TheaterFire

"Not just rebadging": How Stellantis plans to make its brands distinct despite shared tech

Posted by V8-Turbo-Hybrid@reddit | cars | View on Reddit | 69 comments

Future models from the 14 brands that make up the Stellantis empire will be more differentiated, despite the increasing use of common platforms and technology, according to its European boss.

Reply to Post

69 Comments

varzatv@reddit

Stellantis - a Frankenstein of mostly crap brands that weren't viable on their own - stitched together to make it easier for corporate to rip more costs out and try to make everything viable. In other words - a pile of nostalgia and turds - even before the emergence of Chinese brands ravaging the automotive market like termites. Anyone betting on them lasting at all let alone in Australia is kidding themselves.
View on Reddit #97601875

_larsr@reddit

Please, for the love of all things holy, make a vehicle that is actually reliable.
View on Reddit #87590985

Pliskin_Hayter@reddit

Theyre gone now but the Charger and Challenger were objectively extremely reliable vehicles.
View on Reddit #87774656

leedle1234@reddit

Are the French cars not reliable?
View on Reddit #87631241

zeissikon@reddit

Peugeots were Ok until the early 2010s , Citroëns a little less so. But the Puretech was a disaster . In the fifties sixties and early seventies Peugeot were primitive but indestructible but then they introduced pre rusted steel. The situation was better in the eighties and nineties, except for the suspensions, wheel bearings transmission joints and plastics , or some small issues, but it was not a big deal even if the cars often broke down : it was cheap to repair. The cars got much better in the late nineties but the electronics give up after 15/20 years and there are no spare parts . Due to pollution laws the engines became catastrophic after 2010 or so . For Citroen it was always worse due to hydraulics complications and lighter cars (even if the performance and styling were marginally better ).
View on Reddit #87696675

Round_Ad_6369@reddit

No >:(
View on Reddit #87592148

FeemBleem@reddit

Stellantis is going to kill a brand before they make a reliable car.
View on Reddit #87639824

DoubleFudge101@reddit

Never!!!!
View on Reddit #87606811

zeissikon@reddit

They have a reputation to maintain for god’s sake ! Customers would be lost !
View on Reddit #87604330

RiftHunter4@reddit

Ironically, I feel like rebadging might help with this. Focus on a few select products so everyone gets them right.
View on Reddit #87595735

DJBscout@reddit

Okay, maybe I'm missing something here. But if everything is built on the exact same platform, how are they avoiding the different brands just being badge engineering? "Diversifying - really diversifying - the models and line-up and not just rebadging. So you will have the new Peugeot first and after that you're have a new Vauxhall that is not a rebadged Peugeot, then an Alfa Romeo, a Jeep or whatever." So you claim they'll "really be different, for reals!!," then don't explain how, and immediately described the different brands/badges with ZERO explanation of what sets them apart besides "trust me bro it's not just rebadged." I'll be interested to see how they do this, but so far it's nothing but a claim, not even a concrete plan from what I can tell.
View on Reddit #87603973

desf15@reddit

"Platform" in modern times, usually means that it's fully scalable and modular. It's not "platform" as we understood it in 90s. When you drive Audi TT and Skoda Superb you never really think "jeez, these cars are almost identical because they're both on MQB platform".
View on Reddit #87613639

DJBscout@reddit

Interesting, I guess I'm out of the loop. I wonder how it actually saves money if it's so variable, but clearly I have some reading to do. Any suggestions?
View on Reddit #87749848

desf15@reddit

Don’t have anything to recommend. But from my limited understanding modular platform is much more expensive to develop than “old school platform”, but its strength is in fact that you can build not one but 10 models out of it, so r&d costs of each model is lower overall.
View on Reddit #87750305

