that people need to start paying attention to world events. Then the Israel-Gaza war popped off. Now everyone is looking at the China-Taiwan situation.
daveintex13@reddit
If people are warned to conserve and actually do conserve, but no crisis arises, then warnings lose their effectiveness and are eventually ignored. Since people demand to learn the hard way, let us hope the crisis that arises is minor and only affects other people.
sjb0387@reddit
No
DavidG-LA@reddit
Most likely you are in the more affluent (and effluent) parts of the city. Are you asking people in English or Spanish? Talk to people on the outskirts. There are neighborhoods where water has always been limited or even trucked in.
uninhabited@reddit
This plus a sense of pride/embarrassment. Why unload on a nosey gringo who could be tiktoking their misery. That said equally likely they're in denial
xXXxRMxXXx@reddit
To think a tourist might have been asking people (who depend on tourism for money) if the area was going to collapse soon.... The answer would be no from every one of them LOL
beepewpew@reddit
You being a privileged traveler going to places that are known to be the location of impending shortages just makes life harder for the people who live there to manage a crisis. If you aren't contributing anything beyond your own selfish tourism then yeah you are an asshole for prioritizing your good time travels over the safety and needs of people who can't afford to even move.
lurkingandstuff@reddit
This isn’t r/AITA but ok… lmao.
AntiHyperbolic@reddit (OP)
Also, I’m well aware of the opinion of this sub and me traveling to Mexico City during this time. I’ve already caught the flack, this is not new news to me!
Ultimately, I find it bewildering that no one here seems to think there’s a problem. Is this a “don’t look up” scenario, or is the country installing mitigating strategies? That’s really what want to know, not whether or not I’m an asshole. Of course I am, I am an American who is routinely exploiting the poorest of the poor across the world by simply existing as an American. Me coming here isn’t making me much worse than I already am.
shes_the_won@reddit
I saw a clip recently of a reporter interviewing the President who flatly denied there is a problem.
If you think about it, this is probably the only public policy response that makes sense at this point.
Imagine if he said there's a water shortage in months. The only way people respond is to hoard water that would then create a water shortage. There isn't one now. There's nothing they can do about it if there is. Ergo, its business as usual.
There's also probably a bit of the Latino mindset of "You worry too much."
beepewpew@reddit
It's also not r/conspiracy but the title is asking if the water crisis in Mexico is real so here we are.
lurkingandstuff@reddit
I don’t disagree. I just thought it was funny how you ignored the actual question asked and just answered as if this was posted in that sub.
Idk maybe it’s not that funny…
triple-bottom-line@reddit
Dump her, hit the gym
mistyflame94@reddit
Rule 1: In addition to enforcing Reddit's content policy, we will also remove comments and content that is abusive or predatory in nature. You may attack each other's ideas, not each other.
FullOfHimself@reddit
Such a douchy response. Judging the guy for traveling to see the world before the end, as if we're not all doomed anyway. How dare he travel! How dare I use Chat GPT because of how much electricity it uses! How dare I drive to work while 90% of the world has to take a bus or public transit!
Travel all you want.
This isn't about judgement, it is about whether it's possible Mexico City's water crisis is as real as we post about in our doomer sub, or if it's possibly conspiracy.