SF_Bubbles_90@reddit

Bring back Plymouth!
View on Reddit #87718744

MassLuca007@reddit

Can't wait for the Crystler version of the Luce
View on Reddit #87714732

throwawayainteasy@reddit

>So you will have the new Peugeot first and after that you’re have a new Vauxhall that is not a rebadged Peugeot, then an Alfa Romeo, a Jeep or whatever. "Or whatever" really sells that they're taking this seriously and genuinely want to treat each of their brands with respect. Seriously, does no senior exec take any basic media training anymore?
View on Reddit #87587606

BeautifulCuriousLiar@reddit

the only one that comes to mind is the ceo of take-two interactive, the company that makes the gta games. he recently gave an interview and actually speaks like a normal human being.
View on Reddit #87606822

ManufacturerBest2758@reddit

Rockstar makes GTA, not Take Two. Take Two is a holding company that owns Rockstar and some other game studios.
View on Reddit #87667811

cookingboy@reddit

The funny thing is that statement would be perfectly fine if they replaced the word whatever with anything. Like..literally the word "anything": > that you’re have a new Vauxhall that is not a rebadged Peugeot, then an Alfa Romeo, a Jeep or whatever. Fuck I should have gone into corporate PR lmao. This shit is too easy.
View on Reddit #87593924

JK_Chan@reddit

Having to think through every single word you say is so damn tiring and stupid and I could never
View on Reddit #87609890

aembleton@reddit

English isn't Emanuel's first language either
View on Reddit #87597629

cookingboy@reddit

That puts it into context and makes this look a lot less bad actually. I would probably make a fuck ton of mistakes if I try to give an interview in Japanese too, a language that I'm conversational at but definitely not a master of.
View on Reddit #87599818

Secure-Side-3835@reddit

Whatever, I don't give a shit. I am getting paid and just waiting for my golden parachute.
View on Reddit #87591346

tiagojpg@reddit

CEOs and aspiring executives have a signed portrait of Carlos Tavares on their bedroom wall. One day, their wish is to receive a 20 million € payout, after leaving a company in the reliability dirt, thousands of people with chewed up engine belts with debt BUT insanely padded investors pockets.
View on Reddit #87598455

neanderthalensis@reddit

Can an American PU firm please acquire Jeep/Dodge/Chrysler/Ram so we can get them out of the hands of the French?
View on Reddit #87590690

Drzhivago138@reddit

When has a private equity acquisition made anything better?
View on Reddit #87620130

neanderthalensis@reddit

That’s the point. Jeep would be in better hands even under American PE ownership than the French.
View on Reddit #87657867

Drzhivago138@reddit

That didn't answer my question...
View on Reddit #87658875

neanderthalensis@reddit

You’re struggling with the word “even.” I’m not saying PE is great; I’m saying Stellantis has been so bad for these brands that even American PE would be preferable.
View on Reddit #87659419

alfredadamski@reddit

Cerberus did this back in 2007, when Mercedes-Benz/Daimler offloaded the Chrysler group. And the first thing Cerberus did? Hire Bob Nardelli as a CEO, the guy so incompetent to run Home Depot that Home Depot paid him 210 million USD to make him go away and who had experience in the automotive world. Jeep and RAM are the "crown jewels" of Stellantis brand portfolio. Those brands bring in the bacon when most other brands of their other brands don't do.
View on Reddit #87594890

flatpetey@reddit

I'll say this again - prove you can make one hit vehicle before you launch 70. Because I don't think Stellantis can do it.
View on Reddit #87653593

sf400m@reddit

After 15 years in Automotive management and lifetime car enthusiast, I can only be surprised how Stellantis haven't yet failed having so many brands in portfolio and how historically incompetent FIAT management haven't yet turned whole lot of brands into "British Leyland" disaster fallout. My opinion, best way - to act like VW, Audi and Porsche do: use common corporate processes like purchasing, logistics and possibly some R&D tools. Make sure all brands have common financial control but at the same time make them completeley independent for marketing and product so separate teams would compete in doing the best product possible. In the end, customers are not that stupid to understand that e-C3, Grande Panda and Frontera is essentially same car. And they will buy it depending on how good the product generally is, not because of which brand it represents.
View on Reddit #87600485

KentuckyFriedChingon@reddit

> In the end, customers are not that stupid to understand that e-C3, Grande Panda and Frontera is essentially same car. Not the same demographic, but there is a double digit percentage of people who either A) Believe that "Lexus" is a model of Toyota (e.g. "Bill drives a Toyota Lexus") Or B) Have no idea that Toyota and Lexus are related in any form
View on Reddit #87646309

linkheroz@reddit

Why not just make less shitty cars?
View on Reddit #87609779

UmaThurmish@reddit

tough ask for Stellantis
View on Reddit #87623774

holchansg@reddit

Look how they macerated my boy Alfa. Dayum. And it is not as if they recently launched banger after banger, 4C, Giulia...
View on Reddit #87588358

bauhausy@reddit

>banger after banger, 4C, Giulia Was there a third banger after those two?
View on Reddit #87592233

holchansg@reddit

33 Stradale, 2024.
View on Reddit #87592799

bauhausy@reddit

That's 33 units of a Maserati MC20 were dressed up by Carrozzeria Touring. Nothing Alfa Romeo about it other than the badge.
View on Reddit #87593211

SolShadows@reddit

Actually fun fact, the MC20 originally started development as an Alfa Romeo project before they moved development over to Maserati at a certain point. There's probably more Alfa Romeo about it than you think.
View on Reddit #87623528

holchansg@reddit

And the design.
View on Reddit #87593861

bauhausy@reddit

Oh I thought it was about the cars in general, specifically those developed in-house. Alfa Romeo has a great design language, imo the best of the mainstream Euro Stellantis. The Stelvio and Tonale are quite handsome for a SUV and CUV. And while I don't love the grill shield on the Veloce-spec Junior, it's better looking than its siblings 2008/Mokka/DS 3. The Stradale is beautiful, but I think the Maserati donor car is gorgeous.
View on Reddit #87594536

_Spare_15_@reddit

I still see a lot of Stelvios, but Stellantis has killed of their "large" platform, so ciao to the Giulia and the Stelvio.
View on Reddit #87599594

bauhausy@reddit

STLA Large hasn't been killed (it's basically brand new), it's Giorgio that's getting sunsetted. They announced that both the next-gen Stelvio and Giulia are moving to that platform a couple weeks ago.
View on Reddit #87600070

_Spare_15_@reddit

The STLA large was mentioned 0 times at their recent investor day and their already designed Stelvio is without a date of arrival, probably due to the Charger bombing. Their focus on Alfa Romeo now is only on STLA One. https://www.carexpert.com.au/car-news/alfa-romeo-getting-more-fresh-models-but-timing-still-unconfirmed-for-next-giulia-and-stelvio
View on Reddit #87601124

alfredadamski@reddit

The Alfa Romeo Junior is currently the only Alfa model that is somewhat selling in meaningful numbers. The Giulia and Stelvio sell in so low numbers that they had to pause/interrupt the production in the plant where both are built next to the Maserati Grecale (which is just a rebodied Stelvio) earlier in this year. Alfa Romeo cannot compete with Mercedes, BMW and Audi, because those three brands not only have a much larger product portfolio, filled with SUVs, sedans/limousine and stationwagons (which is a German thing, they just love their stationwagons, even if they do not need the space, that's why the German brands created the term "lifestyle stationwagon"), but are also ruling the company car segment. The three "premium" German brands natural habitat is the company car segment. If you simple take the domestic market: 2/3 of all new cars in Germany cars are sold as company cars, only 1/3 are to private households/customers. Just ask any non-German premium brand, how hard it is to break into the German company car segment. Stellantis just keeps Opel, because it is still perceived by a lot of people as a German brand and somewhat lots of companies give Opel cars to their employees as a company cars, even if it is not a "premium" brand, but not employee has the pay-level to get an BMW, Mercedes, Audi. Lots of sales reps and technicians get Opel Astra station wagons as company cars that they also use after work. If you want to gain sales, you need to break into the company car sales. The only reason to keep the Opel brand. The same applies to its UK sister brand "Vauxhall", which are just rebadged Opels. Alfa Romeo and all other "import brands" had never any grip to the company car segment. That's why the Giulia and Stelvio did not sell in any meaningfull number. And any future Alfa Romeo will face the same fate. The enthusiast private buyers are not material when it comes to sales. That's what people simply do not understand. That's why it was rubbish to simply claim: "All what Alfa Romeo needs to do is, build a RWD sporty sedan/limousine, then everybody will switch from their BMWs, MBs and Audis to Alfa Romeo." That's not how the segment works. And "recently" is really an "understatement". Alfa Romeo is the most understood brand out there. Everybody thinks of them as the "Italian BMW". Alfa Romeo was bought by Fiat back 1986 and they have not managed to turn it into an serious contender for the German premium brands. Back in the 1990s Alfa Romeo had its peak with around 200.000 sold cars (over all models) p.a. If you want to meaningful sales, you need many, many Alfa Romeo models, especially ones that enthusiast do not like: Many SUVs and and all the other car types that people buy in meaningful numbers. A 4C is really nice, but does really nothing for the sales volume. But even before the takeover of AR by Fiat, AR was everything but successfull. As I said, it is the most misunderstood brand out there. People want the brand to exist, but stick to their BMWs, Audis and MBs when it comes to talk with their money. You cannot sustain a brand with just "enthusiasts".
View on Reddit #87592260

Dan6erbond2@reddit

I fully agree with your conclusions but not quite a part of your reasoning which is company cars. They're very much a German thing and not even that applicable to my country, Switzerland, let alone the US which is a big playing field for car brands. In general, though, these days people simply are just buying more SUVs than anything else. Hence why the Junior makes sense and Alfa needs to expand their model and engine offerings because the Giulia/Stelvio 2.0T and QV are great driver's cars but if you want to appeal to the masses you need to add hybrid, EV options as well.
View on Reddit #87608524

ulikescience@reddit

Yeah, wonderful point about corporate sales. Alfa Romeo is (perceived at least) a niche enthusiast brand. The real question is will a global public company embrace that or change the brand to chase sales. That being said, in America, the dealer network would also have to improve dramatically to be successful no matter how the brand moves forward.
View on Reddit #87607051

sf400m@reddit

Seems like you are deep into automotive industry. But I wouldn't drop Alfa's brand perception as a sporty car for driver, a car for an enthusiast, down the drain so easily. I think, Stellantis should have used this image, and actually from what I see, they are trying to use it design-wise. I am a product guy in automotive, and I firmly stand on that it would be enough for Alfa to have B-SUV, C-SUV, D-SUV, Sedan / Wagon and a small B-Hatch and it would be ok for volumes. It's just thta the PRODUCT should be good. Cars should be reliable, should handle well, should sound great, look great and be on par with competitors efficiency on engine side. Eg, 5L/100 km with Mild Hybdid ICE. Bob Lutz wrote simple but informative "bible for product guys" once: [https://www.amazon.com.tr/Car-Guys-vs-Bean-Counters/dp/1591846226](https://www.amazon.com.tr/Car-Guys-vs-Bean-Counters/dp/1591846226) Really recommend it
View on Reddit #87599852

Shmokesshweed@reddit

Recently? 😉
View on Reddit #87588451

Bombstar10@reddit

Honestly, the Junior is pretty good, in the ‘economy platform’ way that is the reality of most of Alfas history lol. No way it would work in NA of course.
View on Reddit #87589810

Dan6erbond2@reddit

We love our Junior*. It's the perfect city car and dirt cheap to run since we have the Elettrica, but I have friends with the Ibrida and even they say it's very efficient. The interior is plenty premium for the money, still a non-dominant screen that's driver-facing, which is something too few brands do. The steering wheel feels nice to hold and the seats are comfortable. The biggest thing, though, is the way it drives. It's genuinely quite fun for what it is and handles corners very well with good tires. It's front-wheel drive but the LSD makes it tossable. *I, however, could never buy a Veloce with nearly the same interior for double the price. Alfa needs to get it through their skulls that that kind of a bump requires a more upmarket feel to the car not just slightly more power and different seats.
View on Reddit #87608213

slide2k@reddit

They are beautiful, but they aren’t a banger business wise. A Gulia asks German premium money where I live and doesn’t offer a wagon. You can guess what people rather buy
View on Reddit #87595455

salvibalvi@reddit

Not to mention that they still don't offer a hybrid version, which is a huge downer in many countries.
View on Reddit #87605579

AutoModerator@reddit

*Giulia *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/cars) if you have any questions or concerns.*
View on Reddit #87595456

zeissikon@reddit

The Giulia is beautiful and drives well, and Alfas are actually reliable (I had three of them for three years each , no issues ). However nowadays Giulas are extremely expensive, use a lot of gasoline or diesel, and are very backwards in infotainment or assistance systems ; I could not justify a buy . The leather seats are almost of the quality of Ferrari however.
View on Reddit #87604473

Drzhivago138@reddit

Just do *something*.
View on Reddit #87620072

Wykydtr0m@reddit

They're already distinctly shitty
View on Reddit #87619035

SuperToll9000@reddit

Can’t wait for the Alfa x UFC Ultimate Patriot Edition
View on Reddit #87614855

nyclurker369@reddit

Just another reason to avoid purchasing a Stellantis vehicle. There are far too many other manufacturers who actually care about their products and customers. Spend your money wisely.
View on Reddit #87606582

ShaolinTrapLord@reddit

Smh, good luck.
View on Reddit #87603302

mr_beanoz@reddit

Would this be like how Volkswagen or GM position their brands?
View on Reddit #87591113

leedle1234@reddit

That's already what the French part of Stellantis has been doing. Citroen, Peugeot, the invented DS brand, and Opel/Vauxhall got roped into it, are all lined up trying to do a VW-esque thing. Peugeot is the flagship (VW), Citroen is the mildly quirky value brand (Skoda), DS is trying to be Audi, and Opel isn't really SEAT though, more like the "make this french car feel more german" brand. I don't understand how this is supposed to mesh with Fiat, Alfa, Jeep, etc though. You just end trying to serve too many niches. Only way is to region lock brands at that point.
View on Reddit #87591982

bauhausy@reddit

Fiat is sharing more with Citroen than Peugeot, being a quirky budget brand but Italian: the Panda is a C3 instead of the fancier 208, which instead became the Lancia Ypsilon. So until now it seemed Stellantis was going to treat Fiat as an Italian Citroen and Lancia as an Italian Peugeot (the just announced Lancia Gamma visibly being a 3008). Maybe the plan is to repeat this French <-> Italian dynamic with DS and Alfa Romeo? By naming Fiat as the core brand it seems they let them led the budget-focused development (Fiat does have a whole lineup of budget cars developed and sold only in LATAM after all) and Citroen will take a back seat in the future. Opel/Vauxhall is in a odd spot, as it gets both the "nicer" Peugeots to rebadge into something more stoic and conservative, and stuff like the Frontera and Rocks which are budget stuff from Citroen. Seems with them the strategy is just make what the French did, but extra boring with no flair. I don't know what the heck is going to happen with Maserati in the future because there's no one for them to "share".
View on Reddit #87593003

mr_beanoz@reddit

Maybe Alfa could be the Audi (premium priced with extra features), and Fiat could be the Peugeot.
View on Reddit #87592078

Combat_Wombat23@reddit

lol, lmao even. I don’t believe them and I won’t until they actually make something
View on Reddit #87590576

drseruzawa@reddit

Well, they got to overcome the problem with the shit quality of their products. Who cares if it's different if it's in the shop all the time?
View on Reddit #87590110

Drifty_Canadian@reddit

It will be interesting to see. Someone's gotta clean up the burning shit filled dumpster fire Tavares left.
View on Reddit #87586803